Gramercy/W Village this Saturday @6PM
Looking for nice fish prep AND fresh (preferably) pasta around 14th St locale. @ $100 for 2, 1 with wine. Considered Paul & Jimmy's, Le Midi, Bocca
I've never heard of any of the restaurants you considered. What do you like about them? On another day of the week, I might suggest Crispo, but it will be excessively loud and crowded on a Saturday, and that's a problem you're likely to come across in many places. You could consider Malatesta.
Wife and I met at Da Andrea (35W/13th) one night and found it to be a great local spot. Very reasonable pricing in both food and wine.