Psst... We're working on the next generation of Chowhound! View >
HOME > Chowhound > U.K./Ireland >
Jul 6, 2013 03:58 PM

[Dunvegan, Isle of Skye] Three Chimneys

Our second time at the Three Chimneys- the first was four years ago.

At lunchtime on a drizzly summer day, the Three Chimneys was surprisingly empty, but did eventually fill up a bit.

Starter: seafood soup for me. Gorgeous. Briny but not fishy, good chunks of fish. Blade and tongue of beef for Himself. Tongue fried and crunchy- he loved it.

Main: The last time, I had their seafood platter, but in general, I am not a huge fan of cold seafood, though this was definitely fresh and well-prepared. This time, I had monkfish and scallops, wrapped in bacon, with cabbie claw. Monkfish pearlescent and perfectly cooked, scallop plump and juicy, and I looooved the horseradish in the cabbie claw. I would take this over the seafood platter any day.

Dessert: Unusually for me, this was a highlight. Cranachan- how have I not known of this before?! Wonderful, wonderful. So simple, but works so perfectly. I could have eaten a vat of this. I'll be looking at making this for our summer barbecues, now that it looks like we're actually having a summer.

We will always make time to stop at The Three Chimneys if/when we are on Skye. It's a beautiful room in a beautiful location, and the staff are excellent, especially when you hear them explaining the same thing over and over again for each table. "Cabbie Claw is..." "Cranachan is..."

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. Oh me oh my. Ate here last night and it left me having one of those seemingly very important debates in my head about where in my Top Three Ever it now ranked...pretty close, I say, and that includes Noma and L'Enclume, of both of which it had a whiff.

    The setting obviously helps. You have to make a real effort to get here, driving along isolated roads through some of the most spectacular scenery in the UK, if not the world. It takes time, and feels like a pilgrimage. That sense of worship continues in the lowhung white washed stone building, which has something of the Kirk to it, though obviously a darn sight more comfortable.

    We went for the tasting menu, naturally, because when are we ever going to be back?

    Nibbles of cheese puff with smoked trout rillettes; Scotch Woodcok cheese straws; baked salsify. Then:

    Local Bracadale Brown Crab Parfait, Apple, Mull Cheddar, Sorrel

    Colbost Skink (smoked haddock chowder), Marag Dubh (black pudding) & Talisker (whisky) crumb, Local Croft Egg Yolk

    Skye Lobster Tomalley, Prawn, Totaig (local) veg and radish

    Sconser King Scallop, minted green peas, gooseberries and bacon

    Fried Loch Harport Oysters and Black Isle Blade of Beef with cauliflower, parsley, anchovy

    Loin and leg of hare with spring greens, gingerbread, crowdie (cheese) and blaeberries

    Cairnsmore Goats Cheese, Cherries and Pecan Crumble

    Three Chimneys Hot Marmalade Pudding Souffle, Drambuie Syrup and Mealie (oats) ice cream

    Petits fours then included tablet and mini lemon meringues

    Gosh it was spectacular. Even the crockery felt liturgical, again like L'Enclume. But there was none of the 'I've put this foraged leaf on the plate for educational purposes' - everything was just lovely, and had its place.

    Awesome, in the original sense of the word. If you love food, if you plan your dinner while you're eating breakfast, you have to go. Just have to.

    3 Replies
    1. re: helen b

      Always wanted to go there. I've only got the beautiful Three Chimneys cookbook - a gift from a Scottish aunt (she's from Perth) who dined there and absolutely loved the place.

      1. re: klyeoh

        Go! We tried to get a copy of the cookbook there, thinking we might get it signed, but it's out of print - so you have a collectors' item!

      2. re: helen b

        It's been years since I was there but I loved it too - thanks for reminding me.