HOME > Chowhound > San Francisco Bay Area >

Beaver Creek Smokehouse (Martinez)

m
Malcolm Ruthven Jan 17, 2014 06:44 PM

Martinez strikes again for barbecue. A bbq-loving friend called me today after eating lunch at Beaver Creek Smokehouse in Martinez. The reason I'm posting this is because he's so picky about the quality of barbecue (and other food) and he raved about this place. He and his GF had the $21 combo that included brisket, pork ribs, pulled pork, chicken, sausage and three sides. They thought it was all excellent, including the sides (especially the cole slaw). He also said it was too much food for two people.

Beaver Creek Smokehouse
601 Main St
Martinez, CA 94553
925-335-9915
http://beavercreeksmokehousetavern.com

He sent me this photo: http://ruthvenphotos2.com/files/bcsh_...

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
Delete
  1. Melanie Wong RE: Malcolm Ruthven Jan 17, 2014 06:55 PM

    Cool, another prize-winning competition team gone brick and mortar.

    1. Tripeler RE: Malcolm Ruthven Jan 17, 2014 06:59 PM

      Wow, great photo! Does barbecue ever get any better (looking) than this? I am sure it was very delicious!

      1. b
        bouncepass RE: Malcolm Ruthven Feb 22, 2014 06:17 PM

        Based on the above recommendation, also tried the $21 combo. Same five meats, coleslaw and beans.

        Overall, I thought most things were quite good, say, mostly singles and a couple of doubles, but no home runs. I'd return if others wanted to, but I'll prioritize trying Smokehouse 10 first before returning here. Wouldn't make a special trip from, say, Berkeley.

        One criticism of all the meats is that the smoke flavor was dialed way down compared to my preference. I'd say it was quite subtle at best. I found this a bit odd as the smoke ring was very pronounced on the brisket and ribs (easiest place to see it), and the whole place does smell mildly of wood smoke (in a good way) and there's a large pile of wood stacked in the back.

        Brisket (requested fatty) was decent albeit on the dry side.

        Ribs were good. Nicely cooked (some tug to get clean off the bone) and moist, but I found the dry rub a bit lacking. Probably the best of the meats.

        Pulled pork: also a good version. Came sauced which makes it a bit hard to evaluate the meat itself.

        Chicken thigh: definitely dry in spots. They ran out right after our order so maybe this was the previous days' reheated?

        Sausage: Seemed like a pork-dominated sausage whereas I'm more accustomed to a beef-dominated version (best I've had is Luling City Market). Grind was also very fine, which isn't necessarily my cup of tea either. Probably a mismatch between my biases and theirs.

        Coleslaw was very lightly dressed with vinegar. Throwing on some of the Carolina bbq sauce made it quite tasty.

        Beans were nicely cooked (creamy but still intact).

        Thinking about it a bit more, perhaps their meats are coming out fairly close to how they want them, but their style and mine just aren't well-matched. Despite this, on execution alone it's better than 95% of Bay Area BBQ places that I've tried so maybe worth a shot.

        1 Reply
        1. re: bouncepass
          j
          jaiko RE: bouncepass Feb 23, 2014 11:10 AM

          Thanks for the extensive write-up. I will keep this one in minds for the rare times we are in the area. My DH loves BBQ but hates smoke, so this sounds right up his alley.

        2. Melanie Wong RE: Malcolm Ruthven Mar 13, 2014 01:48 AM

          Sent one of my bbq-pals there and he was very happy.
          http://www.madmeatgenius.com/2014/03/...

          1 Reply
          1. re: Melanie Wong
            Tripeler RE: Melanie Wong Mar 13, 2014 02:09 AM

            Totally great blog. Thanks for the link, Melanie.

          Show Hidden Posts