HOME > Chowhound > New York State (exc. NYC) >

Discussion

Whole rib-cap (spinalis dorsi) from Fred the Butcher, Half Moon

  • 7

Fred the Butcher had on hand some whole rib-eye roasts with substantial caps, the spinalis dorsi muscle that is the most flavorful beefsteak of all, usually just eaten as the tastier edge of a ribeye. Fred's is a full-service butcher, so they were perfectly willing to sell me the whole roast at the whole-roast price of $8.99/lb, and then peel off the cap. (The cap by itself would be three or four times that much, easy.) We grilled it over hickory charcoal last night, and it was just perfect, and grilled up without any shrinkage. We were two, but the cap would have easily served four. Leftovers are in the fridge.

The small end of the roast I took as a two-lb roast, and the rest of it, the four-ribs-worth that was formerly covered by the cap, I asked the Fred's to slice into sandwich steaks, which ought to make the best cheesesteaks a person could make; I took home six 3/4-lb packages of sandwich steaks wrapped for the freezer. So I got

One amazing rib-cap, about two pounds, maybe a little more.
One two-and-a-half-lb ribeye roast.
Six 3/4-lb sandwich steaks.

The whole thing came to about $150. A bargain, considering how much meat I took home, and my $8.99/lb rib-cap made the most delicious dinner I've cooked (or eaten) in a long time. The butchers at Fred the Butcher enjoyed the project, and would be happy, I'm sure, to repeat it for you. A fabulous store, if you don't know it.

    Image Title (Optional)
    Caption (Optional)
    Image Credit (Optional)
    Copy to all
  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
Delete
    1. re: phofiend

      Half Moon, New York, on Rt. 9, near Groom's Rd. Here's the website: http://fredthebutcher.com/ .

    2. Confused about the price; sounds like you got roughly 10 pounds of meat-- at $9 a pound, how is that $150?

      1 Reply
      1. re: DGresh

        Must have been more than 10 lbs (I don't have weights on the roast or the rib-cap, just guessing), and some amount was lost to trimming. They charge 8.99 for the weight of the full roast, then trim. You can see that the rib-cap was trimmed pretty closely.

      2. Wait so the title is misleading. He didn't just sell you the spinalis dorsi. He took it off of the entire roast that you had already bought.

        2 Replies
        1. re: pabboy

          Not sure what your problem is; this was my idea, not the store's. They were just kind enough to accommodate me, and enjoyed the project. They would have been happy to sell me the rib-cap by itself at around $25/lb, so maybe somewhere south of $75, but for about twice that, I bought all seven ribs of the ribeye roast, cut into a rib-cap, a ribeye heart roast, and a lot of sandwich steaks. What's misleading? Seems to me full disclosure all around.

          1. re: PSZaas

            No problem. Just misleading title.