HOME > Chowhound > Home Cooking >
Are you making a specialty food? Tell us about it
TELL US

Home Cooking Dish of the Month (January 2014) Voting

herby Dec 25, 2013 08:00 AM

The nominations are we will be choosing between two soups to cook in January:
LEGUME SOUPS
or
VEGETABLE SOUPS

As usual, click "recommend" in the post for the dish you select. Please only vote for one dish. You can change your vote if you wish, at any time up until voting closes.
Voting will be open until December 31st at 10am EST on Wednesday December 25th (7am in LA, 3pm in London, and 2am next day in Sydney).
You can view the nomination thread here: http://chowhound.chow.com/topics/928363

  1. herby Dec 31, 2013 05:26 PM

    The reporting thread is here: http://chowhound.chow.com/topics/929721

    1. herby Dec 31, 2013 07:59 AM

      Voting is now closed and the LEGUME SOUPS have the most votes.

      I seem to upset more people that I manage to please this month and for that I am sorry. Hopefully, once we start cooking and discovering infinite varieties of legume soups, everyone will cheer up a bit.

      I will post reporting thread later on this evening.

      Happy New Year everyone!

      6 Replies
      1. re: herby
        Berheenia Dec 31, 2013 12:18 PM

        Thanks for your hard work and Happy New Year!

        1. re: herby
          foodcompletesme Dec 31, 2013 02:31 PM

          Happy New Year and hope for whirled peas!
          :-)

          1. re: herby
            b
            BangorDin Jan 11, 2014 09:58 AM

            I wonder if tofu in hot sour soup is considered legume since it is made from soybeans.

            1. re: BangorDin
              herby Jan 11, 2014 10:03 AM

              Interesting question :) I do not know and leave it up to you.

            2. re: herby
              juliejulez Jan 11, 2014 11:17 AM

              I'm late to the party here but, herby, you did a good job. I think narrowing down the category was fine, and I would say, as long as a soup has legumes in it, it counts, so folks who include other ingredients in their legume soups would be fine.

              I personally dislike any sort of legume pretty much, so I'm sitting out, but I hope everyone else is having fun with it.

              1. re: juliejulez
                herby Jan 11, 2014 02:05 PM

                Thank you JJ! Do wonder over to the soup thread - there are some neat ideas there for soups and not just legume ones.

            3. meatn3 Dec 31, 2013 07:13 AM

              I'm not sure if people realize that DOTM is a poster derived concept. CH does not organize it, volunteer posters do.

              There have been numerous past discussions about ways to design/choose a DOTM to keep it focused while still possessing enough depth to be varied.

              A quick look at any cookbook with a decent array of soups will indicate subcategories. Legume, cream, specific proteins, ethnicity, etc. are among the numerous ways this dish can be delineated.

              A legume soup may contain meat and/or vegetables in addition to various liquids and seasonings. But legumes are the headliner, the other ingredients are the supporting cast.

              A vegetable soup may have legumes and/or meat, but if you were served a bowl the vegetables would be the main event, the beans or meat simply an accent.

              Lastly, Herby has volunteered to organize things and I, for one, appreciate the time, energy and generosity that goes along with the job.

              5 Replies
              1. re: meatn3
                jpr54_1 Dec 31, 2013 07:23 AM

                I appreciate the time, energy, and generosity ---
                but not the selection process-

                1. re: jpr54_1
                  meatn3 Dec 31, 2013 07:50 AM

                  If you look at the nominating thread the concept of soup quickly became popular. Once it was determined that the concept was too broad for this project subcategories were nominated. Vegetable and Legume had the most supporters thus became the nominated choices.

                  1. re: meatn3
                    herby Dec 31, 2013 08:00 AM

                    Thank you, Meatn3! This is exactly how the process worked.

                2. re: meatn3
                  foodcompletesme Dec 31, 2013 02:29 PM

                  I agree with everything you said, meatn3. I think some of the controversy and confusion arose from the rules being enforced some months and not others. Even herby had no knowledge of why the broad category of 'cookies' was allowed when soup was not.
                  Of course I appreciate herby's volunteerism & it is not personal. It is just soup after all. I have a life.

                  1. re: foodcompletesme
                    meatn3 Dec 31, 2013 02:54 PM

                    Personally I think cookies stayed very broad since it was for December and so many people have the tradition of making a huge variety of cookies...If cookies had been up for consideration in June I suspect the idea may have been looked at differently!

