Psst... We're working on the next generation of Chowhound! View >
HOME > Chowhound > San Francisco Bay Area >
Mar 5, 2014 07:30 PM

Incanto > Porcellino [San Francisco]

Incanto's final dinner service will be on the 24th, later in the spring they'll reopen as Porcellino, which I guess will be more casual and have a significant takeout operation.

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. How sad.

    Is it worth going before their final service? I think I'll be there that weakend...should they oust my AQ reservation??

    7 Replies
    1. re: BacoMan

      I was there on Sunday, having booked several weeks ago before word was out re Incanto Finito. Wall to wall diners, noisier even than usual, and we were told that they're completely booked through the closing but that seating at the bar may be available without a long wait if you show up when doors open. Quality was as high, menu as inventive and interesting, service as attentive as ever. Cosentino wrought yet another variation on lamb neck, this time with tatsoi rabe, polenta and horseradish gremolata; spaghettini with Sardinian cured tuna heart, egg yolk and parsley is lifted right off La Ciccia's menu but it was done perfectly; diners at the next table raved about the Supper for Two of roasted pork jowl with clams, serrano, escarole and Meyer lemon. Cosentino stayed out front for much of the evening, talking and posing for pictures with customers, many of whom have been enjoying his food for most of Incanto's twelve years. It seemed clear from our brief chat that the change in concept was not Cosentino's idea but that he's working hard on his own new project near the ballpark. You'll get updates about Porcellino if you're on the Incanto email list; for news of Cosentino's new venture, follow his Twitter feed.

      1. re: dordogne

        I've always believed La Ciccia was the one "lifting" the dish from Incanto.

        It's a standard Sardinian dish, but not strictly, and my impression is seeing it on a menu right down the block, getting write ups, was validating.

        1. re: sugartoof

          Why is La Ciccia so famous for it then?

          1. re: BacoMan

            La Ciccia was not initially getting the national write ups Incanto was.

            I think Ruth's thread gives the best context:

            1. re: sugartoof

              Thanks for the shout-out, sugartoof. I agree. I believe Incanto was serving cured tuna heart first. What I don't know is whether it's the same preparation as La Ciccia's, and whether the current tuna heart dish being served at Incanto is the same one that it first served.

              Apparently the Incanto version now being served is specifically identified as Sardinian. Again, whether they've altered the dish (or the characterization of it) because of La Ciccia is unknown.

              To answer BacoMan's question about why La Ciccia is famous for it ... at La Ciccia it's more of a signature dish, while Incanto has a less narrow focus and thus isn't known for any one specific dish.

              1. re: Ruth Lafler

                La Ciccia and Incanto have both done the simple, classic spaghettini / spaghetti with tuna heart and they've both done other things with it. I think the most common prep at La Ciccia is with fregola.

        2. re: dordogne

          Who served it first I don't know, but Incanto had served cured tuna heart before the first mention of La Ciccia's on this board.

      2. I maybe the only person on the planet who thought our one dinner there a few years ago was ho-hum. So I'll look forward to the new iteration.

        1. Ten years ago, Delfina and Incanto were two of the most frequently recommended restaurants on this board. Now their names rarely crop up (Delfina Pizzeria more than Delfina itself). My impression is not that they are no longer good, but that the mid-range Italian (or Cal-Italian) niche has been oversaturated. Given its less-than-central location, it makes sense for them to refocus Incanto as more neighborhood-centric restaurant.

          22 Replies
          1. re: Ruth Lafler

            As always, good points. And NV ought to be able to support them. Unlike when we were first there and no one had ever heard of NV :)

            1. re: Ruth Lafler

              Agreed Ruth, and interesting that they are taking this route given the recent opening of La Nebbia so close by. I hope the neighborhood will keep them both busy. I've been to La Nebbia a few times and it's now part of my regular rotation (as is La Ciccia), but I never liked Incanto as much as I did Delfina or La Ciccia. I'm looking forward to the new iteration.

              1. re: farmersdaughter

                On our 2010 trip to SF/Napa, we ate at Incanto and at La Ciccia. I expected to love Incanto and maybe like La Ciccia (I was not too familiar with Sardinian food back then but loved the head to tail food served at several places here in NYC). As I wrote on CH at the time, we fell in love with La Ciccia and had what I considered to be an "ehh" meal at Incanto. Nothing bad, just leaving us wondering what all the fuss was about. They seem to have had a very nice run & I hope we just had an off night there (it happens) and that things in the new place go well. Maybe by the next visit to SF...

              2. re: Ruth Lafler

                The only SF Cal-Italian place I've been to that to me is on the same level as Incanto is Cotogna, and the two places are so different that it's actually kind of odd to make that comparison.

