Red Wine and Sushi?
There is a new article by Robert Parker where he drinks three bottles of CDP with sushi at Naka in NYC...raving about the combo.
I'm very suspect of this opinion...mainly because I really don't share RMP's palate when it comes to food, or wine for that matter (though I do think he's the best critic - his description are spot on...the same can't be said for his ratings).
Any case, I've only enjoyed sake/beer with sushi. White wine and Champagne is OK, if you don't drink the other two.
What are others thoughts on this?
IMHO rules about what color of wine goes with what protein are meant to be broken. For starters it depends on what type of red wine and what type of fish. I think salmon can handle red wine better than white fish. Also, I think that raw fish holds up better against red wine than cooked fish - something to do with texture and mouth feel. JMHO
I stick w/ Viognier or Riesling or pilsner beer. I could only imagine a very oily fish standing up to a red wine. Maybe tempura?
I've never tried this combination and it doesn't on the surface seem that palatable but I'll keep an open mind until trying it. Should also preface that I'm not a major fan of japanese cuisine in general and sushi in particular.
As others have suggested, it's very likely that the species of fish is a factor...
Also if some of the seafood was raw ... the rawness, and perhaps especially the FATTINESS of some raw fish I think could be important factors.
Is there any more specificity than just "sushi" in the article?
Parker has said for many years that CdP counterbalances soy sauce, and that's the reason for his pairing it with sushi.
I'm not agreeing or disagreeing, just reporting.
Parker is certainly entitled to his opinion... I've long been a big fan of CduP, and less long a sushi fan. My palate does not "sing" when contemplating pairing the two. In fact, my reaction is "Yuck." I'll not likely be trying that combination. With my sushi, sake or sparkling wine are what I prefer.
We drink Burgundy (both red and white) with sushi all the time. I find that Pinot Noir from the more northern climes like the Alexander Valley or Oregon go well too.
Sushi is not my cup of tea.
Nevertheless I would choose a straightforward white - such as Sauvignon Blanc, Alsatian Riesling, Pinot Blanc or Chablis.