BYO recos for 8 in Montclair
I need some good suggestions for an upscale/casual (great food/not to stuffy) BYO restaurant that can accommodate our group. We are all 40+ friends who don't get together as much as we like, so although we won't be drunk and loud, we will be talking and laughing a lot;-)
Have to agree that Corso 98 has excellent food, but unless the night I was there was an anomaly, I don't feel like it has a festive vibe to it, which the OP seemed to want. Then again, a boisterous group of 8 could make it festive...! Food there is terrific--no question there--but also more expensive than some of the other places posted.
Samba (Brazilian--I have a post on this board w/details)
I'll also throw out the idea of Stamna Greek Taverna in Bloomfield, on the Montclair border.
All of these match what you're looking for...the catch will be getting the reservation locked down (hint: ASAP)!
Any cuisine preference? I'll throw some options out:
Salute - Italian - place is deafening so you can laugh to your heart's content
Fin - Seafood - sister restaurant to Salute
Aozora - sushi/japanese
Costanera - Peruvian
Mesob - Ethiopian
Some other recos may be a bit tight for 8 - Blu/Next Door, Samba (Brazilian)