Psst... We're working on the next generation of Chowhound! View >
HOME > Chowhound > New Jersey >
May 5, 2013 11:14 AM

Need an American restaurant

My MIL is coming up (this is NOT for Mother's Day) and I have run out of restaurants to take her to. She eats very plainly. She loved Charlie Brown's because it had what she wants a salad, piece of meat, baked potato and plain veggies.

Any suggestions? No Italian, Chinese, Thai, etc. LOL

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. What county or area are you in? NJ is 150 miles long...

    1 Reply
    1. re: lemarais

      Sorry, you are right and I hate when other people do that. Bergen or Passaic County would be great. Thanks and I hope there will be some suggestions.

      We were just thinking about maybe taking her to The Manor for a buffet , not the seafood buffet, as we could pick out different items that she would eat. No baked potato, but, really for one day it might be ok. LOL

    2. Old 76 House for one... excellent American food. In Tappan, just steps over the State line.

      Emerson Hotel, Emerson seems right in your category.

      What about Pub food? Lots of those.

      Seasons, in Washington Twp.

      1. Edit: I meant Bacari Grill in Wash Twp, and I also thought of the Stony Hill Inn in Hackensack.

        Palmer's Crossing in Tenafly.

        Joe's American in the GS Plaza.

        Glen Rock Inn, GR.

        Also, lots of Pubby-type places with the food you described above always available.

        1 Reply
        1. re: lemarais

          Lemaris, thanks for all the suggestions. I had put the Old 76 house as a possible when meeting a friend from New City, but, maybe this will be the time to check it out. I will keep the others in mind for the future as some of the them look promising.

          Thanks and still hope others will make suggestions as this is not a one time dinner as there will be many more in the future.

        2. How about one of the many diners in NJ? They certainly have the kind of food you're looking for and most of them now have a dining room with tables for a restaurant setting.

          2 Replies
          1. re: TomDel

            She LOVES diners, but, we HATE diners and they are the last place we want to eat. We wanted someplace nice not a noisy, busy diner. Thanks for the suggestion it's a good one, but, not for us.

          2. Nizza, you never answered about Pub food. There are dozens of these type places in NNJ and they all serve plain meat, plain veg, salad, and potato! Very preferable to a diner.

            2 Replies
            1. re: lemarais

              If it has a bar atmosphere that would not work, but, if they are a bar that has a separate area serving as a restaurant that would work. She would not want to eat in a bar. We go to a place in Brick that is called Craig's and I would call that a bar that has a restaurant and it's very good (at least the last time we were there and I think they have been sold). So, please make some suggestions and we will check them out. Thanks so much!

              1. re: nizza

                Ok, there are LOADS with a dining area separate from the bar:

                Paulies, Closter (Now called Cask 171)
                Fox & Hounds, Northvale
                Davey's Locker, Montvale
                Noonans, Pearl River
                Peppercorn's, Park Ridge
                Griffin's, Cresskill
                Smith Brothers, Ridgewood
                MacMurphy's, Ridgewood
                Village Green, Ridgewood

                Looks like you'll be busy dining out for the forseeable future!