Psst... We're working on the next generation of Chowhound! View >
HOME > Chowhound > BBQ, Smoking, & Grilling >
Feb 12, 2013 08:02 PM


I just bought a Smokin-it smoker and was wondering if any chowhounders out there do their own smoked foods?

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. Check forum bradley
    You'll get wonderful recipes and everything you need to put your smoker to good use.

    6 Replies
    1. re: TDEL

      Yes, the Bradley smoker forum has everything you need to know. I've worked with pro competition bbq teams smoking meats, and helped put together huge bbq events. I have had all types of smokers over the years, but once I got a Bradley electric smoker 5-6 years ago, my game went up dramatically. I learned how to hot rod my Bradley on the bradley forum. Put in a second heating element, convection fan, digital computer controller, etc.

      I cold smoke everything you can imagine in the winter, including various cheeses, and hot smoke all year round. I even smoke salt and sugar, which I use all the time.

      1. re: JMF

        Electric smokers are just too fancy to me. I'm sure the food is great, but my garage houses a 1963 Greg Noll longboard and a 1930 Buick coupe. Moreover, there are four guitars in my collection - none electric. I may be prematurely crusty, but I'd rather have vodka in my martini or drink chardonnay with a steak than use an electric smoker.

        1. re: MGZ

          I used to be a traditionalist in many things, especially smoking food, but when you try something new and it's easier, better, higher quality, more consistent, etc., then you realize that maybe doing things the traditional way isn't worth it anymore. I do think that learning the traditional ways and becoming skilled with them is good. But I can accomplish so many things, so easily and accurately with the bradley smoker, that I would never go back to staying up all night, reeking of smoke, burnt hands, etc. from a manual smoker. But then, I have other things in my life where i do things the traditional way. I just don't have time and energy to do so in everything, and I choose which things to do which way.

          1. re: JMF

            In a sense, I'm really just making fun of myself. I'm afraid there are just certain things that I have a preference for the process over the product. As noted, making barbecue, for me, is one of those things. I have little doubt I would love what comes out of the Bradley, but I would also greatly miss waking up before dawn to start the fire, chopping wood, and being tethered to the backyard and a can of beer all day.

            1. re: MGZ

              Yeah, but c'mon, VODKA in your martini?!

        2. re: JMF

          + another for Bradley's forum.

          I would lean on it even if I DIDN'T own their product.

      2. Yup. I smoke year-round on my BGE. Hence: Big Green Matt.

        What about it?

        1. I use a Brinkmann offset that I have modified by moving the thermometer to about the cooking surface, lowering the bottom of the chimney, and spot welding a few gaps between the firebox and the cooking chamber.

          I'm an old school barbecue purist though and believe it's art and not science that is involved. I'll wax a bit and note that the word is spelled with a "c" not a "q" (never, ever abbreviated) and that those who make it (if only for financial reasons) should have an axe (and/or a maul), a chainsaw, at least one chimney, briquettes as well as lump, and at least three kinds of wood around. The final point is essential. I firmly believe that wood affects flavor more than the rub or the mop (though neither of those should be underestimated).

          If, however, you're talking cold smoking salmon and such, I shall politely withdraw my comments and await those of others more knowledgable.

          9 Replies
          1. re: MGZ

            What MGZ said, except sometimes I abbreviate and use 'cue.

            I generally use lump in my WSM.

            1. re: chileheadmike

              I like the longer lasting heat from Kingsford briquettes to make sure I can keep the fire going in the offset. I do prefer lump, but using some of the briquettes permits me to have a longer window when it comes to adding logs.

              I've posted on other threads about what wood for what protein, but for the sake of the OP gettin' started, I'd note that hickory and mesquite are rather unforgiving. Fruit woods are a good way to go with pork when learning. Oversmoking can be a real problem when beginning to make "'cue".

              1. re: MGZ

                That was going to be my one tip:
                Novices (at least me anyway) tend to oversmoke.

