HOME > Chowhound > Quebec (inc. Montreal) >
What's your latest food project? Get great advice
TELL US

Brunch: Lawrence, EVOO or Prohibition?

c
causeimhungry Nov 11, 2013 12:45 PM

Hi guys!

I am a huge fan of the brunch at Lawrence and I am planning on going this coming weekend. But then I asked myself if I should maybe try something different. How is the comparison of Lawrence and EVOO for brunch? I saw a couple similar dishes on each menu, and prices look about the same.

I've also heard people liked Prohibition on Monkland for their brunch. This one is closest to me, so it would make traveling easier, but if it's not up to par of the other two, I'd probably pass.

Are there other newish and solid choices for brunch that I might not know about? I'm not looking to break the bank (i.e. The Ritz) but I haven't been out for brunch in a little while and want to be able to relax and enjoy the food. I have no problem getting someplace early or waiting in line.

Thanks!

  1. w
    williej Nov 25, 2013 08:37 AM

    Went to EVOO for brunch yesterday. Superb meal. Lots of variety. Everything tasted scrumptious. Friendly and informative staff and cooks. Looks like the Lunch menu is excellent too. Not a lot of diners but it was afternoon. Just around the corner from atwater and notre dame. Will definitely return.

    1 Reply
    1. re: williej
      w
      williej Dec 8, 2013 05:30 PM

      Went to Prohibition today for brunch. It was wonderful. We had the pain perdu with fried chicken and the lemon ricotta pancakes. Only quibble is it was extremely noisy and hard to have a good conversation. Due to the small space and fairly low ceiling in this basement space, probably nothing that can be done about this so be warned about that aspect. I otherwise highly recommend it. (Make reservations if you are going for brunch; the place is extremely busy). Meals are quick to serve as well so don't worry about it taking too much time at brunch!

    2. c
      causeimhungry Nov 18, 2013 03:19 PM

      Recap:

      We ended going to EVOO. We made reservations online for noon Sunday. When we got there, they were only full to about half capacity, which is rare for brunch in Montreal.

      Service is great and friendly.
      I had the Baked eggs; tiny veal bacon meatballs, poached eggs, cheddar, tomato sauce, soda bread. Fun, exciting dish with great flavours.

      Spouse had the Smoked fish; scrambled eggs, apple coleslaw, crème fraîche, lime, capers, grilled bread. Beautifully plated and tasty.

      Fresh juice of the day was a combination of pear, orange and grapefruit. Nice, light and fruity.

      Small side of granola; homemade goat yogurt, Gaudreau warm honey, dried strawberries. Fresh and tasty.

      Americanos were served with frothed milk, with is always a nice plus!

      Overall, I really enjoyed my meal. We will be back for brunch again and we also want to try their lunch menu; 21$ for 3 courses, which is a great deal.

      Thanks to everyone's comments and suggestions. I am surprised to hear APDC is serving brunch and will be checking that out next!

      As we were leaving, the place is almost empty, yet down the street Quoi de Neuf had a line of about 15 or so out the door. Couldn't really understand why EVOO wasn't busier? Hope they continue to do well and thrive in the neighbourhood.

      13 Replies
      1. re: causeimhungry
        w
        williej Nov 18, 2013 06:34 PM

        Problem could be lack of familiarity as Quoi de N'Oeuf and the place near it are longstanding places on Notre Dame. EVOO is relatively new. Also the name is not very evocative, ie not saying much about what it is and specializes in, whereas Qot de N'oeuf is a nice little pun about eggs!

        1. re: causeimhungry
          mindfultable Nov 18, 2013 07:23 PM

          I believe one of the challenges they have is that they don't attract the locals, whereas other places in St-Henri do. Among my non-foodie friends who live in the area it's seen as "expensive", but when I've asked further, it seems the perception is based off of dinner prices, which are definitely at a higher end than the neighbourhood.

          1. re: causeimhungry
            s
            sophie.brunet Nov 19, 2013 07:11 AM

            I think part of the problem is the decor. I've been twice and was very pleased with the food and will be back again, but it was always half filled like you also noticed. The decoration is pretty bland and non-descript (in my opinion), and I think that for a place like this to work, you have to put a bit more tought in the design and the atmosphere of the place. It doenst have to be fancy, but there need to be a coherent theme or feel... It doesnt entice somebody to go in and check it out...

            1. re: sophie.brunet
              carolilas Nov 19, 2013 01:55 PM

              I hope they manage to survive... I've talked with one of the chefs/owners, Peter Saunders, and he's so nice and passionate about his craft!

              I prefer quiet and subdued environments, so I don't mind the bland decor. Anyway, to me, it's more about the food and people...

              1. re: carolilas
                w
                williej Nov 19, 2013 01:56 PM

                Why the name, though? Their website provides no clues.

                1. re: williej
                  e
                  EaterBob Nov 19, 2013 02:28 PM

                  Extra Virgin Olive Oil

                  1. re: EaterBob
                    w
                    williej Nov 19, 2013 02:57 PM

                    Seriously? They should have been CP-EVOO then!

                    1. re: williej
                      e
                      EaterBob Nov 20, 2013 07:16 AM

                      I'm certain that they have heating at the restaurant, and from my recollection there was enough space between the tables that no one was squished...

                      1. re: EaterBob
                        w
                        williej Nov 20, 2013 12:25 PM

                        i assume your reply was in jest! As was mine.

