Milo and Olive - Mediocre at best
Saturday night we dined at Milo and Olive, and I could not be more underwhelmed. My jaw is still agape at what could possibly merit the slobbering effusive reviews and lines out the door. First of all, the physical setup of the place is absurd. A few communal tables and a bar. I've seen larger living rooms. Most importantly, the food. We had the Milo chopped salad, which was essentially a pizzeria salad that might be 10% better than one you'd get in a foil container from any take out joint. Decent, but it was nothing more than that. Then we ordered the sunchokes. I like sunchokes. These were sickeningly sweet, with a sugary glaze surrounding them. No balance, which is a theme for the chefs here - a complete lack of the concept of balance. Finally, we had two pizzas. The roasted potato with rosemary cream, caramelized onions, Parmigiano Reggiano, and the Burrata with La Quercia prosciutto, tomato sauce, arugula, olive oil, and sea salt. The Potato pizza was good. Not great, but good. It was by far the most put together dish that the restaurant served as far as flavor, compatibility of the flavor profiles and balance. The buratta pizza was a complete failure. I'll forgive them for the cold temperature (which I don't prefer), putting cold buratta on a pizza after cooking it and then covering it with cold arugula will reduce the temperature, but cannot forgive the flawed thought process behind its composition. The tomato sauce was hyper sweet and acidic, the buratta was cold and flavorless, the arugula didn't add anything to the dish, and the biggest failure was the prosciutto, no flavor at all. It painfully needed to be strong and salty in order to counter all of the other elements and it was literally nothing. The crusts were decent. Better than a take out joint, but not state of the art gourmet either. We didn't even bother to try the vaunted desserts because everything else was just painfully mediocre. My point is this, I can go to Pizzeria Mozza who BTW will accept a reservation, not wait outside on a bench forever to get in, sit like a civilized person at my own table, and eat pizza which is the same price but is literally 10 times better than the pizza and Milo and Olive, Oh, and I can get a spectacular salad, and get an amazing starter....and get a luscious memorable dessert. I guess if this place serves the purpose of reducing the crowds at Mozza, I'm all for it. But I'm not returning.
Wow, that stinks.
I've quite enjoyed my meals at M&O; nothing earth-shattering, but both the pizzas and pastas have always hit the spot.
I'm not sure why they would put cold arugula on a pizza; was it, perhaps, closer to room temp? Or outright cold, as though straight from the fridge?
The buratta makes more sense, though temp matters less than flavor. It's certainly not the most flavor packed of cheeses, but Pizzeria Mozza tends to nail it.
Anyway, from my experience it sounds as though you had an off night. Granted, I've only ever been for lunch.
Lastly, in terms of the space, I believe they are expanding into the space next door, which should GREATLY help your absolutely valid complaints.
OCMUTT, next time you want pizza and a nice wine on the westside, go to South End on Wash Blvd nr Abbot Kinney in MDR...tell Mario i sent ya!
I agree generally that most things are mediocre (and I would add overpriced considering the setup) but I keep going back for the pork belly sausage pizza and, recently, the lasagna (also with the same pork belly sausage and kale). I also very much enjoyed the minestrone there. And I too hate the communal seating so get takeout 90% of the time. Burrata served at anything colder than cool room temperature is just wrong and a complete waste. The portions tend small (except pizzas). I got some kind of pasta to go once and I believe I involuntarily snorted when I saw the pathetic portion. It was about 5 bites of food. Never again. Now I know to just stick to the 3-4 things I can rely on.
I agree that for a high end pizza place - Milo and Olive - can't compare to Mozza. It's overpriced and cramped - totally agree.
But, I have to say that Milo and Olive is wonderful for brunch or lunch. Great specials, excellent unique breakfast entrees & delicious pastries to boot.
All my friends that I've taken there for brunch have loved it.
Maybe they could put up a sign - "Warning, our reputation is based entirely on brunch and lunch. Try dinner at your own risk and pleeeeeeeeease don't hold dinner against us."
I'm still scratching my head over the sunchokes and the burratta pizza. Did someone, or a group of people actually taste these and arrive at the consensus - "Hey! This tastes GOOD!" ?
I've actually enjoyed the vast majority of my experiences there, food-wise. There was one visit where the food only seemed okay, but otherwise I think it's very tasty. Agree that the garlic knot is consistently chow-worthy. I also really like the pepperoni pizza since they slice the meat *so* thin.
Seating is indeed cramped and uncomfortable. I used to have some pretty enjoyable interactions w/ strangers at the communal tables, but it seems that, on my last few visits, like nobody wanted to talk. =(
I also don't live far from the place, so I think that makes the seating discomfort far more tolerable for me....
My GF just went there with a friend and when I asked about her experience said, this is another place she is fine never going back to.