2 BELLS for Gennaro's Tomato Pie
I went there about a month ago, and I thought the pie was excellent. It's very thin, probably even thinner than Lombardi's. Sauce was very good.
While they have a special take-out timing system, I think their pizza would be best enjoying eating it there. The thinness of it could make it soggy with a take home order (although I reheated leftovers and they were ok).