Son of a Gun
Finally tried this today...I had enjoyed Animal last year, but not enough to warrant a return.
Service was warm and efficient.
Room is unremarkable and fairly cramped...noisy, but not as bad as Cynthia's was.
Shrimp Toast was tiny...literally a 2 inch square which I had to cut in half myself! It was perfectly tasty, but don't need to order it again...not for $12.
Lobster rolls were cute...but they were impossible to eat - it was like someone spooned a tablespoon of lobster salad on a brioche bun. And it didn't taste much of lobster.
Chicken sandwich was delicious...and large. Crispy, excellent slaw. At $14, the clear bargain on the menu.
Lime Desert - it was nice, but tiny...better order one for everyone.
Like Animal, I had a perfectly fine meal. But don't need to go back.
I had similar thoughts when I went about a year ago but I avoided most of their signature items in favor for their raw seafood dishes. Overall very fresh and well prepared but nothing really stood out. I would definitely return for just their shrimp toast and to try the chicken sandwich. Service wise I had a stellar waitress.