HOME > Chowhound > Food Media & News >

Top Chef Canada, Season 3, Episode 12

chefhound Jun 4, 2013 03:54 AM

Quickfire: The chefs must prepare two burgers: the first must be a take on the classic burger and the other must be their ultimate burger.
Jonathan's classic burger is a rib-eye steak burger with double-smoked bacon, pickled cucumber, onion and marinated tomato. Jon's ultimate burger is a rib-eye patty with truffled pecorino, yellow tomato jam and baby arugula.
Danny's classic is a double stacked hangar beef and pork patty with truffle, aioli dressing and confit tomato. His ultimate burger was a camel and pork patty with trout roe and tahini glaze with parsley, mint and tomatoes.
Dennis' classic is a ground beef with Kobe burger with ketchup, pickled onions and white cheddar. His ultimate is a spicy pork burger with spicy pepper purée, chicharron, Brie and watercress.
Matthew's classic burger is chuck and foie gras with red wine braised mushrooms and grainy mustard mayo. His ultimate burger is a lobster patty with tarragon mayo, crispy potato chips and oven-dried tomatoes.

The bottom: Danny and Matt.
The top: Dennis and Jon.
And the winner is Dennis and his prize is $5,000.

Elimination: The chefs must create a two-course meal for Air Canada's Executive First international service. They must cook in the kitchen and reheat the dishes on the plane. The food must fit into the plane's ovens. The prize is a trip for two to anywhere Air Canada flies. Guest judge is Charlie Palmer.

Chef McEwan comes around during prep and rattles everyone's cages.

Danny serves a prosciutto and pickled melon antipasto. For the entree he served a Dijon roasted veal with potatoes dauphinois and asparagus.
Dennis' appetizer is a roasted pork loin with fennel salad, ricotta, blueberries and pickled cucumber. His entree is grilled chicken breast with polenta and seasonal vegetables.
Matt's appetizer is roasted fennel and celery salad with roasted plums, shaved radish and lemon citrus vinaigrette. His entree is orecchiette pasta with sautéed mushrooms, corn, kale and leeks with lemon mascarpone cream.
Jon serves a grilled Ahi tuna with bean salad with cilantro soy vinaigrette for his appetizer. For his entree, he serves Arctic char with chanterelles, chickpeas and tomatoes with smoked paprika.

Charlie Palmer announces that Jonathan is the winner. Shereen announces that Danny has also earned a spot in the finale. Dennis and Matt are on the bottom and one of them is not going to the finale. Lisa announces that Matt is in and Dennis is out.

As Shereen said, why today? Not a good time to start screwing up. After making it through the season without being on the bottom, Matt certainly chose a bad time to lose his mojo. But I don't agree that Matt is overconfident. Unless he is a really good actor, he never seems like he was expecting to win. He always had an anxious look in his eye. And we never see him brag about his wins or behave in a cocky manner like Caity or Becky. So I think it was just a bad decision, not over-confidence.

Jonathan is on a roll. After hanging in the middle for most on the competition, he finally found his rhythm. Can he sustain it long enough to win?

I like Danny and I'm glad he's in but he seems very irratic these days. One day he has brilliant ideas and the next he blows it completely. He needs to pull it together, to take a bit more time to think through his ideas. I think he's a long shot for the win.

Did anyone else find the editing on the quickfire to be terrible? I felt that they cut the critique too short. Mark McEwan did not address both burgers for each chef. He just made a comment about one burger for each. With only 4 people left, couldn't they allow him enough time to discuss both burgers? Or what was the point of making them create two burgers?
And what was Danny thinking? With $5,000 on the line, it's not a good time to experiment with camel meat. And how can it be the main protein in your ultimate burger if you've never made it before? Though maybe he has eaten it before but never cooked it before?

One more quickfire next week and then on to the finale. And some familiar faces return.

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
Delete
  1. c
    C70 RE: chefhound Jun 4, 2013 06:06 AM

    I predict Jonathan 3rd, Danny 2nd, and Matt the winner.

    1 Reply
    1. re: C70
      y
      ylsf RE: C70 Jun 6, 2013 08:21 PM

      I say Matt the winner as well but Jonathan #2 .

