HOME > Chowhound > General Topics >

Discussion

Pecan pie safe at room temp?

  • 8

Never sure. Fridge is crammed packed, but I got it in there.

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
Delete
  1. Oh dear god yes!!! There's soooo much sugar in one of those puppies there's no way anything could live on it.

    Seriously, sugar is a very effective preservative. That's why we have things like candied fruit and fruitcakes with shelf lives of forever (give or take a decade or two). ;>

    1. Its fine for almost 48 hours (unless we eat it faster!! ;)
      No problem, take it out.

      1. Pecan pie safe at room temp?
        __________

        From what?

        Spoilage? Or straying mouths?

        The former, for sure. The latter, who knows ...

        1 Reply
        1. re: ipsedixit

          lol. Yes, it is quite tempting. Thanks, everyone!

        2. Assuming normal kitchen conditions it should be fine for a few days. If it lasts longer than that there is a problem with the pie.

          But seriously, I know it is a highly modified custard pie, but I've left them out for as long as 4 days and had no problems at all.

          1 Reply
          1. re: KaimukiMan

            And it tastes better at room temp, maybe a little whipped cream.

          2. I wouldn't leave a pumpkin pie out because the custard is way better cold (yes i know you buy them unrefrigerated...) but a pecan pie should be just fine. There's too much sugar in that baby for anything to grow!

            1. I always figured that is why we have pie keeper cabinets...to keep the pies out of sight, but not refrigerated . Enjoy!