A little closer to NJ, and about the best beer selection you will find is Porters Pub in Easton. It's not a brewery, so the selection includes lots of great imports. When I went to college it was THE place to go. But I'm relatively old (pre-Breworks, but not by much). Website makes it look exactly as I remember with the same extensive beer list, but I can't vouch for the food anymore. Yelp reviews are still pretty good, for the most part.
Hmmm... wonder if the mugs are still there from almost 20 yrs. ago....