Psst... We're working on the next generation of Chowhound! View >
HOME > Chowhound > Great Lakes >
Jun 10, 2014 10:58 PM

Milwaukee Area on a Sunday + / - 1 day

Will be in town for Sat - Sun - Mon (staying in West Allis)

I was thinking of doing Polonez on Saturday for a big group (we all like that place) and it is tough to get Polish in AZ

Sunday seems like many good places are closed

On Monday I was thinking about doing Sanford (can the 7 course meal be done on Monday's, is the main chef off on Monday's where it is not worth going to that day...the reason I ask is that Monday's are the off day in Phx for most places or they are closed, which seems like Sunday for Mke)

I like Odd Duck's cocktail list, it looks interesting - seems like a cool menu - seems like Sunday would work, what else is worth considering

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. I suggest also considering Wolf Peach, which would be good for either brunch or dinner on Sunday. Rustic cooking, heavy use of a wood fired oven, with a focus on local ingredients. I've had a couple very good meals there.

    1 Reply
    1. re: kellyds

      I've still only been to Wolf Peach for brunches, but enjoyed them...but I do think since you are coming from out of town it should be mentioned that the view of Milwaukee at Wolf Peach is awesome.

      The restaurant the space previously housed (Roots) was a favorite spot to bring guests from out of town and they always commented on the neat view of Milwaukee.

    2. Whenever a great fine dining restaurant like Sanford is open, they serve Sanford-quality food. Don't worry about Mondays; if that's the day you want to eat there, then go for it!

      As for Sunday, many of the best restaurants in Milwaukee are indeed closed, but some others are open for dinner. Consider Bartolotta's Lake Park Bistro, an elegant upscale French bistro in the middle of the park a couple miles north of downtown; Pastiche, a casual neighborhood-ey French bistro in the Bay View neighborhood four miles south of downtown; or Crazy Water, a casual barlike restaurant in the Walker Point neighborhood a mile south of downtown.

      You might also consider doing brunch on Sunday. There are some great brunches in Milwaukee! I love the "order as much as you like" prepared to order brunch at Envoy, in the Ambassador Hotel just west of downtown. They have a big buffet brunch at Harbor House, the seafood restaurant downtown. Or you can go to one of the breakfast-specialty restaurants like Blue's Egg or the Eatery on Farwell.

      14 Replies
      1. re: nsxtasy

        Blue's Egg would be extremely convenient for breakfast if OP is staying in West Allis, especially on Monday when it won't be so busy.

        Unfortunately Eatery on Farwell closed back at the beginning of the year.

        1. re: mse924

          >> Unfortunately Eatery on Farwell closed back at the beginning of the year.

          Darn! I was hoping to go there on an upcoming trip. Oh well. Thanks for the info! (Their website is still up, grrr...)

          1. re: mse924

            "Unfortunately Eatery on Farwell closed back at the beginning of the year."

            Thanks for the update. I spent a significant portion of my life eating, drinking and even living in that neighborhood and that specific restaurant location is cursed. There have been numerous great little ethnic restaurants in that spot going back to even La Casita when they sold margaritas for $1.50 but they have all closed.

            From talking with former owners and/or managers of past restaurants at that address, the problem is not that the restaurants are not good, but the landlord is a four letter word that begins with an F and rhymes with duck.

          2. re: nsxtasy

            Since you brought up Lake Park, I will mention their 3-course Sunday Brunch as it's quite nice and offers a great value over having dinner there.

            I do love Blue's Egg. Its sister spot, Maxies, could be another option for a dinner for a fun & casual southern inspired spot open 7 days a week.

            1. re: bte576

              It's also worth mentioning that Maxie's, like Blue's Egg, is right near West Allis (which is west of downtown).

              Nice to hear that Maxie's is worth recommending, since I'm planning to go there on the same trip I mentioned. I selected it primarily because Maxie's opens at 4:00 pm, so it's one of the few places where I can have dinner early enough to then make a 6:00 pm game at nearby Miller Park.


              1. re: nsxtasy

                Hope you enjoy it!
                Unfortunately, they have cut back their happy hour deal a bit, but they do still have some specials every day from 4-6, so with your early dining you could take advantage of those.
                Everything may not always be perfect, but I’ve had many delicious meals there and it is a fun place to be with good drinks and lively atmosphere. Husband usually gets pulled pork or other smoked meat, while I almost always order something from their seafood selections. While not bad, I’ve been less excited about the more well-known traditional items like jambalaya, shrimp & grits, and gumbo than their more unique creations. They usually have a great seasonal salad option too and definitely check out their daily specials.

            2. re: nsxtasy

              Thanks for all the ideas - I am somewhat hesitant of going French in Milwaukee, last time i was there i went to coquette cafe and was pretty disappointed although i have seen lots of good things about the Bartolotta's family of restaurants

              Blue Egg looks great, and it is great to know it is close and that we have Maxie's close by also

              1. re: Dapuma

                Just to add info...

                FWIW, I've eaten dinner at Pastiche and I thought it was thoroughly excellent, with one delicious dish after another. I haven't been to Coquette Café.

