Psst... We're working on the next generation of Chowhound! View >
HOME > Chowhound > Outer Boroughs >
Jun 30, 2013 09:05 AM

Lioni's--your favorite sandwich?

The title says it all...

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. The lack of responses say it all........ Stick to Defontes

    6 Replies
    1. re: psnative

      I disagree. The lack of responses may have to do with the fact that Lioni's has about 300 different named sandwiches, so I doubt whether anyone could have tried enough to say what a favorite was. And maybe Lioni's customers are into these kinds of favorite questions.

      1. re: bobjbkln

        Like what's your favorite Beatle song?

        1. re: psnative

          When I originally asked the question it was because I'd never been there and was trying to narrow things down a bit, not comparing post mortem notes...

      2. re: psnative

        You've been to both and prefer DeFonte's?

        1. re: psnative

          Yeah, before I saw this post I was unaware of Lioni's, so I went and checked it out. And...I will be back! It's an easier trip for me than Defontes, and it obviously has a very deep menu and quality ingredients.

          I got the #99 which was veal cutlet, fresh mozzarella, and "bruschetta", which was great. I liked it better than the #132 which was a little too funky.

          Soooo...THAT'S MY FAVORITE.

          1. re: scooter

            I heard their sausage was very good, so I gave Lioni's another try. Had the sausage with bruschetta (tomatoes, onions, black olives). Very simple and very delicious.

        2. i dont really like the sandwiches at lionis. i just go for their smoked mozzarella and their sausages to grill.

          4 Replies
          1. re: sam1

            But there's so many sandwiches there... You don't like any of them? Or is it the bread which is with all of them? My son had #125 w. prosciutto de parma, bresaola, cappiocola, fresh mozzarella, basil mix and balsamic and we both thought it was really good. Please tell me why you don't like their sandwiches as I'm no expert regarding Italian sandwiches but trying to learn... Do you like DeFonte's better? What DO you like?

            1. re: rschwim

              Lioni's is on Grubhub and they deliver to my neighborhood. I've ordered twice after hearing from old Bensonhurstians about how great it was. I was not impressed either time. I do, however, like their attached meat market. It's reasonably priced and very good.

              1. re: Sluggo1407

                What sandwich place does impress you?

          2. The Sophia Loren's been my go to for about 15 years...

            Mozzarella, prosciutto and stuffed peppers on a massive hero for just under $14. The put about half a pound of prosciutto on the sandwich so it's not a bad deal at all. Quality products with extremely fresh and milky mozzarella.

            I wouldn't order most of their sandwiches to deliver, to be honest. They sog out too quickly and the prosciutto sticks together into a mass of meat.