HOME > Chowhound > Home Cooking >
Do you create unique foods? Tell us about it

What does lemon meringue pie taste like and is it as good as it sounds?

desserina May 10, 2013 05:09 PM

I haven't ever tasted a lemon meringue pie in my entire life. Crazy, right? But I'm planning to make it tomorrow for Mother's Day but I'm not sure if it's as good as everyone makes it sounds. So, what does it really taste like? And if you could give me an awesome recipe for that, I'll be really thankful! Be honest, what does it taste like?
(And what's the difference between lemon meringue pie and tart?) thanks!

  1. q
    Querencia May 10, 2013 09:11 PM

    The lemon filling should be rich and very lemony, while the crust is, well, crusty and the meringue is sweet. The three together are lovely. I assume your filling will use fresh lemon juice and grated lemon rind---lemon extract won't do the job.
    A tart can be almost anything with a crust and a filling. Lemon meringue pie definitely has a crust, lemon filling, and meringue (on top).

    1. k
      kitchengardengal May 10, 2013 09:22 PM


      This is a simple lemon meringue pie that has a filling made like a traditional key lime pie. It is tart and refreshing, and easy to make.

      1. greygarious May 10, 2013 09:30 PM

        The lemon part is essentially lemon curd. Crust is crust. Meringue tastes like marshmallow.

        1. j
          janniecooks May 11, 2013 12:41 AM

          We grew up eating lemon meringue pie. It is delicious! The filling should be tart, sweet and lemony, the meringue topping kind of tastes like marshmallows. Here's a link to a classic lemon meringue pie, in fact this recipe has changed little ( or not at all) over the decades, it is the one my mom used:


          The classic lemon meringue pie fililng is a cooked lemon pudding, not quite a lemon curd as the filling uses cornstarch. The cornstarch gives the filling a translucent quality, as opposed to the creaminess of a curd.

          A lemon meringue pie made like key lime pie, using sweetened condensed milk, is not a classic lemon meringue pie. If you want to know what the real thing tastes like, use the Betty Crocker recipe.

          BTW you can use your favorite pie crust recipe instead of BC's.

          As to the difference between a pie and a tart, here's a good roundup of the definitions:


          1. Ruthie789 May 11, 2013 04:14 AM

            Think of a good flaky pie crust, topped with a smooth lemon filling which is both sweet and tart and then topped with soft meringue. I think the difference in pie and tart is in the crust, the lemon tarts that I have had are made with a shortbread crust. As well the filling is a little different, the tarts are often made with lemon curd, which is thicker and more intense in lemon flavour and rich, the tarts do not usually have a soft meringue on them..

            1. Ruthie789 May 26, 2013 04:56 AM

              Just had a slice yesterday of lemon meringue pie. Mile high meringue, lovely lemon curd filling, and nice flaky pie crust. Delicious are you going to try it or have you since posting this thread?

              1. h
                Harters May 26, 2013 06:33 AM

                In my view, lemon meringue pie technically isnt a pie but a tart, as there's no pastry on top of the filling.

                It's a dessert I have loved since childhood although, then, my mother made it from a packet mix, rather than from original ingredients. In adulthood, when I was able to taste a properly made one, it was a revelation. It was no longer an overly sweet gloop but a well balanced mix of sharp lemon and sweet, but not overly sweet, meringue.

                It's been out of favour for some years but it's good to see it start to appear on restaurant menus again.

                1 Reply
                1. re: Harters
                  Ruthie789 May 26, 2013 09:23 AM

                  Me too for seeing it appear on menus again as well as other pies or tarts.

                Show Hidden Posts