                1. re: Robert Lauriston

                  But now Incanto is going to have a massive decline in quality huh?

                  Is it worth canceling Cotogna plans to eat there once on the 22nd?

                  1. re: BacoMan

                    I'd expect Incanto to be pulling out all the stops in the final stretch.

                    Side note: almost no reservations available on their website (but calling may present more options). I plan on trying to get a seat at the bar at least once more before the 24th.

                2. re: Ruth Lafler

                  Hardly competent as an Italian restaurant, the wave of hype around Incanto was not initially for their pastas.

                  1. re: sugartoof

                    "When it opened about two years ago, this outer Noe Valley restaurant was a typical neighborhood place, but during the past year, it has become a destination. … the new chef, Chris Cosentino, has made this one of the best Italian stops in the Bay Area. … Specialities: Handkerchief pasta with pork ragout; any house-made pasta; braised meats; panna cotta."—SF Chronicle Top 100 Restaurants 2004

                    1. re: Robert Lauriston


                      Major omission? Offal as a specialty.

                      Again, fans of Incanto ultimately did the place a disservice by routinely hyping the place with little basis in reality.

                      1. re: sugartoof

                        No omission, that just came later. It was my favorite Italian restaurant from my first meal there (missed the first chef), which had nothing to do with offal:


                        1. re: Robert Lauriston

                          Yes, your love of Incanto has always been off the charts and hard to avoid. Didn't you once refer to them as the best Italian restaurant outside of Italy?

                          I've been a vocal critic. It's the only place in SF I can recall being served a pasta broken down, stuck together in a massive clumped tangled ball. Shameful.

                          1. re: sugartoof

                            "Didn't you once refer to them as the best Italian restaurant outside of Italy?"

                            I never even said they were the best Italian restaurant in the Bay Area.

                            1. re: Robert Lauriston

                              Oh, but IIRC you did call some place "the best Italian restaurant outside of Italy" -- what was it?

                              1. re: Ruth Lafler

                                I am incredibly curious about Robert's answer!

                                1. re: Ruth Lafler

                                  Who would say such a thing except as a joke?

                                  In 2005, when Paul Bertolli was still chef, I said Oliveto was the best Italian restaurant in the Bay Area, but the competition has gotten much stronger in the meantime.

                                  1. re: Robert Lauriston

                                    Could be there's been some satire behind a grandiose statement or two that went over my head.

                                    If I was mistaken about it being Incanto, it may have been in the context of La Ciccia, or even a general comment about San Francisco's Italian restaurants, but I distinctly recall the discussion, questioning if you had done the leg work (even to NY) to make such a statement.

                                    In any case, I believe a less polarizing, Boccalone style project will do well there.

                                    1. re: sugartoof

                                      I don't really know Robert...but if you look at his website, it appears that he has done the leg work.

                                      1. re: BacoMan

                                        To justify that level of hyperbole?

                                        I don't think even Robert is claiming that.

                                        I think the tendency for all of us is to go overboard at times when talking about San Francisco restaurants, or bars, or even Farmer Markets. There's often a lack of context or first hand exposure to what's happening in other cities, or even just Brooklyn, Austin, Portland, alone.

                                        1. re: sugartoof

                                          Yes, I was more just saying that, if anyone is qualified (and no one may be), it probably would be Robert.

                                          The guy appears to be a professional food critic, who just happens to enjoy posting to CH.

                                    2. re: Robert Lauriston

                                      Actually, what you said was:

                                      Robert Lauriston Mar 25, 2005 01:20 PM
                                      Oliveto makes the best Italian food in the Bay Area, maybe the best anywhere outside of Italy


                                      1. re: Ruth Lafler

                                        Maybe they did, who could possibly know? It was empty hyperbole, proportional to the post I was responding to.

                                        1. re: Robert Lauriston

                                          And so the statement is no longer operative.

                    2. Part of the problem is that the trend that Incanto helped create (head to tail dining) has now become much more commonplace.

                      A major part of its allure was its uniqueness vis-a-vis everyone else. Now that that's no longer the case, Chris has to rely just on cooking moxie to separate his restaurant from everyone else. And while he's a good chef, that's a difficult road to travel.

                      Regardless, 12 years is a great run for any chef or restaurant.

                      1 Reply
                      1. re: ipsedixit

                        Part of the problem was branding and turning an old tradition into a novelty experience people were afraid to honestly critique. Once the place slipped with the Chef focusing on his other projects, there was a floodgate of criticism, and it became okay to admit you weren't impressed.

                        The Church St. room itself always looked dated. I think he'll just move his head to tail dining to the new location more suitable to his image. Zuppe had a terribly akward layout though.

                      2. One is left wondering if this commodification of Chris Cosentino was Chris Cosentino's own idea.