Mid-Tier Spirits for Every-Day Cocktail Making
We were discussing this on another thread. Here are my every day hooches (hint: buy 1.75L bottles for MUCH better economics) for making an after work cocktail, or bunch of cocktails for a party:
Sauza Hornitos, El Jimador, or Camerena, either silver or reposado for Margaritia.
For Manhattan's I am all over the map, and typically use bourbon instead of rye:
Evan Williams, Jim Beam, Old Overholt
Rums, really depends on the drink.
Coruba, Cruzan, Goslings, Mount Gay, El Dorado, Don Q (which I haven't seen lately). I love Brugal Anejo for a delicate sipper, but is has gotten a tad pricey lately until I caught it in a 1.75L bottle at a great price: $23 or so.
Gin: Tanqueray, Seagram's is surprisingly good, as is Gordon's.
Vodka (I don't drink much vodka, but Sobieski is great vodka at a silly cheap price.
Sazerac is tricky: lately I've been using 50% Rittenhouse and 50% either Old Overholt or Wild Turkey Rye. Not particularly happy with this though. Gotta find some of the higher proof Wild Turkey.
I am sure I will think of more...
Rye: our standby spirit at home, mainly used in Manhattans and their variants, Fort Points, etc. Saz 6 (when we can find it), Redemption, Rittenhouse, Riverboat. Just got some James E. Pepper 1776, but haven't tried it yet.
Bourbon: Eagle Rare, W.L. Weller, Four Roses Yellow Label, Evan Williams. Was surprised how good the $13/750ml Old Fitzgerald is.
Gin: Plymouth (a shame it has been pushed into the premium pricing band), Tanqueray, Gordon's, Brokers.
Irish: Powers, GrandTen South Boston Irish.
Other American whiskeys: Bully Boy American.
Tequila: mainly use silver in Margaritas and other tequila cocktails. Lunazul, Espolon, El Jimador, Zapopan, Olmeca Altos.
Rum: I like traditional Tiki, so have tons of rums and rhums around, but for an inexpensive white rum, like for grandma's Cuba Libres, I use Don Q, Cruzan, or Flor de Caña.
Vodka: Smirnoff. I don't drink a lot of vodka, but I cannot see the point of going higher than this. I consider the whole super-premium category a transparent swindle. Karlsson's Gold I keep around to drink neat.
Sweet vermouth: the missus loves Antica Formula and I'm a big fan of Punt e Mes and Vya, but our budget brand is Dolin Rouge.
re: MC Slim JB
will try and get a full list up soon but:
1. striperguy, thanks for starting this thread.
2. on vermouth, I love that the 750 ml of dolin are all ~15, especially the blanc, which is just lovely. also comparatively priced (when you account for size), carpano has recently brought to the US their carpano bianco- i saw it in NY for $23 for a litre. I haven't done a side by side with dolin, so i can't say which i prefer, but look forward to doing so sometime soon.
punt e mes always feels like a steal. and, i've wanted to try the classico. i like antica, but now that i've played aroudn with it on my own... anytime it's used in a cocktail, unless it's a really restrained amount, it just dominates the drink for me (i feel the same about cynar... and wonder if that's just what happens when you've had a distinctive spirit a lot, or if certain ingredients/profiles are more prone to that development).
Friends are bringing Classico and Amer Picon back from France. I will be enjoying myself at their house. They said Classico is great. Punt e Mes is my house sweet, unless I think the drink (or drinker) can't take it.
For dry, I like Dolin and Boisierre. I'd love a dry version of Punt e Mes!
re: MC Slim JB
Just wanted to thank you for starting this thread.
Not a "serious" drinker. I mainly keep a bottle of vodka in the freezer for making pie crust!
Yet...I would like to be able to add a bit of seltzer/tonic and lime to my freezer vodka and have that available to sip. I find this "mid-range" list to be very helpful.
Tequila: Olmeca Altos blanco and repo, Espolon repo, Azunia blanco
Bourbon: for me a 1.75L of Bulleit for $30 at Total Wine is tough to pass up. Buffalo Trace is our other go-to.
Rye: Old Overholt
Gin: Tanqueray or Plymouth
Vermouth: Dolin (dry, blanc, rouge)
I've compiled a table of recommended budget, every-day, and premium brands. I used recommendations from personal experience and various threads form here, eGullet, and elsewhere.
I think the "mid-tier" brands are often better than premium for mixing, as their rough edges and unsubtle flavors tend to stand up to mixing.
Gin: Beefeater 1.75 for about $29 at Fresh Pond and Sav-Mor, to name two places that have it perpetually on sale.
Rum: Metusalem, white or gold, is a steal at around $17 for 750 ml.
Sweet vermouth: If you enjoy Carpano Antica – or if you find it too dominant in a cocktail – try Cocci Vermouth di Torino, a delicious, less assertive and less expensive alternative (around $20).
Vodka: Blue Ice or Tito's or Smirnoff
Gin: Beefeater or Seagram's
Rum: Sailor Jerry, Wray & Nephew, Smith & Hook, Gosling's Black Seal
Tequila: 100 Anos or El Jimador
Bourbon: Evan Williams or Jim Beam
Rye: Wild Turkey
Vermouths: Dolin. All of them.
It seems crazy to me (and it's my own list) but I overspend on rum these days more than any other category. I guess I just think it's hard to find good rum under $20 a fifth where as I can find good bourbon under $10 on sale.
NB: I regularly invest in much more expensive spirits for both home and work but when I need volume, I've found these brands to work well.
My current go-to's:
Bourbon: Old Weller Antique
Rye: Rittenhouse 100
Rum: Barbancourt 3 & 5 star, El Dorado 3 & 5, Appleton VX & Reserve, Goslings Black Seal
Aside from a few of the rums, these are all about $17 - $25 for a .750. About half of these I came across on this website, so thanks to whomever has recommended these fine, affordable spirits in the past.
And not to go off topic, but I've found it increasingly harder to find Old Weller and Rittenhouse stocked on a regular basis in all the places I used to find them. I hope that's not the new norm.