HOME > Chowhound > General Topics >


Mango Varieties - What NOT to Buy

Hi All -

A question I get all the time is...how do I know what mangoes to buy/not buy. Well, I'll tell you...Avoid Tommy Atkins mangoes; they are stringy/have fiber. For a full primer on the mango varieties available in US markets, please refer to the collection of blog posts contained in this link - I review every single one in detail. You'll never buy a bad mango again! :) I've attached a pic of a Kent mango box at Costco.




  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. How lovely to have a choice! In Chicago we mostly takes what we gets and likes it. Usually we have "big ones" vs "Manila mangoes" and variety isn't always on the label. One year in a pretty ratty African market I got mangoes that seemed to have no fiber at all---had the consistency of pudding. Seems to be a matter of chance here. But thanks for the link---I will watch for the good names.

    2 Replies
    1. re: Querencia

      Manila mangoes are typically marked as such, but the "big ones" are many times labeled as just "mangoes." Before you buy, ask the produce gal/guy at the store about the variety. You know what to do if they are Tommys. :)

      1. re: Querencia

        Querencia -
        Watch for the Alphonsos - especially in the markets on Devon. Short season, but we get them. Usually in mid summer,I think, the big honkin Mexican ones are at their peak, and it's really easy to pick out great ones, The Atualfos I've been getting have been pretty good right now.

      2. I bought some organic mangoes that were hard to the touch, much less ripe than I usually buy them. They took over a week to ripen. But they had black blotches inside them when I cut them. Is it better to buy mangoes closer to being ripe? Or what caused the black blotches inside?

        1 Reply
        1. re: elise h

          You probably got a bad batch of mangoes - perhaps they were afflicted with a disease called diplodia. The process you used (buy and let ripen) is normally 100% aok, so I wouldn't change your tactic. I've had the same thing happen occasionally and it's so frustrating when the mangoes look good on the outside and the inside is ruined! If this happens again, I would take them back to the store. They were doomed from the get go. You know a mango is ripe when they are soft to the touch and have little wrinkles beginning to form here and there on the skin.

        2. In Montreal we can get the big ones but I prefer the smaller, yellow ones that I think are labelled "Ataulfo". However, the last few times I've bought them, they have been inedibly sour, even when they looked and felt ripe. Has anyone else noticed this? My mom has noticed the same thing in Vancouver.

          1 Reply
          1. re: stak

            I've never had a sour ataulfo; I can't even imagine such a thing. Make sure they are soft and have little wrinkles before you cut into them - that's how you know they're ready. If the flavor is bad under those conditions, I'd return them.

          2. I dislike Tommy Atkins, too. The mango that I have been most impressed with here is the Mexican (not Chilean!) ataulfo.

            1. Hey Wendy - you wouldn't happen to know what Mangoes are most often grown in S. Florida. I lived there as a teen and our house was in a mango grove. They were the most sweet and easy to handle mangoes ever. Good even when green.-

              The fruit looked similar to pic six in your header, but the stem was brown or green, not red.

              2 Replies
              1. re: Sal Vanilla

                Hi Sal -

                I whipped out my trusted mango guide and boy - the mangoes you're thinking of could be any one of these: Ford, Irwin, Kent, Rosigold, Sunset, Smith, Z80, Torbert, or Zill. Florida has a TON of mango varieties, so the mangoes you're remembering so fondly could be something different altogether as well.

                1. re: MangoGal

                  Well at least I have a place to start. Thank you for looking it up!

              2. I'm Indian, and grew up in England, and the mango variety that my family has always loved is called an Alphonso. Unfortunately I have never seen those in the US (unless they are sold under a different name?). Would you happen to know whether they are available in the US? And if not, what variety might be closest as an alternative?

                4 Replies
                1. re: freelancer77

                  Indian markets around here get them in season -- and it's a short season and they often sell out quickly. I would try your local Indian grocer and ask if they can notify you when they come in, then you can buy a case.

                  1. re: freelancer77

                    You might try Savani Farms... The mail order market is not yet very robust for Alphonsos so do proceed with care when ordering online. I think, but am not 100% sure that organic, ripe Hadens might be a decent substitute.

                  2. What about green mangos like you'd use for indian mango pickle? Is that a special type of mango or just an unripe version of any mango?

                    3 Replies
                    1. re: tcamp

                      For green mangos for pickling or cooking, I go for the small size. I don't know what they are called, but they are about the size of a large lemon. I have tried the large ones a few times and find that their texture isn't always as nice, but they still work. I don't know the name of the kind I get, but they are always at the Indian grocery or multinational hypermarket near me.

                      1. re: luckyfatima

                        Thanks! These green ones you buy, are they firm or soft (ripe)?

                        1. re: tcamp

                          I only buy them when they are ripe or almost ripe and smell sweet and perfumey at the store, and I only have to let them ripen for 1-2 days or I can even eat them the same day. I have had bad experiences ripening at home with mangoes that may have been mishandled or chilled and then never get to the peak sweetness.

                    2. In Sri Lanka, the best mangoes I've ever had were a variety called karthakolomban. They're luscious, sweet and so flavourful. They're also more expensive than other varieties of mangoes, of course. My mother in law, though, has this variety of mango tree in her front yard, so when we're in Sri Lanka and they're in season, we always get these mangoes by the bucketload.

                      Unfortunately, I don't know what their English name would be, nor do I know their species name. But if you do manage to come across this variety, get some. They're so lovely! :)