HOME > Chowhound > Vegetarian & Vegan >

Anyone ever try Vegan Jel by Natural Desserts?

CloggieGirl Apr 21, 2013 11:16 AM

Someone told me that 'Vegan Jel by Natural Desserts' is a better analog for gelatin than agar agar, etc because it reacts to heat similarly. Has anyone tried it?

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. Science Chick RE: CloggieGirl Apr 22, 2013 12:02 PM

    Pretty sure I tried it a few years ago (flavored versions) when DH had severe diverticulitis and was forced onto a liquid diet for days. I bought it at Whole Foods, as it was the only vegan gelatin dessert that they carried (looking at an image on Google, I'm pretty sure this was the brand I got). It was easy to prepare...similar to Jello of long ago. I have tried making agar desserts in the past using agar agar without success. I was never was able to get the agar flakes to dissolve properly...this from a gal used to making agar plates in the lab with NO PROBLEM!

    1. c
      CloggieGirl RE: CloggieGirl Apr 25, 2013 09:00 PM

      I made panna cotta with it tonight and it went well. Granted, I've never made panna cotta before, but it set well and it was pretty easy to use. My only issue was that the powder is kinda clumpy, but I've never used gelatin powder before, so I don't know if this is different.

      11 Replies
      1. re: CloggieGirl
        plantsvsme RE: CloggieGirl Apr 26, 2013 10:25 AM

        Can you taste it in the panna cotta? I mean, does the jel have a flavor of its own?

        1. re: plantsvsme
          CloggieGirl RE: plantsvsme Apr 27, 2013 09:08 PM

          Nope. They have flavored "jels" for a jello-o analog but this was unflavored.

          I wrote the review before I had eaten more than a quick taste from the top. The bottom wasn't as set. I haven't made panna cotta before and had to alter the recipe on the fly, so it may have been user error.

          1. re: CloggieGirl
            plantsvsme RE: CloggieGirl Apr 28, 2013 03:30 AM

            Hey, thanks for the followup. I haven't attempted anything gelled since a failed attempt at marshmallows. Maybe it's time.

            1. re: plantsvsme
              CloggieGirl RE: plantsvsme Apr 28, 2013 12:02 PM

              Yes. It's time! My next dessert attempt will be butterscotch pudding from scratch with soy milk, since I found the butterscotch flavoring. I tried making vanilla pudding once but it ended up a thicker version of creme anglaise. Not one to cry over spilled milk, I used it to dress up some store-bought desserts. However, I haven't attempted any puddings or custards since.

              1. re: CloggieGirl
                Science Chick RE: CloggieGirl May 17, 2013 04:43 AM

                Rather than use butterscotch flavoring, I highly recommend you make it yourself. Just brown sugar and butter melted together! If you are vegan (I'm ovo-lacto veg, so I use the butter), you could use vegan margarine. I've also found that almond milk or coconut milk gives far superior results over soymilk in puddings. Try this recipe for a vegan version....and don't use that artificial flavoring!

                1. re: Science Chick
                  CloggieGirl RE: Science Chick May 18, 2013 08:21 PM

                  The flavoring is consistent, distributes well and doesn't alter fat or liquid contents. Also, brown sugar and butter tastes like brown sugar and butter, not the same as butterscotch.

                  1. re: CloggieGirl
                    Science Chick RE: CloggieGirl May 19, 2013 01:12 PM

                    I'm glad you found a product you like working with. But I'm pretty sure that butterscotch *is* brown sugar, butter and cream cooked down.

                    What is it you perceive is missing that the flavoring contains? I was simply voicing my preference for real, natural butterscotch, as opposed to an artificial flavoring.

                    1. re: Science Chick
                      CloggieGirl RE: Science Chick May 20, 2013 05:26 PM

                      As the link you posted notes, there isn't an exact recipe for butterscotch out there, neither in content nor proportion. Since I had to guess at the proportions you were suggesting, similar combinations seem like brown sugar or caramel.

                      Also, my post was on whether people had used the gelling agent, not whether or not you approve of my using an 'artificial' flavor.

                      1. re: CloggieGirl
                        Science Chick RE: CloggieGirl May 21, 2013 03:36 PM

                        No offense intended.....and certainly no "disapproval". I was just voicing my preference and providing information in case you may not realize that it isn't difficult to make, if you are going to the trouble of making homemade pudding anyway. This is a public forum, and I usually welcome people's opinions on the general topic at hand....never know when you are going to get a useful piece of info ;).

