Black Sheep Bistro, Jessica's, Bob Cat Cafe, Storm Cafe, somewhere else?
We will be in the vicinity of Middlebury next week and need to fill in one dinner. It's been a few years since we've been in the area. Of the 5 restaurants listed above, which would you recommend? We are looking for good food and drink, and don't want to drive very far ( e.g., love Starry Night but want to stay closer to Middlebury). Also, what about eating at the Waybury Inn; used to love it but it's been years since we've eaten there.
We love the Bobcat. We were just there Wednesday. My favorite of the ones you have listed. They brew their own beers. Yum.
I had the steak-ordered it medium and it came perfect. Spouse had the haddock dish and it got rave reviews. Mother in Law had the burger - it was HUGE. It looked great. Father in Law had the meatloaf-he really enjoyed it but be forewarned that the sauce it comes with is HOT. If you don't like a lot of spice but want the meatloaf, ask for it on the side-they'll happily oblige.
Be sure to make a reservation for wherever you choose - its busy season here now between leaf peepers, college parents weekends and us locals who like to eat out!