Psst... We're working on the next generation of Chowhound! View >
HOME > Chowhound > New York State (exc. NYC) >
Mar 14, 2014 05:02 AM

Another Shout Out for Maple Tree BBQ in Riverhead

It's been awhile for us, but finally stopped last night for some corned beef and pastrami. Also couldn't resist a half dozen smoked wings to round it all out. We were in heaven!

This was our first time for their wings, and I am hooked. Subtle smoked flavor, fall off the bone tender, a nice change from fried. These are going to be my go-to take out wings from now on. The BBQ sauce that came on the side was one of the hottest things I've even tasted, very memorable.

The corned beef could have used a bit more time in the oven, but as always the pastrami melted in your mouth. We kept picking at it long after our sandwich was gone. And the mustard they give with take out is Bauers, my favorite in the world! You don't see that most places. They have the whole thing perfected down to the condiments.

I ordered the holy trinity: potato, slaw and macaroni salad. To my surprise they're not doing the macaroni anymore; the owner told me they now do quinoa salad and other variations of the usuals which I can see with the summer crowds coming up. The potato salad was perfection. Southern style, sweet with basically just potato and mayo. Finshed that off in no time. Ended up being talked into the beet slaw. It had a very gingery Asian sauce that is making me hungry just thinking about it. Their regular slaw is cut a bit thick for my liking but the flavor is right on.

The area inside is so different now, not like a deli at all. Good seating area, lots of room, although of course you can still go across the street and sit by the river too when the weather gets nice. Another new change is that they sell local bottles of wine, beer and hard cider, so you can make yourself really comfortable when you sit down for your meal.

See you there!

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. Not your neck of the woods, but they sell Bauer's by the jar (regular and with horseradish) at Taste of Long Island.

    1 Reply
    1. re: Scott_R

      Thanks that's great to know. I used to buy it by the gallon where I worked and it would last me a year, I was never without it; now I am planning on asking if he will sell me a deli container of it next time I go in. He said they buy about 25 gallons a week, YAY! A local source! (The things I get excited about!)

    2. I love that place!!! A local gem. Very nice family operation.

      3 Replies
      1. re: Motosport

        They are so nice, and the food so good...and the location isn't really out of the way. I have a feeling they are going to go hog wild, real soon.

        1. re: coll

          Maple Tree catered a party I went to in the Fall. Roasted a whole pig and provided all of the trimmings. It was amazing and not too expensive.

          1. re: Motosport

            They have the service, and the food, so rare to find now. Hope they don't get TOO busy and can't handle it (my only fear for them!)

      2. Thanks for the report, Coll. Is it still counter-serve or is there table service? Can't wait to get there again!

        2 Replies
        1. re: emarcus

          Last time I went, it was counter service to order but they then bring you the food to your table.

          1. re: Scott_R

            I only got take out but I could tell they would do anything for you, probably including running it across the street if you so desired. They are sweeties.

        2. Oh man, I didn't even know about this. Feel like changing my menu tomorrow night.....