Psst... We're working on the next generation of Chowhound! View >
HOME > Chowhound > Home Cooking >
Dec 18, 2013 03:21 PM

What's your *personal* eggnog recipe?

Let's hear it.

Raw eggs, cooked eggs, non-dairy, vegan, Kosher, etc. Whatever.

Rum, bourbon, brandy, vodka, whiskey, scotch, Peppermint Schnapps, punch, Kool-Aid. All good.

Please share.

Happy holidays.

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. Raw egg yolks, milk , cream, bourbon

    1. In my (southern) family we don't do eggnog...we do "boiled custard." No nutmeg! No peppermint! It's eggs, milk, sugar, and vanilla. I have a bunch of recipes but it's probably way too plain for ya. We love it though.

      4 Replies
      1. re: Bliss149

        so mine must be boiled custard with nutmeg. (and Kahlua.)

        1. re: DebinIndiana

          Oooooohhhh...Kahlua! Now that sounds good!

          1. re: DebinIndiana

            Ooh, I never would have thought of kahlua but that sounds so good. Plus I think it could be a legit brunch drink-eggs and coffee, right?

          2. re: Bliss149

            Lazy boiled custard is: milk, eagle brand and vanilla pudding mix. Yeah not as good as homemade but better than the carton.

          3. My personal eggnog.
            Store bought carton of eggnog. Add bourbon or rum to taste. Sprinkle with nutmeg.

            1. Here's my current formula. This is designed to be aged at least one year. (BTW this probably should have gone in the Spirits forum.)


              - 7 egg yolks (L or XL eggs)
              - heaping 3/4c sugar (raw crystals, turbinado, or demarrara if possible, for some molasses flavor)
              - 2/3c heavy cream
              - 2 1/4c whole milk
              - 1c bourbon (WL Weller, Maker's Mark, or similar -- a mellow wheated bourbon)
              - 3/4c rum (dark amber, not too sweet: Banks 7 Island, Appleton XO, Zacapa XO, etc)
              - 3/4c cognac (something robust. Ferrand 1840, Martell VSOP, or maybe Marie Duffau Hors D'Age armagnac)
              - 1/2c - 3/4c* peach brandy (Mathilde Peche, Marie Brizard, Bols, or some other good brand ... *NOT* the cheap garbage from DeKupyer, Leroux, or anything else you would spit out if you sipped an ounce straight, at room temperature)
              - 1/3c pimento (allspice) liqueur (St. Elizabeth is the standard here. If you can't get it, you can sub some other liqueur, but it's tough to know what would work. Nocello might be nice. An almond liqueur could work well too. Something deep, smooth, and warming.)
              - 1/4 tsp salt
              - 2 tsp vanilla extract

              * Regarding the peach brandy, I find that the flavor fades over the aging period. The Mathilde has great flavor but is a bit less concentrated than some of the others, so the 3/4c is for that brand. For the others go toward 1/2c.

              - Cream together sugar, salt, and yolks
              - Add everything else. Mix well.
              - Fill bottles (I use two 25 oz glass Perrier bottles, which this recipe fills just about perfectly)
              - Close bottles, stick at the back of the fridge, and forget about them for a year
              - Open, pour over an ice cube or two, grate on some fresh nutmeg if you feel like it, and enjoy (I hope!)

              3 Replies
                1. re: Ttrockwood

                  You and me both.

                  I feel like I need a Designated Reader.

                  1. re: Ttrockwood

                    Hah! Well:

                    A) It needs to have high enough proof to keep raw milk and raw eggs safe for an entire year. (And I've actually had it after two full years.) The goal is to create a nice drink and hopefully not to kill anyone (but see (C) for more information on that).

                    B) It's actually not -that- strong. It creates around 56oz of nog, which is 14 or so servings (4 oz over ice is a nice serving size IMO). Each serving contains just over 2oz of spirits -- about a regular pour.

                    C) If you had to spend Christmas with my in-laws, you'd want all the strong drink you could find :-)

                2. Welp, I come from Chanukah folks, so no eggnog in sight.


                  Every year at the holidays, my mom would dig out the recipe for homemade bailey's. Divine.

                  1 Reply
                  1. re: happybaker

                    Eggnog is agnostic in my circle. But I go the easy route: storebought with Makers Mark.