                        I still am wondering what you find lacking in the sugar/butter concoctions that this flavoring has. Is there a sort of rum-like infusion? I've tasted butter-rums that are really yummy, and I was wondering if that was what you were going for.

                        1. re: Science Chick
                          JudiAU RE: Science Chick Jun 4, 2013 08:17 AM

                          Butterscotch "flavoring" is pretty nasty. If you are already using other substitutions, I suggest flavoring it naturally.

                          1. re: JudiAU
                            Science Chick RE: JudiAU Jun 4, 2013 09:18 AM

                            I agree, but if the OP likes the flavoring she has procured, that's certainly her call. It seems like there is some flavor note in the flavoring that she prefers that isn't in traditional butterscotch recipes, but I don't know what that is. C'mon, CloggieGirl, fill us in!!

      2. l
        Laura D. RE: CloggieGirl May 16, 2013 01:17 PM

        I just heard about this product last month and haven't had the chance to try it. I'd love to know if anyone has had success using it for marshmallows, as my attempts using agar agar and xanthan gum both failed. Thanks!

        8 Replies
        1. re: Laura D.
          youareabunny RE: Laura D. May 18, 2013 11:44 AM

          Did you try the MM recipes from this site http://blog.khymos.org/wp-content/200... ?

          I haven't... but lots of searching and I've yet to find any definitive vegetarian/vegan MM online recipe or discussion. Maybe it needs to be here :


          Can I nominate Marshmallows for Vegetarian recipe of the month? Year?

          1. re: youareabunny
            Laura D. RE: youareabunny May 20, 2013 11:31 AM

            I've tried the ones with xanthan gum but not the ones with agar (at least not this particular recipe...I made some kind of agar recipe years ago). The xanthan gum ones were okay, but wouldn't hold their shape.

            Thanks for the link, though!

            1. re: Laura D.
              youareabunny RE: Laura D. May 20, 2013 09:49 PM

              I've read some blogs that used the khymos recipes with success. It's presented so simple yet science-y that it just has to work! I've yet to delve in myself (I think I want a scale that measures to the tenths, first).

              1. re: youareabunny
                Laura D. RE: youareabunny May 21, 2013 12:28 PM

                I'm excited to try it. Thanks again for posting as a vegetarian/vegan marshmallow recipe that actually yields successful results is something I've been looking for for well over a decade. Thanks!

                1. re: Laura D.
                  youareabunny RE: Laura D. May 21, 2013 08:33 PM


                  Two blogs that have used the khymos XG marshmallows recipe with success! It seems a key difference is that they are set and possible stored in the refrigerator.

                  Turns out I've got XG in the cupboard so I will try it out soon. Please post when you do!!

                  1. re: youareabunny
                    Laura D. RE: youareabunny May 23, 2013 01:29 PM

                    I feel like I was having a senior moment during one of my last posts. So, the xanthan gum recipe that is on the khymos website is from Elizabeth Faulkner's book. That is actually the recipe I tried without success, though, in all fairness, it was more successful than previous attempts using agar and some other gelling agent. Let me know how yours turn out because I'd be willing to try the recipe again given that I have xanthan gum too. From what I remember, the spread of the marshmallows was annoying but tolerable. Even when storing them in thr fridge they tended to grow over time. But, the taste just wasn't what I wanted. The homemade marshmallow trend wasn't very popular when I stopped eating marshmallows, so perhaps I'm unsure what a good quality homemade marshmallow is supposed to taste like. But, I actually enjoy the spring/chew of an air-puffed "commercial" marshmallow and believe I was disappointed in how flat, dense, and non-airy the marshmallows from this recipe seemed to be. I hope they work for you, though. Keep us posted

                    1. re: Laura D.
                      plantsvsme RE: Laura D. May 23, 2013 02:34 PM

                      A long time ago I made Falkner's Demolition Desserts recipe for marshmallows, the one using xantham gum and egg whites. I guess you could say it turned out, but I didn't like the flavor at all.

                      It could it have been user error, though.

                      1. re: plantsvsme
                        Laura D. RE: plantsvsme May 24, 2013 09:55 AM

                        I don't remember being in love with the flavor either. I'm not sure what exactly I didn't like--I probably made them 3-4 years ago--but I didn't like the flavor enough to perfect the texture issues by making the recipe again.

        Show Hidden Posts