                The window between not enough and too much is usually quite wide, but realize all smoke all the time is not necessarily a good thing.

                1. re: MGZ

                  Kingsford has an off smell, at least to me. I've totally gotten away from it. If I'm doing a 12-14 hour cook, I will have to add charcoal one time. It's not that hard.

                  I stay far away from mesquite. I just don't like it. Hickory can overpower but I like it a lot. I use apple, pecan, cherry etc for different meats.

                  The most important thing I tell people just getting started is to keep your vent wide open. Control your heat with intakes. This will allow the fire to burn clean and avoid bitter creosote buildup on the meat. Also, I use 3 large chunks of wood only. That's enough. You don't want a bunch of smoke chugging out of the the thing. Little whips of blue smoke=good 'cue.

                  Sorry for the abbreviation.

                  1. re: chileheadmike

                    I like the Kingsford for about two thirds of the first chimney. I agree that it can produce an off taste if used too much, but it does give me an extra window of time for replacing the first few logs.

                    I think your vent tip is a very good instruction.

                    1. re: chileheadmike

                      Just curious, do you mean briquettes in general or Kingsford in particular?

                      As a side, I tend to use briquettes (Kingsford, Royal Oak, or Brand X...anything but matchlight stuff) as a slow-burn, low-temp fuel source augmented by lump (usually maple since its the easiest to get in my neck of the woods) and wood chips or chunks (usually apple or cherry or alder or hickory, depending).

                      1. re: porker

                        Kingsford. I use lump, usually Cowboy lump but I've used the generic store brand with good results.

                        Never tried Royal Oak.

                        1. re: chileheadmike

                          I actually much prefer Royal Oak briquettes but have difficulty finding them locally:

                          1. re: MGZ

                            I got sucked in last year when coming across Kingsford mesquite charcoal briquettes; I thought "wow, charcoal made from mesquite" (mesquite is a rare bird in southern Quebec...) and bought a bag.
                            I opened it intending to grill steaks on the weber. The briquettes looked pretty standard with fine, brown specks. A look at the bag clinched it....charcoal WITH mesquite...
                            Geeze, it could be 1/10 of 1% mesquite and still be labelled "with mesquite".
                            Caveat emptor Kingsford MFers.

              2. Yep, I smoke with a Cookshack Ameroque smoker. Wonderful but kind of expensive, made in Ponka city Oaklahoma.

                2 Replies
                1. re: malibumike

                  We have an electric smoker. Looks like a mini frig. Hubby loves it. He spent many years with his Weber (which we still have) smoking many things. It's just so time consuming w/ Weber compared to electric smoker.

                  We've smoked brisket, pork butt, chicken, cornish hens, portobello's - all excellent.

                  1. re: chloebell

                    You're probably talking about a Bradley smoker. They are great.

                2. I use an old 22.5" Weber Grill that I found in the trash with a Cajun Bandit (

                  My favorite bbq/smoker board is the BBQ Brethren (


                  Best tip that I can give you right now... St. Patrick's Day is coming up so buy a bunch of Corned Beef to make a quick pastrami since they will go on sale for a fraction of the price. You will need to soak in water for a few days to get a lot of the salt out. Check out some forums for rub & smoking instructions.

                  Other favorites are pulled pork (obviously), country ribs, pork necks (seriously, if you get meaty ones, these come out great- I smoke them just like I do the ribs). Also, pork belly is great in the smoker since the fat gets to the perfect consistency.

                  3 Replies
                  1. re: eatanddestroy

                    I agree about the corned beef. Here's some of my previous notes on the subject:


                    1. re: eatanddestroy

                      Huh? Pardon a Goyishe question, but I thought these were two different cuts---brisket for CB, navel for pastrami.

                      1. re: mwhitmore

                        Absolutely correct if you're going by the book- but hell, you can give virtually any cut the corned beef treatment.