                Every year, the reviewer in the local newspaper lists the top 30 restaurants in the area, and another article with 20 other places that are more "cheap eats" or specialty places. Both articles show hours for each restaurant so you can see which ones are open Sunday. Here are the most recent versions:

                Top 30 Restaurants:

                20 Good Eats:

              2. re: nsxtasy

                It's almost time for our upcoming trip to Milwaukee, and it now appears we'll be sticking around late enough on Sunday for dinner. We've ruled out Lake Park Bistro (we'll be on our way from outdoor activities so we're not inclined to go to such an upscale place). We're now considering the following places, which are all open Sundays:

                Pastiche -
                Crazy Water -
                Harbor House -
                Rumpus Room -
                Wolf Peach -
                Odd Duck -

                I've been to the first two and liked them enough to consider a return (which is why I recommended them in my previous post). I'll report back after our trip.

                1. re: nsxtasy

                  I'd be curious as to what you think of Wolf Peach and Odd Duck. Liked both a lot.

                  1. re: kathryn

                    Looks like I'll be the odd duck going to... Odd Duck. :)

                    What's appropriate attire there? Is casual okay, or is it more a business casual type of place? TIA!

                    1. re: kathryn

                      >> I'd be curious as to what you think of Wolf Peach and Odd Duck. Liked both a lot.

                      I LOVED Odd Duck! I posted a detailed trip report, including my dinner there, at Thanks again for the recommendation!

                      1. re: nsxtasy

                        So glad I saved this thread! Your great report will come in handy for the next MKE trip :-)

                2. See also Blue Jacket, the Hamilton, Bryant's for cocktails. It's much more of a beer town, but does have small, but burgeoning cocktail scene. Maybe take a tour of Great Lakes Distillery?

                  2 Replies
                  1. re: kathryn

                    Great Lakes Distillery sounds fun

                    1. re: Dapuma

                      Second the recommendation for the cocktail lounge Boone & Crockett. Quite good. Was just there tonight. They have a lovely patio. Tried three of the cocktails. Lovely. Note that the online menu is out of date and they're serving much more summer-y stuff now, including a twist on a gin and tonic with basil.

                  2. Dapuma-
                    I know you were looking for ideas of what else to consider, but having gone there again over the weekend, thought I would comment that I really like Odd Duck for interesting small plates in a lively & casual atmosphere. I have been there a handful of times and have always found it enjoyable. We've had a few items that have been misses, but I've always left feeling satisfied from a value standpoint. If you are one to order charcuterie and/or cheese plates, I am a fan of their selections. The cocktails are respectable and they have a thoughtful wine/beer list.

                    There is a cocktail bar just up the street from Odd Duck called Boone and Crockett that you may want to look up if you are into craft cocktails and end up in Bay View. They are open Sundays, but not Mondays per their website.

                    Hope you have a great trip!

                    1 Reply
                    1. re: bte576

                      Thanks, good to hear that people like Odd Duck as well

                      I was able to reserve Sanford for Monday decided to to with Odd Duck - the menu seems interesting and the cocktail and beer list sound great, seems like a fun place

                    2. What's a good spot at some point from the airport to west allis to grab a casual lunch

                      8 Replies
                      1. re: Dapuma

                        I'd make a stop at Milwaukee Public Market. Lots of choices there.

                        1. re: nsxtasy

                          Just note that the area around the Public Market is all torn up right now due to highway construction. But they're still open and the main parking lot is still available.

                        2. re: Dapuma

                          If you want something really easy, Northpoint (burgers and custard) is at the airport, outside security. It's run by the Bartolottas.

                          1. re: Dapuma

                            It totally depends upon which route you are taking from the airport (I am assuming you are flying through Billy Mitchell and not one of the other airports) to West Allis. If you take the bypass, for example, you would be no where near the Public Market or anywhere else in that area.

                            1. re: Fowler

                              Of course. Neither expressway route - the 894 bypass or 94 - is precisely direct (and there isn't as much along 894 the way there is going past downtown). And you can also take local streets, for a shorter distance but probably a longer driving time. So there are lots of different routes. Much of Milwaukee is along one of those various routes. And of course, some places aren't even open for lunch.

                              1. re: nsxtasy

                                You know what...that raises a good idea nsxtasy. Maybe taking city streets would be the way to go because there are so many good places to stop if one took streets from Billy Mitchell to West Allis instead of 94 or 894. National Avenue alone would satisfy most people and that goes right into West Allis.

                                1. re: Fowler

                                  Except that, except in prime commuting hours, National Avenue is going to take a lot longer than I-94, which runs parallel just to the north. And depending on where you're going in West Allis, you might be better off taking one of the east-west routes south of National Avenue.

                                  Anyway, if you'd like to recommend some places along any of these routes, feel free; just make sure they're open for lunch. Personally, I think the Milwaukee Public Market is a great choice, because it offers so many different lunch options under one roof, and because it's a very nice public market, the kind of place any visitor interested in food would enjoy.

                                  1. re: nsxtasy

                                    Great advice as always. Thanks.