Log In / Sign Up
HOME > Chowhound > Quebec (inc. Montreal) >
j
Jeremy Osner Jun 2, 1998 04:47 PM

Montreal

Well I just spent the weekend in Montreal -- what a
great city for eating! We had:
Friday Lunch: a newly opened bistro in Vieux Montreal.
Price Fixe lunch was $10.50 for appetizer, main course
and dessert. We both had salad for appetizer; I had
Moules Mariniere and Ellen had Cassoulet au Canard.
Everything was excellent, though I could have skipped
the dessert just as well.
Friday Supper: fresh strawberries,
mascarpone/gorgonzola torte, and honey; all purchased
at the Atwater Market, a beautiful location for buying
produce, cheeses, meats, bread, flowers.
Saturday Lunch: Smoked Meat (Canadian Pastrami)
sandwiches at Schwartz's, which my friend Maurice
described as the Canadian Katz's -- well, I wouldn't go
that far as I found the meat a touch too dry and tough;
but it is a very respectable deli, at least as good as
the Pastrami King in Forest Hills.
Saturday Supper: The only miss of the trip. We went to
a jazz club called Biddley's and ate their barbecued
ribs and chicken wings. I wouldn't recommend the food
or the music particularly.
Sunday Lunch: The cafe at Musee des Beaux-Arts de
Montreal. Excellent soup, fair sandwiches -- certainly
better than any other museum cafe I've ever eaten at.

  1. j
    Jake Klisivitch Jun 17, 1998 10:05 AM

    Oh my. Even comparing Schwartz's to Katz's seems
    sacriligious to me. And to compare it unfavorably just
    dumbfounds me. When I lived in Mtl, I was a regular at
    Schwartz's, and though they might have had an off-night
    or two, I found the brisket to be better by far than
    anything NYC has to offer. Perhaps you didn't order it
    correctly? Ask for 'medium' smoked meat -- 'lean' is
    too dry and tasteless, 'old-fashioned' is a heart
    attack between two pieces of bread. Accompany with
    fries (homemade and best on planet), pickles (local
    Mrs. Whyte's), and a Cott's Black Cherry Soda...
    Aaaaah. I went to Katz's recently and thought the food
    was terrible, really really bad. The pastrami was badly
    sliced and dry, the fries had been kept heated for a
    day or two, and the pickles had seen better days. So
    please. Give Schwartz's another chance.

    Also, next time you're in town try the all-night
    Fairmont Bagel Factory for the best bagels in the
    world.

    1 Reply
    1. re: Jake Klisivitch
      f
      Frank Language Jun 17, 1998 02:13 PM

      Jake Klisivitch writes:
      >

      I've mentioned at least once on Chowhound how I pine
      for Fairmount bagels; there's no bagel in NYC to
      compare to a Montreal bagel - by which I just mean
      Montreal bagels are a whole different experience; I
      wish to God they did mail order. (I still have my
      Fairmount bagel T-shirt that I got for $3. Ah,
      memories.)

    2. s
      stephen kaye Jun 13, 1998 08:53 AM

      you didn't have dinner at Toques??

      2 Replies
      1. re: stephen kaye
        j
        Jeremy Osner Jun 15, 1998 09:44 AM

        No. What's Toques?

        1. re: Jeremy Osner
          g
          Gary Cheong Jun 15, 1998 03:25 PM

          See my post on "Montreal restaurants" a few lines down
          on this message board. It's called Toque (pronounced
          To-kay). I think that is what Stephen Kaye was
          referring to.

          You can now go to Cena -- 12 East 22nd St. here in NY
          to sample Normand's food. He's partner there with
          Stephen & Thalia Loffredo of Zoe. He spends some time
          here every month to change the menu. Prices are on
          the expensive side, but there is also a less expensive
          cafe menu. The best bargain is still Toque in
          Montreal because of the exchange rate (but then you
          have to pay airfare).

      Share with your friendsX