                    :-D

                3. jpr54_1 Dec 31, 2013 06:07 AM

                  I DO NOT like the way this months dish was selected-
                  there must be a reason that hereby directed the dish recommendation.
                  I would like to know the reasoning-
                  This process or lack thereof will turn off lots of ppl

                  my legume soups contain meat/vegetables

                  1. j
                    Jeanne Dec 31, 2013 05:22 AM

                    Again - I say (as other people have said) that we need the general all inclusive category SOUPS!!! I love soup, and I would love to see everyone's different recipes.

                    I think you should go with what posters want herby - as do I. Just general soups.

                    And I don't mean to be abrasive - but what makes you the final "judge" on this post? Especially when there are so many people who disagree with you? Can't you go with what everyone wants?

                    2 Replies
                    1. re: Jeanne
                      herby Dec 31, 2013 06:21 AM

                      Please, do not shoot the messenger, Jeanne! :) I am very far from being a 'judge'; I am temporarily replacing LNightshade as DOTM coordinator and asked for her guidance about accepting 'soups' as DOTM. Apparently, this was discussed some months ago and agreed that 'soups' are too broad a category to constitute a 'dish' which is defined for the purpose of this thread as indredient+technique. Also keep in mind that these boards are moderated and mods have a say in this too.

                      Personally, I think that either one of soup categories is broad enough to make a variety of soups. However, if you like to have larger veriety why not start a separate 'Soups' thread - it does not have to be DOTM. This has been done in the past when someone thought that selected DOTM was too limited to their liking.

                      And lastly I would very much appreciate your voting by clicking 'recommend' button in the post for the soup that you selected.

                      1. re: herby
                        foodcompletesme Dec 31, 2013 06:45 AM

                        Not trying to stir the pot…..lol :) I love this site since I found it a few months ago! Just feel the idea should be to meet the needs of those posting, right?

                        I was going to suggest that same thing herby: a new thread for general soup posters. I would prefer to do it through DOTM since it is most current and would get the most discussion. However, if the rules of DOTM keep herby from being flexible about the category, other chow hounds can discuss soups in general elsewhere on the site.

                        So Jeanne, jpr54, boyzoma, Berheenia, nothingswrong, juliejulez, linguafood, chefgabs, and anyone else interested could follow these…….

                        1st I wanted to mention that the upcoming COTM discussion has links to Latin-style soups/stews which look good.
                        That is here: http://chowhound.chow.com/topics/928644

                        Some discussion already on the website about soup just have people listing their favorite soup. But I found an older thread about soups in which CH posted ingredients and recipes (over 200 posts). We can cook those and add to it if you like.
                        http://chowhound.chow.com/topics/6037...

                    2. j
                      Jeanne Dec 26, 2013 05:25 AM

                      Since the selection is so limited (yes, I wanted soups as a group) - I vote VEGETABLE SOUPS

                      5 Replies
                      1. re: Jeanne
                        herby Dec 26, 2013 08:45 AM

                        Jeanne, please click "recommend" in the post for vegetable soups.

                        1. re: herby
                          j
                          Jeanne Dec 31, 2013 05:26 AM

                          Herby see my post above. That's my final vote -

                          1. re: Jeanne
                            The Chowhound Team Dec 31, 2013 06:47 AM

                            We have no horse in this race, but there is an established voting method being used by the Dish of the Month volunteer coordinators, so please make things easier for those volunteers by using their chosen method for voting. Thank you!

                        2. re: Jeanne
                          linguafood Dec 26, 2013 09:43 AM

                          Yah, this might be the most similar "contest" for DOTM ever.

                          I'll sit this one out. Again :-D

                          1. re: linguafood
                            foodcompletesme Dec 31, 2013 04:43 AM

                            Yah, my legume soup will have vegetables in it. Some of my soups might even have cream or meat in them too! I look forward to seeing what SOUPS everyone makes :-)

                            Since this month's DOTM (COOKIES) had over 300 posts, I think we need variety to have more than 10 posts on soups.

                        3. herby Dec 25, 2013 08:01 AM

                          LEGUME SOUPS

                          Click "recommend" here to vote for legume soups

                          1. herby Dec 25, 2013 08:01 AM

                            VEGETABLE SOUPS

                            Click "recommend" here to vote for vegetable soups.

                            Show Hidden Posts