Psst... We're working on the next generation of Chowhound! View >
HOME > Chowhound > Manhattan >
Feb 25, 2014 11:24 AM

stellar meal at Black Tree

Been meaning to check out this relative LES newcomer, and finally got to stop in last night -- with uniformly positive results.

It's a smallish place, 8-10 tables, long bar, dark, rustic d├ęcor, quiet, well-chosen music selection and overall nice vibe.

The guys behind the operation are devoutly locavore without being pretentious about it (some sourcing is mentioned on the menu, but not to the level of being tiresomely minutae-driven). The menu changes every two or three weeks, according to the owner, who came over a couple of times to check on our meal.

we started with a shared order of burrata - a nice, intensely creamy ball accompanied by a warm, crusty small loaf. a good appetite-whetter.

moved on to sandwiches. I've been veggie-deprived the past few weeks, so I opted for the squash sandwich -- a rough mash of several varieties, delicata, hubbard and some others, topped with toasted squash seeds, thin sliced chips of same, fresh mozzarella and a handful of herbs (sage dominant) on a ciabatta. the essence of winter veggie captured perfectly, and enough textural variation to keep things interesting.

my GF opted for the Winter Pig - beer braised pork belly, sliced a bit thinner than usual and very tender, matched with baked apple, pickled apple, cheddar and mint. had a nibble of the pork, which I plan on trying next time around, and was very impressed.

the biggest winner, for both of us was the one dessert on hand -- a s'more with brownie topped with a house made brown sugar marshmallow offset with a scattering of sea salt and a house made graham cracker. warm, melty, sweet, salty and comforting.

impressed by the food as well as the service/interaction. our server seemed really interested in what she was doing, and the food she was offering. she answered every question we had, and was actually conversant in details of preparation and ingredients. the chef came out near the end of our meal (it was approaching closing time, and there was only one other table of diners) to talk as well. asked about how we liked the food, what we might add or subtract, what we'd like to see served...the friendliness was so non-lower east side, so anti-hipster (despite the beards :) )....reminded me of a small town church supper (although I don't think many of those places have Fourtet on the jukebox).

131 orchard, just above delancey.

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. Thanks for the report. I am on that block often and haven't noticed Black Tree. I'll definitely check it out.

    1. One of my favorites. Everything I've had there has been great!

      1. Really enjoyed this place, too.

        The new Russ and Daughters restaurant will be next door--am hoping Black Tree will benefit from the spillover.

        1. I have been reading about this place for awhile. Interesting menu...only sandwiches as main for dinner? How was the portion size...everything looks very affordable especially if they are made with 'high quality' ingredients.

          1 Reply
          1. re: Monica

            We opted for sandwiches , which make up a third of the menu. The core is a nose to tail type rotation of dishes from their animal of the moment . This week, it was two - quail and rabbit. There were three dishes made with each, from small (offal tacos) to large (a nice looking saddle of rabbit). The chef said he was getting a half cow in for next week, and had steaks and other offal dishes in mind.