Psst... We're working on the next generation of Chowhound! View >
HOME > Chowhound > Kosher >
Jun 15, 2014 09:27 PM

Found: Best kosher pizza in Brooklyn

We went to Pizza by the Bay on Jerome avenue. Does not say Kosher on the outside and its a very small store so easy to miss, although there is a car park really close by. The pizza was fantastic- easily best pizza in brooklyn and probably in the whole NYC area. Also, the french fries- omg the fries.. Home-made, home cut and proper belgian frites- a perfect crisp to them and beautifully seasoned with a salt/ paprika mix. They also do make your own salads, mozarella sticks etc. Highly recommend.

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. who certifies that it's kosher?

    16 Replies
    1. re: zsero

      EDIT: looking at the wrong PIZZA by the Bay restaurant

      1. re: follick

        Menu looks kosher friendly. Google search results have many listing them as kosher. Appears to be chof-k

          1. re: follick

            That is for downtown Mumbai, not Brooklyn USA!

            1. re: MartyB

              Yes, my mistake and my apologies. I have edited my post above.

              1. re: follick

                the link to the place in Mumbai is still there

      2. re: zsero

        I called the restaurant. The employee who answered the phone stated that the restaurant is kosher, and under the supervision of Rabbi David Navarro.

        1. re: bigredesq

          I knew that it sounded too good to be true.
          for whatever it's worth, the cRc in Chicago does not recommend that certification.
          Oh well, what the second best pizza shop in Brooklyn?

          1. re: chicago maven

            I'm confused. Is it Kof-K as the menu MartyB linked to, is it a really Rabbi David Navarro, or was the employee messing with bigredesq by giving smicha to the guitarist from Jane's Addiction?

            1. re: elmoz

              I emailed the Kof-K and got a reply:

              Unauthorized use of your symbol?

              Yes it was and I spoke to the owner who said this error was made over a year ago and he is correcting it on this web site now. Thank you for bringing this to my attention.

              Rabbi Yehuda Rosenbaum
              KOF-K Kosher Supervision
              201 837 0500 x7
              201 491 4610 cell

              1. re: elmoz

                Yeah. I saw that and thought, coincidence or second career?

                1. re: elmoz

                  There really is a Rabbi David Navarro, of Staten Island, and R Reuven Feinstein says he's reliable.

                2. re: chicago maven

                  Oh no! I was going to have knishes as a side for dinner tonight when I noticed that Gabila's knishes have the chof-k hashgacha. I bought it from Costco but could have sworn that Brach's also sold these knishes. One of the nice things about shopping at places like Brachs, Gourmet Glatt and Seasons and other big kosher boxes is to not to have to look at each and every item that you put in your carriage like one must do when shopping at non-kosher stores. Is there a problem with chof-k that I dont know about or is it a chumrah thing?


                  1. re: MartyB

                    Gourmet Glatt sells Gabila's knishes.

                    1. re: MartyB

                      Please see my post above and Kof-K's reply to my question of whether this is an unauthorized use of their symbol.

                      According to Kof-K, the owner of the pizza restaurant admits to making this mistake more than a year ago and until I questioned it and contacted the Kof-K who immediately called the owner, the owner did nothing to remove the symbol from the website.

                      That said, if the owner knew the Kof-K symbol was being used on his menu/website without permission (even if originally posted in error) and did nothing about it for over a year, until he was caught, I wouldn't be trusting him, I don't care who he now claims is giving supervision.

                      1. re: MartyB

                        Um, who suggested there was a prblem with chof-K?

                  1. re: EmpireState

                    Very close to Sheepshead Bay. There were many extremely chassidsh/ Yeshivish people eating in the restaurant, and FWIW, my LOR said that Rabbi Navarro is fine....

                    ETA: I think zsero looked into this in 2011- see this post for what was said then: