Psst... We're working on the next generation of Chowhound! View >
HOME > Chowhound > San Francisco Bay Area >
Sep 7, 2013 01:49 PM

Fisherman’s Cove Deli and Bait shop in Bodega Bay

Friday was a glorious day to be on the Sonoma Coast. A friend and I escaped the heat for Bodega Bay’s blue skies, gentle sea breeze and 70-degree temperatures. Our chow mission: Check out the new fish shacks.

In January I’d tried the clam chowder at Fisherman’s Cove as part of the annual Chowder Day. I’d enjoyed the chowder and was charmed by the bait and tackle shop with a food counter. In the months since, the shop has scaled back the tackle displays and squeezed in more tables inside and out. Still, this is the place to buy an oyster knife, if you need one.

Oysters are the specialty here, offering oysters on the half shell or a variety of grilled preps. Here’s the oyster menu board:

Though it’s now the “R” month of September, I felt that the recent run of hot days might affect oyster texture and only wanted to order cooked oysters. We went with two each of 1) Garlic butter and wasabi cocktail sauce, 2) Chorizo butter with fresh lemon, and 3) Sweet Heaters with pickled jalapeños and shallots. Ordered as a sampler, they’re $2.75 apiece.

While we waited outside at a picnic table, a bowl of clam chowder, $7 for 16 ounces, was as good as I remembered. Garnished with some chopped scallion and served with oyster crackers, this version is less rich with bacon fat and cream than others, highlighting the fresh vegetables, milky base, herbs, and clams more.

Our six-oyster plate came with garlic ciabatta bread for catching the sweetly briny juice run-off. Both of us preferred the garlic butter and cocktail sauce prep, mostly because the added flavors did not dominate the natural taste of the oyster. I also liked the jalapeño and shallot butter prep, as the bright pickling added a good touch of acidity, but the chile’s flavor was somewhat overpowering. The chorizo oyster did not have enough acidic lift and the mouthful tasted mostly like the Mexican sausage.

After this sample, Andrew said, “What did you think about the oyster quality? Shouldn't we should get a couple on the half-shell?” I quickly agreed, as the oysters had a firm pop and were fresh as can be. These turned out to be our favorite, so plump and served up cleanly shucked with all their salty juices accompanied by just a squeeze of lemon. The oyster shucker/griller does an excellent job here --- cleanly separated, no mangled oysters, shell fragments, or loss of juices.

These oysters are as fresh and well-prepped as going to Marshall on Tomales Bay. I’m really happy to have an alternative that’s easier for me to reach.

Fisherman’s Cove Deli
1850 Bay Flat Rd
Bodega Bay, CA 94923
(707) 377-4238

More photos of Fisherman’s Cove

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. Thanks for the report, Melanie. Collecting Bodega Bay options for an upcoming visit, and this one looks like a winner. I checked out their website, love how they state that 'hours vary in season or storm'...

    1 Reply
    1. re: susancinsf

      I neglected to take a photo of the view. FC is across the street from the marina, so there's a bay view. But since it's so close to Bodega Head, another option would be to pack up your food and have a picnic oceanside.

      It's quite remarkable how much the food scene has change in BB in the last 5 years. Not necessarily fancy, but you can get good food on the coast now.

    2. We stopped here a few days after Christmas for oysters and also tried the pulled pork sandwich and Portugese style fish soup.

      The dozen oysters were perfectly shucked, cold and fantastic. The pulled pork sandwich was devoured by my kids but I stole a bite and it was quite good.

      The fish soup had shrimp, rock cod, linguica, potatoes and kale among other things. We really enjoyed this and my kids loved it as well, though I didn't love the linguica.

      They offer beer and wine and I had a Lagunitas Lil Sumpin to enjoy with the oysters while my wife had a glass of white.

      They also had Dungeness crab for sale on ice.

      1 Reply
      1. re: MikeW

        Thanks for reporting! I've been wanting to try that Portuguese soup. Between the two of us, looks like we've covered just about the whole menu but the crab dishes.

        I feel like I need some of those oysters this weekend. Pretty remarkable, aren't they? I've been to much fancier oyster bars that can't shuck as cleanly as this bait shop does.