Psst... We're working on the next generation of Chowhound! View >
HOME > Chowhound > Cookware >
Nov 15, 2013 06:14 AM

Rolling pin questions

I am new to baking, and I want to buy an inexpensive, non-stick pin. I will be using this pin only for bread dough and pizza dough. I will NOT be using the pin to make pastry.

I saw a plastic pin that looks as if it may meet my needs. Can any of you tell me if there are problems associated with using a plastic rolling pin to roll out bread and pizza dough?

I also saw some pins that are called "fondant" rolling pins. Can fondant pins also be used for rolling out bread dough?

Also, what is the best length pin for rolling out a 14" pizza? Does the pin have to be at least 14" long? Or can I use a shorter pin and just roll twice to cover the extra dough?

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. You usually don't roll out pizza, you stretch it by hand. Not sure how it would come out otherwise.

    I have a short pin that I got back in the 1970s and I thought it was fine. However, I recently invested in one that is over 20 inches long (I think they are called a French pin?) and I don't know how I ever lived without it. I got it at Bed Bath and Beyond.

    2 Replies
    1. re: coll

      A local pizzaria agrees with you. They claim rolling the dough crushes the air pockets making a dense crust

      1. re: Alan408

        Thanks, I was just thinking all the pizza joints I've been in all my life and I know I've never seen a rolling pin! You put the yeast in to make it rise, so why would you want to squish it then?

    2. Thank you for the pizza information.

      How about for bread dough? Would a plastic rolling pin or a fondant pin be okay?

      2 Replies
      1. re: JCook233

        You usually punch down bread dough between risings. With your fist!

        1. re: JCook233

          I don't roll bread dough

          Fondant is cake icing

        2. Doesn't sound like you need a pin at all if pizza dough and bread are your plan. Bread doesn't need rolling either.

          If you are in a pinch, you can always use a clean wine bottle to do a bit of rolling.

          1. I just began baking this summer. I mostly bake pizza and bread, rarely cookies or biscuits and NEVER pastry. I don't use a rolling pin at all. I shape pizza skins and bread loaves by hand.

            My pizzas are works of art, in that each one is unique, none are quite round, some are almost triangular, but they all look gorgeous when they come out of the oven. My pizza shaping technique is a work in progress, but it feels good to keep trying.

            When bread calls for shaping into a certain size for loaves or rolls, I use my hands to pat, stretch and coax it into the needed dimensions.

            Happy baking!

            3 Replies
            1. re: DuffyH

              I want to make a very thin crust. Wouldn't a rolling pin be helpful for getting the crust extra-thin?

              1. re: JCook233

                No, you have to learn to stretch it, that's all.

                1. re: JCook233

                  In pizza, I do very thin and really, really thin. Both are simply stretched into whatever shape they're willing to achieve, although they are getting much closer to round as my skill improves.

                  The difference in thickness is entirely doe to the age of the dough when I make the pie. A younger dough, about 18-24 hours old, is very thin, with nice big bubbles. The older dough, 3-5 days, is almost cracker thin, with far fewer bubbles. it's a little past it's prime, but makes an excellent pie all the same.

                  The older dough is the easiest to stretch into shape, as it has very little elasticity left. It doesn't snap back like the younger dough does.

              2. If I do say so myself, I make a mean piecrust, using a rolling pin.

                However, I never roll pizza or bread dough. I find that gentle stretching of those doughs works much better.