HOME > Chowhound > Quebec (inc. Montreal) >

Le Comptoir {or} Au Cinquieme Peche

OliverB May 5, 2014 03:37 PM

Two different types of eatieres, I realize... I haven't been to either place in 3 years (roughly since I left the city) and I have room in my dining schedule next month to squeeze one of these in. I'd greatly appreciate your feedback on which of the two has remained most consistent. Which would you chose?


  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. v
    vabou RE: OliverB May 5, 2014 08:25 PM

    I would choose Au Cinquième Péché because its exactly how i would describe that restaurant : consistent.

    2 Replies
    1. re: vabou
      OliverB RE: vabou May 5, 2014 08:57 PM

      Thanks vabou!

      I was hoping consensus would lean in favor of ACP because I'd frankly much rather stick to the market-driven regional terroir menus that the city does so well. It's quite unlike anything we have here in San Francisco, and I do miss this type of cuisine. Having not been to the restaurant in several years though, I just wanted to be sure the kitchen hadn't slipped over time... I'd chosen Comptoir as a backup because it's hard to go wrong with charcuteries and a strong wine list, so while a bit on the boring side, it's always a safe bet. Based on your description of ACP, I've already made reservations though!


      1. re: vabou
        Stax88 RE: vabou May 6, 2014 06:59 AM

        ACP is more of a nice sit down meal, where Le Comptoir is somewhere you can go with a group, chat, drink with and eat some great food.

        While I land up at Le Comptoir more often than ACP, if you are coming in from out of town and want to have one strong sit down dinner, ACP is the way to go.

        Regardless, you should have a great evening at either place.

      2. o
        OliverB RE: OliverB May 9, 2014 09:47 AM

        A friend just informed me that she passed by A5P recently and noticed a board outside advertising large screen tv and local beers for the playoffs. I hope this isn't the case... It's difficult enough to find a decent drinking establishment free of TVs at the bar, the last thing I want is to have is sports broadcasts while dining out. Can anyone confirm?

        5 Replies
        1. re: OliverB
          OliverB RE: OliverB May 9, 2014 10:04 AM

          I just found this article:


          Is the main dining room shared with this new "pub space"? It was such a small room to begin with...

          1. re: OliverB
            Maximilien RE: OliverB May 9, 2014 10:37 AM

            AFAIK, It's not in their main dining room; they have a second dining room for groups upstairs.

            1. re: Maximilien
              OliverB RE: Maximilien May 9, 2014 10:58 AM

              Thanks Max, so it's entirely seperated and wouldn't be intrusive at all?

              One more option to throw in - what about Chez l'Épicier?

              I think that's a more reasonable comparisson than Comptoir. How would A5P stack up against Chez l'Épicier as of late?

              Thanks again.

              1. re: OliverB
                Maximilien RE: OliverB May 9, 2014 12:40 PM

                L'Épicier is more modern (and a little bit more upscale) than A5P. (and more so than le Comptoir)

            2. re: OliverB
              williej RE: OliverB May 10, 2014 07:43 PM

              I hope that isn't the case! I went to another small cafe today and they had a tv on with the sound turned off. There were loads of interview shows on the channel, but with the sound turned off, what was the point of a TV?

            Show Hidden Posts