HOME > Chowhound > Manhattan >
Do you create unique foods? Share your adventure

Favorites at Supper Restaurant (EV)

jaba Mar 22, 2013 09:41 AM

Going to Supper with a group in a couple weeks. Wanted to see what people's favorites are.


  1. p
    Pan Mar 24, 2013 04:26 AM

    Copied and pasted from their website:

    daily suppers

    FRIDAYS - Filet of Sole Oregonata $20.95
    Sole w/ breadcrumbs & lemon, served w/ steamed new potatoes & parsley

    Lemony, fresh, good. There's also a very good fish dish with a tomato-based sauce with olives. I can't find it on the online menu. It might have been a special.


    1/2 Roasted Giannone CHICKEN $18.95
    w/ wild fennel rosemary, roasted garlic & mashed potatoes

    Yeah, I wouldn't normally order roast chicken in a restaurant, but they do a really good job: Even the white meat is moist and flavorful, and they use just the right amount of rosemary to give it a good flavor. The skin is often perfectly crispy, too.

    daily soup

    From THURS to SAT - RIBOLLITA $11.95
    the Classic TUSCAN black Kale, vegetable, and bread Soup

    I don't have this too often, but like most of their other offerings, it has a clean, fresh taste.


    BRUSCHETTA $6.95
    Roasted garlic, olive oil & sea salt
    Freshly sautéed mushrooms

    Probably any of the crostini would be good, but I seldom have them because I usually eat low carbs, which also accounts for the lack of pastas on this list.


    Finely Sliced FENNEL, Shaved PIAVE cheese & arugula leaves $12.95

    I love fennel, and their fennel is very fresh and flavorful (seeing a theme here?).


    w/ olive oil, garlic & toasted almonds

    This is the best of the contorni, all of which are fine.

    You probably can't go wrong there. I remember liking the Golden Polenta, too, when I had it some time ago.

    Supper is by no means a great restaurant, but it is an honest, solid restaurant that uses good ingredients and is consistently good. Good, inexpensive wine list, too.

    3 Replies
    1. re: Pan
      jaba Mar 25, 2013 07:16 AM

      Thanks so much. We're going with a group of 10, and so their reasonably priced group menu was appealing to us. Unfortunately, our group is a little too small to book their private room.

      1. re: jaba
        Pan Mar 25, 2013 11:26 AM

        See if they can seat you in the back room. It's not private, but it is probably going to be more nearly so than the front.

        1. re: Pan
          jaba Mar 26, 2013 05:52 AM

          Will do - thanks.

    Show Hidden Posts