Psst... We're working on the next generation of Chowhound! View >
HOME > Chowhound > General Topics >
Feb 16, 2014 10:16 AM

No love for Gnudi?

I love gnudi and make it often usually because I have ricotta past its expiration date and the other ingredients eggs, grated cheese, flour & nutmeg on hand . I live in the NYC metro area where there are plenty of good Italian restaurants but I rarely see it on the menu. Even here and on other food blogs, not much talk about it. Did it have its day in restaurants and is now passe? Do other Chowhounders make it or even care for it? I always wonder why gnudi & pizza frite aren't on more menus. They are both simple to make, delicious and inexpensive.

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. I make it occasionally. Should make it more often. Good stuff.

    When I see it on menus it is typically not labelled gnudi, but rather ricotta dumpling, or even gnocci.

    1. That is funny, I am making some spinach gnudi today! I have some big batch homemade Sunday gravy thawing as we speak :)

      I love it too. Much less floury and carby than its cousin, gnocchi. I make a lot of things from ricotta though (pancakes, cheesecake, mousse, stuffings/fillings). I think many people are learning how to cook with ricotta because it is a healthier substitute for many dishes.

      Maybe more people make it at home, rather in restaurants because it doesn't hold up as well as gnocchi? Being more delicate? I sure wish it was a choice on a menu for when I want something lighter!

      14 Replies
      1. re: sedimental

        I'm diabetic so it's a better choice than pasta at least carbohydrate wise. Do you use a specific recipe with exact quantities or just eyeball it? Do you poach it in plain water or stock and for how long? I let mine cook too long/too high just now and the dumplings really expanded in size but I liked it.

        1. re: zackly

          I hardly ever make the same thing twice. The trick with Gnudi for me, is to drain the ricotta first, being generous with the flour for rolling them in, then keep them cold in the fridge, sitting in the flour all day, before boiling ( well, simmering them). It keeps them together and forms a little crust for the soft interior to sit in.

          I have boiled them in all kinds of liquid. I typically just simmer in salt water because my sauces are flavor packed enough. I just simmer until they pop up and look puffy, only a minute or two.

        2. re: sedimental

          Can gnudi be made and shaped ahead of time, and stored on a covered baking sheet until cooking in water?

          1. re: monavano

            I make them ahead and store them in the flour (in the fridge). They will get sticky if you don't store them in flour.

            1. re: sedimental

              Do you mean rolled in flour vs covered? Do you cover with plastic to store?


              1. re: monavano

                Yes. After making it, I roll them in flour on a platter, and keep them on the platter (with plenty of flour over them) in the fridge until I am ready to simmer them. If you just hold them on a cookie sheet without extra flour, they stick to it,well.... mine do. I cover with plastic or leave bare to firm up.
                Extra flour on the outside doesn't make them tough like adding flour to the dough does.

                1. re: sedimental

                  I never would have thought to store gnudi this way. Very helpful!

                  1. re: sedimental

                    You must make your's smaller than mine if they cook that quick. I make mine about the size & shape of a chicken egg. Are your's small like gnocchi? Mine take about ten minutes to cook @ a gentle simmer. I've never shaped them beforehand then refrigerated but I do sometime store the whole batch in the refrigerator for several hours then shape them with a large spoon, like a quenelle, dropping them right into the poaching liquid. If I had to quantify my recipe I use about one large egg per cup of ricotta, about 1oz. (by volume) grated parm or romano and enough flour to get it to a moist dough consistency, just enough flour so it holds its shape. Does that sound similar to your method?

                    1. re: zackly

                      I use a tbsp flour to a cup of ricotta. No egg usually.

                      I make them gnocci-sized

                      1. re: zackly

                        For all my Gnudi peeps...
                        Okay, that sounds weird....
                        Here is my Gnudi day today (so far) in the kitchen....keep in mind I am making a ton of prep stuff for the week (so I am a bit of a mess).

                        I drained the ricotta (several hours, always) then make the dough....change of plan about spinach...made pecorino parsley instead. my corgi waits in the next room for the word..."oooops"....she is essential to keep me on task...she loves pecorino :)

                        Then I roll the dough in flour and put it in the fridge to wait until I am going to cook it. I use the "two spoon" method for rolling.
                        I made some chicken meatballs (in about the same size as the Gnudi) to serve with. Delish.

                        I save a " test piece" of dough to see if the texture and spice is okay. It got dropped into a soup stock simmering on the stove...multi tasking and all that....It was pronounced. "Perfect" while eaten plain.

                        Looking forward to my Sunday dinner italian meal :)

                        1. re: sedimental

                          Love this and your little dog, too! :D

                          1. re: kattyeyes

                            Lol. Thanks. She follows behind me and really cleans up after me in the kitchen......what MORE could you ask for in a family member? Seriously!

                            1. re: sedimental

                              I have a Corgi and an Airedale at my ankles when I cook. Floor is cleaner than my cutting board.

                2. re: monavano

                  Storage in flour is a key step... for 24 to 48 hrs. The wet gnudi binds a layer of flour on the surface that makes it tough enough to withstand simmering.

                  I put them in a big deli container (or an empty ricotta container) with a layer of AP flour on the bottom...add a layer of gnudi...add more flour etc etc.

                  After simmering you can either sauce and serve...or brown in butter in a pan. Both are great.

              2. I just bought a big tub of ricotta to make this but with sweet potato not pumpkin.

                Care to share a proven gnudi recipe!?

                1. Anne Burrell's gnudi is pretty simple and delicious. It's very light and easy to put together. The semolina-lined cookie sheet does help to hold the formed gnudi pretty well.


                  2 Replies
                  1. re: bear

                    Interesting. She cooks immediately, but dries the ricotta overnight beforehand. As opposed to the recipes I've used which essentially dry the gnudi in flour after forming them.

                    1. re: sal_acid

                      I don't usually drain the ricotta because we have a couple of local places that sell really fresh, well-drained ricotta and it works well in the recipe. I might try drying the gnudi if I'm ever organized enough to plan that far in advance and can handle the delayed gratification, though.

                  2. Saw this recipe on Youtube. Different than how I prepare, firmer & twice cooked but it looks excellent. I will try soon.

                    2 Replies
                      1. re: zackly

                        Huh, chickpea flour. Looks delicious. And she convinced me to let my gnudi set in the fridge for a while. I could do without the honey, though.

                        Thanks for the link. Now I have to explore Hungry.