Restaurants near Falling Water, Mill Run, Laurel Highlands
It's been about 10 years since we visited. We stayed at the Nemacolin Resort for 2 nights and ate there both evenings, as well as at least 1 lunch. There are a range of restaurants there, running from high-end "continental" (might now be "American" or "farm-to-table" given trends in dining in the past 10 years) to simpler basic burger/sandwich/salad type restaurant. As I recall, the food was very acceptable. It was not the best meal I ever ate and not value-priced, but I'd return there if I found myself in the area.
We are in the area frequently due to my husband's whitewater habit. :)
You won't find too much fancy stuff out there. Primarily casual dining. As mentioned, the cafe at Falling Water is very nice. In Ohiopyle, there is the Falls City Pub http://www.fallscitypub.com and really good sandwiches (get them to go for a picnic or eat them overlooking the river on their deck) at Ohiopyle Bakery http://www.ohiopylebakery.com
For a nicer sit down experience, we always enjoy River's Edge Cafe in Confluence http://www.riversedgecafebnb.com/index.htm
If you enjoy lamb, there is Shepherd's Farm up Rt. 281 from Confluence. It is what it's name says it is, and they serve up a menu of primarily lamb based dishes. They also sell cuts of lamb from their freezer case. They sell ice cream as well. http://www.urbanspoon.com/r/252/11587... If we are there on a rainy weekend, I always make my husband drive out or our way so I can warm up with some lamb stew. The food is good even if the locale is a little odd and the restaurant extremely casual.
Of course, not too far away is the Nemacolin Resort. With high end accommodations and high end dining to match it. I have read very good reviews, but never been myself. There are multiple restaurants on site. The most well known is Lautrec.
We have stayed in the area several times over the past eight years, the last time being in 2011. The Stone House was the best restaurant early on. Our favorite motel is the National Trail Motel in Markleysburg, just east of Farmington. It is an updated, well-kept 1940s motel with hummingbirds visiting in the morning. For dinner in 2011, there were occasional thunderstorms, so we only went as far as Nemacolin Woodlands rather than to try the Stone House again and had a nice casual meal in its tavern. On an earlier trip, we did eat at an Italian restaurant in Uniontown -- average to pretty good. Sorry to hear it is now terrible.
I was in the area for the same reason a couple of years ago.
http://www.caileighs.com/ was the better of the 2 dinners we had. The other was the single worst meal I've ever had. It was an Italian restaurant in downtown Uniontown, and I'm repressing the name. If you see an Olive Garden, it would be far preferable. There is a good cafe at Fallingwater, but, if I remember correctly, only ice cream at Kentuck Knob.
There have been a number of inquiries for good food in the area, so if you find something good, please share. You may find interesting possibilities in West Virginia, which is very close.