Psst... We're working on the next generation of Chowhound! View >
HOME > Chowhound > Cookware >
Mar 18, 2013 11:49 AM

Granite Tile Kitchen Countertops?

I am considering granite Tile countertops. Any advice?

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. The grout will become an eyesore and repository for all things growing. Cannot use for bread and pastry manufacture. Does not defrost food as quickly as a solid piece of granite.

    If budget is a factor, as it was for me, do a seperate portion in solid granite. The rest can be corian, formica, whatever. But please do not think you can get the tiles so close together that they will be the same as solid granite.

    1 Reply

      My mother had black granite tile countertops installed when she remodeled her kitchen 20 years ago. When we sold the house in November, they were in pristine shape. No eyesore grout and certainly no repository for all things growing.

      But she didn't bake bread or pastry very often.

      I think it was a cheap alternative to solid granite. There was significant countertop footage.

      Now, I have worn out faux woodgrain formica in my kitchen so her's looked pretty good to me.

    2. My son installed his own, for a fraction of the cost of solid granite. He said he would never do it again, they were such a pain to do.
      However, they look gorgeous and pristine, even the grout after 4 years.
      I have 6 year old laminate and I envy the shine and feel of the granite, even if it's just the large tiled ones. He also did his back splash in the same tile.

      1. We just remodeled and had granite tile counters and a solid piece for our island.
        The grout never showed and the grout lines weren't crumb catches. It is just as cold as solid.
        The overall look is granite.
        That said, I'm so incredibly glad we were able to get all solid granite for the new kitchen because it is gorgeous and just feels richer.
        I highly recommend solid if you can possibly afford it.

        1. I've used slab granite in the past two kitchens I've remodeled. Make certain you ask about the hardness of the granite options on your short list. Not all granite is equally hard. I was leaning toward White Fantasy (AKA Alpine White) but the sales rep at the marble fabricator told me it was a terrible choice for kitchen use -- too soft.

          When you look for granite, the varieties are labeled by price -- not hardness. Be sure to ask that crucial detail, too.

          I'm not a fan of tiles on counter tops, either kitchen or vanities for the reason others have mentioned.

          12 Replies
          1. re: Indy 67

            We installed solid black granite. Looks great but it is sooooo expensive. I don't understand why a piece of a mountain should be so expensive.

            1. re: kagemusha49

              Agree. We are having a hard time justifying the cost of granite slab. It's not that we can't afford it, we just think it's overpriced. Also, if it breaks or cracks we would possibly have to replace the whole slab....and we've seen it happen.

              1. re: sherrywho

                What are you considering instead? Granite tiles? Solid surface? We're face-lifting our kitchen and can't decide what counters to use. I've ordered edge-grain maple for our new island, but can't decide what to use for the rest. Right now we're leaning towards some of the new laminates. I agree about the cost of slab granite, it's hard to justify. I'd love to know your thought processes as you decide.

                1. re: DuffyH

                  The cost of installing slab granite can vary a great deal. I suggest going to several sources and in particular, go to places that sell, cut and install.
                  Our first designer firm had us pick out granite and then told us what it would cost installed. Long story short, we put granite in our whole kitchen for what they would have charged us for higher-end granite on just our island.

                  1. re: DuffyH

                    We are considering granite tiles. I have always liked the look of tile (it gives character), but my husband had a bad experience with small tiles with light grout many years ago. However, he does like the larger, dark tiles with very small, dark grout, lines. They can even bull-nose the edges.
                    There are some beautiful laminates out there. In fact, we built a house about 8 years ago and used it. I have struggled with using it again, but we think the granite would be better for resale value where we live. We aren't planning to sell, but you just never know.

                    1. re: sherrywho

                      Granite tiles will be better for resale over laminate, but not over a solid slab. I'm with you on tile, I like the classic look it gives. But, it also comes at a price to get this look right. When we did our last kitchen, we went with a nice tile. And it ended up costing as much as we were quoted for granite.

                      1. re: mike0989

                        We have received quotes for both, not including backsplash with slab, and the tile is a little more than half (and that includes tile backsplash)
                        Also, if we go slab we will have to Sheetrock before installing backsplash because we were told that when they tear out current laminate it will probably leave some gouges in the wall.

                        1. re: sherrywho

                          The tile we used was one of Walker Zanger's. We could have saved quite a bit with some thing like Dahl Tile. We could easily of spent twice as much as well. Tile prices run all over the map. You also have to remember that it is the trim prices that kill you. They are priced by the piece, not sqft.

                          1. re: mike0989

                            Right. If we go the tile route, it's more to bullnose the edges, done by the granite company, but that cost has been figured in. We haven't decided on a pattern....looking at several

                      2. re: sherrywho

                        We're not looking to sell for another 10 years or so, and while I prefer springing for at least a solid surface, the dude doesn't, but hates the idea of any kind of tile, even granite. In our neighborhood, the streetscape suggests quality cabs/counters, but inside, almost all are builder's grade. So we don't have to worry about getting good resale; simply replacing our undersized island and adding nicer laminate will get us good money. I just ordered a dozen or so large laminate samples, maybe I'll get on board with it. I've got to admit, there's some interesting stuff out there.

                        1. re: DuffyH

                          My son's first house was redone in laminate after he looked at granite prices. But, as you say, the neighborhood really didn't dictate granite for the purpose of resale. In his newer house, he installed granite, this neighborhood is considerably more upscale and I think granite would be expected.

                          As someone mentioned up thread, there is a lot of variation in granite prices. Certianly the more common grades are less than half the cost or the more exotic grades. You also pay a premium for the thicker 3 cm stone than the 2 cm stone. Also a good portion of the cost of solid granite is the edge finish and how many and what finish is used on the holes for sinks, etc. For example a sink hole with a rough edge for a drop in sink is far less expensive than a polished edge for an undermount sink. Also the edge treatment, round over being one of the least expensive, to triple waterfall being one of the most expensive, can greatly effect your overall cost.

                2. re: Indy 67

                  Thanks for reminding me to double check the hardness.

                3. Wait for a good deal and get a solid slab. Too many seems spoil the granite look and will definitely not help value should you decide to sell.