      My initial gut reaction was that the airplane challenge was dumb too but I guess as a "top chef" you should be expected to be thrown into a variety of environments and sometimes with equipment you have never used before.

    2. cellophane_star RE: chefhound Jun 4, 2013 09:04 AM

      The camel burger.... wtf? I can't imagine that tasted good.

      Prediction: Jonathan & Matt in final two. Jonathan wins.

      4 Replies
      1. re: cellophane_star
        c
        cresyd RE: cellophane_star Jun 4, 2013 10:37 AM

        I live 1.5-2 hours away from a region where camel meat is available in local butchers. I think it says something that a) despite camels being available throughout the area - the meat has strictly stayed in that region and b) locals do not recommend it to visitors (either those from neighboring regions or international visitors) and it's more a curiosity for tourists driving by butcher shops.

        I wanted to believe that Danny had a solid plan for camel and I would have been fascinated had he achieved good results. But as soon as he said that he'd never had camel before - I knew he was doomed.

        1. re: cellophane_star
          hal2010 RE: cellophane_star Jun 4, 2013 06:10 PM

          Camel is a bit like moose - dry and gamey beef. The pork was probably a good idea to add some fat, but the fish roe sauce - who thought that was a good idea?

          Jonathan is growing on me. He has a wry sense of humour and more depth in cooking than you'd imagine from watching the brief clips of him in action

          1. re: hal2010
            c
            cresyd RE: hal2010 Jun 4, 2013 10:32 PM

            I too got the logic of adding the pork to add some fat - but there's also a muskiness to camel meat (unsure of moose having never had it) that makes it more assertive than venison or other very lean game meats. And getting that distinctiveness of camel to work for you wouldn't be something I'd gamble on getting just right the first go.

            1. re: cresyd
              c
              catroast RE: cresyd Jun 5, 2013 01:59 PM

              danny is kind of ridiculous. you can tell that he lives in a vacuum. he definitely does not belong there.

        2. Firegoat RE: chefhound Jun 4, 2013 09:40 AM

          Sad to see Dennis out after he won the quickfire.

          1. dbrodbeck RE: chefhound Jun 5, 2013 05:39 AM

            I was surprised when the 'resident judge' (I forget her name, and I have watched every episode of this show ever, that says something I think, but I digress....) said that pork was 'boring'. Not the specific pork dish, but pork itself. That struck me odd. Then again, perhaps I misunderstood and she was talking about one dish.

            2 Replies
            1. re: dbrodbeck
              cellophane_star RE: dbrodbeck Jun 5, 2013 01:10 PM

              Shereen Arazam

              That dish was boring so I assume the comment related to it and not all pork.

              1. re: cellophane_star
                hal2010 RE: cellophane_star Jun 8, 2013 07:14 PM

                I thought she said the same about chicken as well. I took it as a blanket statement on chicken breast and pork loin.

            2. s
              stgrove RE: chefhound Jun 5, 2013 11:38 PM

              I thought it was late in the game to do a "cook on an airplane" challenge. Would have rather had constraints that had to do with food or style rather than equipment.

              Also: Agreed on the camel. What was he thinking??

              1. e
                ElizabethS RE: chefhound Jun 6, 2013 02:27 PM

                Thanks Chefhound - guess we're down to the last episode soon.

                I think this was a lame episode to determine the final three - at this point we want to see some cooking "chops" and making a couple of hamburgers (really?) and screwing around with an oven on an airplane didn't seem to me to be the best way. The best product placement way, perhaps.

                Can't even guess at the final outcome ..... based on the season they'll likely have to cook an entire meal with the heat source from a Bic lighter.

                1. John E. RE: chefhound Jun 6, 2013 03:15 PM

                  I too thought this is quite late in the season to have gimmicks such as cooking on an airplane. Jonathan having experience with the ovens certainly gave him an edge, at least in having confidence in what he was doing.

                  When I think of an Air Canada 767 I don't think of Executive First International Service, I think of the Gimli Glider.

                  The best airline meal I ever ate was on an Air Moldova flight (the plane was a Russian made Yak-42). There was no food choice, but what we got was excellent. We got a charcuterie plate of sausage, cold roast pork, cheese, bread and red wine.

                  Show Hidden Posts