HOME > Chowhound > Florida >

Discussion

Mystic Fish, Guppy's on the Beach or Salt Rock Grill?

  • h
  • 7

Looking for great seafood for dinner with local fish among the choices. I've narrowed it down to these three. Want upscale experience (not a dive) and extra points for a view but not necessary. Must have healthy choices too. Chowhounders, which do you like best?

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
Delete
  1. Middle Grounds on Treasure Island

    1. I had to take a look at Salt Rock's menu again. I don't see much fish offered on their menu.

      1. Thanks--now have a reservation at Middle Grounds.

        1 Reply
        1. re: hibye

          I have always enjoyed their fresh catch "Oscar". A bit different in that the crab portion is a softshell crab. The last time I had it, it was prepared with fresh mahi and was excellent.

        2. Even though you have made your reservations I'll comment for future readers.

          I have never been impressed with my meals at Mystic Fish.
          Guppy's has always delivered fish prepared perfectly. Even though Guppy's is on the beach the view is largely a road and a parking lot. I have not tried Salt Rock Grill...

          Please give a review of your dinner at Middle Grounds! Recent experiences are appreciated and sometimes hard to find on this board.

          1. Guppys and Mystic Fish are owned by the same people...

            1 Reply
            1. re: byrd

              Yes, which is why I've always been puzzled with the difference in my experiences.

              :-}

              I guess it is similar in that I loved Eugen's but E & E Stakeout Grill just never did it for me...