                2. re: carolilas
                  s
                  sophie.brunet Nov 19, 2013 02:13 PM

                  I do remember that when we went, there was this lady chef (?) that came and explained in detail each dishes. It was clear she was really passionate about her job, which make the whole experience even more pleasant.

                  1. re: sophie.brunet
                    f
                    Fintastic Nov 20, 2013 12:53 PM

                    I think the points about the decor are valid (I'm also reluctant to bring visitors for this reason), but in my experience this wouldn't be an issue in cities like Halifax, St. Johns, Quebec City, Ottawa, Vancouver, most major US cities (excluding NYC, SF, etc), and maybe even Paris. I think we're spoiled here either by the impeccable decor in many fine-dining restaurants, or by what I like to call the "artificial heritage" of casual restos like Joe Beef, Dominion Square, etc etc. Sometimes the desire to sit in a cool room that looks historical even overshadows the mediocre cooking (as in much of Old Montreal). It's amazing how many online reviewers of Joe Beef are fooled into reporting that it is a very old restaurant opened by Charles McKiernan himself.

                    When I travel to Paris I'm always puzzled by the seemingly bland and outdated (read: mid-90s) decor of many high-end restaurants, perhaps because true historical sites exist everywhere and continually updating haute design is prohibitively expensive.

                    In any case, I think EVOO serves some of the most creative dishes in the city, and at a fraction of the cost of places like Toque!

                    1. re: Fintastic
                      s
                      sophie.brunet Nov 20, 2013 01:12 PM

                      I think you are completely right, its a good way to put it in perspective by comparing with other cities. We are indeed spoiled here in term of design of restaurants, and were some restaurants are even opened jointly between architects and chefs (H4C).

                      1. re: sophie.brunet
                        f
                        Fintastic Nov 20, 2013 07:10 PM

                        Agreed! The architecture of H4C is amazing, although I'm not entirely fond of all of the decorating choices here either... something about the material of the bench seating and the red planters... Though I like everything else!

            2. j
              j_do Nov 16, 2013 02:47 PM

              maison publique is also good
              also griffintown cafe
              also the new pied de cochon brunch starts on sunday...

              the vibe is terrible at EVOO despite the food being decent. i wouldn't recommend it to someone visiting

              3 Replies
              1. re: j_do
                s
                Simon Patrice Nov 17, 2013 07:52 PM

                Wait... What Pied de Cochon brunch?!?

                1. re: Simon Patrice
                  e
                  EaterBob Nov 18, 2013 05:05 AM

                  http://www.restaurantaupieddecochon.ca/ Right hand side. No reservations and through the end of January

                  1. re: EaterBob
                    s
                    Simon Patrice Nov 18, 2013 06:54 PM

                    Thanks! I see it now.

              2. mindfultable Nov 15, 2013 08:41 AM

                I've been to EVOO a couple of times for brunch and it's fantastic. I heatedly recommend it. I haven't been to Lawrence though, so have no idea how it compares.

                Prohibition was good, but it was super busy and loud, and ultimately I ended up being a bit undewhelmed by the food and overwhelmed by the busy-ness.

                I've been hearing good things about Bete à Pain. I haven't been since they expanded into brunch, but loved the bakery when I've stopped by in the past, and I'm a big fan of Le St-Urbain.

                I also really like Bacci on St-Antoine in St-Henri. Small, neighbourhood place with only a few tables, changing brunch menu, delightful owners, very affordable.

                2 Replies
                1. re: mindfultable
                  w
                  williej Dec 7, 2013 10:00 AM

                  I checked and it is called Cafe Baci. Bacci is a bar on the Plateau.

                  1. re: williej
                    e
                    EaterBob Dec 7, 2013 10:03 AM

                    Café Baci's, 4354 St Antoine W, 514 516-2232
                    http://www.cafebacis.com/

                2. s
                  stak Nov 14, 2013 07:08 PM

                  I like Lawrence a lot but have been underwhelmed a couple of times. The menu at Prohibition actually appeals more to me. I've been there once and really enjoyed the French toast and fried chicken. I haven't tried EVOO yet but I would say Prohibition
                  Is worth a try.

                  1. carolilas Nov 11, 2013 04:42 PM

                    I have been to all three places mentioned. I'd say Lawrence and EVOO are excellent, while Prohibition is ok.

                    I'd recommand EVOO for its attention to details. The food is original and tasty, the service is friendly and efficient. A quiet place compared to Lawrence.

                    I'd also recommand La Récolte on Bélanger:

                    www.facebook.com/LaRecolteEspaceLocal

                    and La Bête à pain on Fleury:

                    www.twitter.com/LeStUrbain

                    Lots of people like Régine (I personally think the food lacks finesse and the place is very crowded):

                    www.reginecafe.ca

                    2 Replies
                    1. re: carolilas
                      mindfultable Nov 15, 2013 08:42 AM

                      La Recolte sounds really interesting!

                      1. re: mindfultable
                        carolilas Nov 16, 2013 03:04 AM

                        Their menu changes every weekend and includes seasonal ingredients (like apple and squash these days).

                        My friend had the panzanella salad with root veggies, goat cheese and poached egg while I had the grilled cheese with Wagyu beef. I also enjoyed a cup of hot chocolate with a homemade maple marshmallow. I usually hate marshmallows, but this one I devoured! It had just the right hint of maple and the hot chocolate was not too sweet. Both meals were thoughtfully put together and excellent.

                        I go to a lot of restaurants, especially for brunch which is my favorite meal, and I really fell in love with this place!

                        I highly recommend it!

                    Show Hidden Posts