10th Anniversary-Corduroy or Restaurant Eve?
Those are our two choices for our big night. Hubby is an adventurous eater, I am not. Would love your thoughts either way. Which is quieter/more romantic for two? (acknowledging neither is truly quiet on a Saturday night)
Corduroy is quiet but not romantic. Eve is romantic but not really quiet. Foodwise, they're comparable (even though Eve probably has a better reputation) and I believe Corduroy is quite a bit cheaper. Neither seems to update their online menu but I don't think Corduroy's menu changes much so....hope that gives you the info to make a decision.
Actually Corduroy is a pretty quiet, serene restaurant (they don't play music---the chef is against that). It's been awhile since I've been to Corduroy (and even longer since I've been to Restaurant Eve....for my own 1 year anniversary, 7 years ago). But I've always found Corduroy to be consistently delicious and there should be something to please both your tastes.
If you like scallops you should order them---Corduroy has the best scallops (regardless of preparation) I've ever had. And the lobster carpaccio is delicious if it's on the menu.
Restaurant Eve is also a very lovely evening with good food. I just haven't been there in so long that I can't recommend it.