HOME > Chowhound > Greater Boston Area >

Discussion

Grill 23, tomorrow, for a friends birthday, what one plate should I get?

it's RW, it's an overpriced steakhouse (full disclaimer, ALL steakhouses are overpriced IMNSHO), I'm going there for a good friends birthday dinner though, so I'm ready to make the best of the situation.

That said, what do I order there to make the experience of spending way too much money on a steak that I can cook just as well at home for 1/8 the price not so soul sucking?

Also, can I expect a decent bar tender? I'm going to need me some smokey martini to get through the night, and a bar tender that properly knows how to make one will make up for any other possible disappointments...

Thanks!

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
Delete
  1. Dry-aged prime boutique-ranch ribeye or strip takes some work and cost to recreate at home. G23, despite the punishing noise levels, is my favorite Boston venue for that kind of steak. (It's a little quieter upstairs.)

    Bartending is very good if you stick to the classics, as opposed to a Drink-style craft number. Don't expect a welcoming nod or precise results if you order a Toronto or Last Word. (What's a smokey martini? Dash of single-malt? I imagine they could fix that up. Good premium whisky selection, and big cocktail glasses.)

    http://mcslimjb.blogspot.com/

    1. G23 is a great place for a great steak in BOS. If you can get beyond your NSHO, you'll be fine, make your friend happy.

      1 Reply
      1. re: treb

        Agree - nothing flashy here - just quality. Get the cut you like cooked the way you like and have a good scotch. If you go martini, it better not be vodka. :)

      2. If you don't want to spend on a steak, try some of the seafood. They are very creative and very good with fish. I always order fish, usually the nightly special. Also, my favorite steakhouse. Bartending I always found top notch, espcially the martinis. Great wine list! Very loud, very expensive and very good!
        Enjoy,
        CocoDan

        1. your rw entree options are brisket, bluefish or pork belly ramen. OR ny strip with an $8 upcharge. since it's a steakhouse, i'd go with that. personally my home oven doesn't reach 800 degrees like a steakhouse grill does,so i'd put my bias aside for the night to enjoy the food and the company.

          order a standard martini, nothing crafty, and you'll be fine.

          3 Replies
          1. re: hotoynoodle

            Having never been to a place during RW can you order off the regular menu if you want or are you locked into the RW one? I would hate to go to G23 and only have those options…

            1. re: foodieX2

              You can order off the full menu at G23. I've never been anywhere that doesn't offer a full menu during RW, though there may be a few. As soon as you order a cocktail and announce you won't be ordering the RW menu, most service levels improve noticeably.

              That said I am a day late on the post and RW, and the OPs meal are over. My rec would have been to enjoy the experience for your friends birthday and order your favorite starter followed by the dry aged NY strip or porterhouse.

              Also to the OP, when you consider that G23 serves largely prime, dry aged Brandt beef, the steaks aren't a terrible deal. If you know of somewhere to buy a comparable porterhouse for $7 (or anything remotely close to that) I will be eternally grateful.

          2. Shell fish chowder is great, I would go with the bone in Ny Sirloin or the Grilled Salmon, if you like Salmon it is one of the best I have had .

            1. Although I share your sentiments on steakhouses and never personally choose to go to them, I often find myself at them for business. That said, I think Grill 23 is really one of the better ones and I've been impressed there.

              I would echo the sentiment that if you can sit upstairs, it's quieter and more intimate. I've had great King Salmon there (they do a much better job with non-steak options than most steak houses) and you can't go wrong with your favorite cut. Personally, I would just pay the upcharge for your favorite steak and enjoy along with a chopped salad.

              Wine-wise, like most steakhouses the big names and regions (especially Cal Cab) have insane markups, but because the list is so long, you can still find a couple of good deals, so take your time with the list.

              If you stay cocktail only, they do fine with the classics. As always, when not at a craft cocktail bar, your best bet is to be very specific (especially for martinis). Make sure to specify stirred, vermouth ratio, garnish, brand, etc. You'll get what you want.

              1. Agree about this being one of the better steakhouse options. In part because G23 does a better job with the fish options than most of the other steak places in town.

                1. G23 martinis are epic

                  1. I love Grill 23, and I alternate between getting the Kobe Cap Steak and the 100-Day-Aged Ribeye.

                    That said: The "Epic Pot Roast," made with braised beef cheeks, is true to its name. The sleeper hit on the menu, and at $25 it's an economical choice. A photo from the chef's blog (four pictures down):

                    http://grill23recipes.blogspot.com/20...

                    2 Replies
                    1. re: Jolyon Helterman

                      Thanks for the suggestion and for the blog link! Grill 23 is my favorite steak house as well. I also don't go out of my way to go there, but when I have an event or a gift certificate I do enjoy it. Now I know what I to try next time!

                      1. re: Jolyon Helterman

                        THAT blog!! I had to drag myself off it to do some work - what a fabulous, delicious rabbit hole of a web page. Thank you for sharing!!