Psst... We're working on the next generation of Chowhound! View >
HOME > Chowhound > Home Cooking >
Jul 12, 2013 05:26 PM

No mayonnaise potato salad

Please, everyone Thanks for all your responses, but most of you have mayonnaise in your recipes

The potato salad I am thinking of was thin sliced, obviously had vinegar and a ? little sugar, and was sprinkled with a very small amount of parsley. There wasn't any egg, or other additives, or spices that I remember. I am quite sure that there was NO mayonnaise. It's possible that there was pickle brine, but certainly not sweet pickles.

Anyone who is younger than 75 need not answer!!!!

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. I have a couple of recipes that sound very similar, but since I do not fit your age requirement ........

    1. You do realize that we have no idea what your request was and what the responses were, right? If you had added to your original request, we might have a clue. Frankly, anyone who is younger than 75 might actually be able to answer you, but you've dismissed them outright. Do you actually want some help or are you going to be rude before you even ask?

      4 Replies
      1. re: Terrie H.

        Sorry if I offended you. The original request was for a recipe for the ubiquitous potato salad in NYC and Long Island delis in the 40's and 50's. The reason I asked for people older than 75 is that no one else seems to remember the thin sliced potato salad, wit NO mayonnaise, just a sprinkling of parsley, and obvious vinegar
        I assumed that you all would know about my original request, but I see that I did not reference that.
        Please see that original post for NY deli potato salad under my name

          1. re: maplesugar

            Ah, I should have read back 5 years ago. Sorry, msmouser.

        1. This German Potato Salad recipe from my Dad, who would have been 91 this year might be a starting point for your dressing, using oil in place of the bacon fat. Sounds like you'd also omit eggs from the layered salad.
          Dad’s Hot German Potato Salad

          2 lbs potatoes
          ½ lb bacon
          ½ cup minced onion (finely chopped raw, will be cooked in dressing)
          scant 1/3 cup vinegar or pickle juice
          1 ½ teaspoon flour
          1 Tablespoon sugar
          3 ½ teaspoon salt
          ¼ teaspoon pepper
          ¼ cup minced onion (finely chopped raw, leave raw)
          2 Tablespoon green pepper
          1 Tablespoon dried parsley
          1 teaspoon celery seeds

          4 hardboiled eggs, sliced into rounds

          Peel potatoes and cook until just tender. Slice into rounds.

          Cook bacon, and reserve 2 tablespoons bacon fat

          Make dressing: In 2 tablespoons bacon fat, saute ½ cup onions. In a small bowl, mix flour, sugar, salt, pepper, vinegar and water then stir mixture into onions. Cook over low heat, to thicken slightly while stirring, until dressing looks clear.

          Add sliced potatoes, ¼ raw onions, green pepper, parsley and celery seeds to dressing.

          Layer in serving bowl – potatoes, bacon, eggs. Most often served while dressing and potatoes are still warm.

          1 Reply
          1. re: MidwesternerTT

            Oh whoops, looks like someone else already identified it as German potato salad before I did. Should have read first. My bad.

          2. Ms. Mouser, I'm substantially younger than 75, and I don't have a recipe of my own for you, but what you're looking for sounds an awful lot like German potato salad...for example...



            Do those sound about what you're looking for? Not a speck of mayonnaise in sight....

            1. Why did you start a second thread for this topic? You are now getting the same suggestions (which you already rejected) as you did for the original 2007 thread.

              5 Replies
              1. re: greygarious

                I was trying to get a recipe that had NO extras, NO mayonnaise, just potaoes, seasoning, Oil and vinegar, I think, and not much else. I guess no one really understands that, and I can't find anyone who seems to recall that type of potato salad, I just keep hoping!!!

                1. re: msmouser

                  Ms. Mouser, it sounds like what you want is German potato salad, did you see the two links above? You could always remove extras like sliced egg, etc.

                  1. re: msmouser

                    How about just *making* a potato salad with oil, vinegar, salt & sugar. Sounds like that is what you are looking for. It's not rocket surgery, ya know '-)

                    1. re: linguafood

                      I'm not 75 either, but as linguafood said, you've got your ingredients figured out already anyway, so what do you need a recipe for?
                      Just make it and adjust the proportions till it tastes right to you.
                      Odd that you would assume we all know what you were talking about five years ago, msmouser. Everyone's happy to help, but the participants here on Chowhound have had quite a turnover in five years.

                    2. re: msmouser

                      Have you tried ANY of the no-mayo recipes that have been provided? It it's been 50 years since you last had it, I am sure your memory has faded and your tastes have changed.