Unique Regional Foods in Boston
Hey all -
Just doing some personal research here. I was wondering what are some uniquely Boston foods. Obviously baked beans and clam chowder, but is there anything Boston offers that is distinct from the umbrella of New England food? Is there a distinctive style of pizza? A distinctive hot dog or sandwich? For instance, Chicago has its triad of deep dish pizza, Italian beef sandwiches, and Chicago hot dogs. Does Boston have anything like this?
-
ChInese Pie....kind of like shepard's pie....browned hamburg topped with corn then mashed potatoes.
›7 Replies-
-
re: Allstonian
I grew up in Lowell, just north of Boston and it was in a regular rotation in our home growing up in the 70s It was apparently popular with railroad workers and in school cafeterias.
I haven't seen in in any other areas I've lived in....California and NJ.
It is still in rotation with my home these days.
-
re: missylrn
Pâté chinois is a popular dish in French Canada. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/P%C3%A2t...
Interesting connection to New England.
-
-
-
It's weird...the bottom line of all the "unique Boston foods" discussions that I've seen here and elsewhere is that there ain't much. Lots of quirky RI foods that are still going strong (disclaimer: native RIer here) but Boston, not so much. Why is that, or is that my own skewed perception? Where did the dilution occur? Or did it never occur and that's just the way it is?
›13 Replies-
re: digga
I think it's also worth noting that a lot of the "typical Boston foods" have kind of gone extinct e.g., baked beans in pots, brown bread baked in coffee cans, boiled dinner, etc.
Maybe partly because Boston is a large, cosmopolitan city with many prominent ethnic enclaves, e.g., Vietnamese, Cape Verdean, Haitian, and partly because the prior mentioned foods have simply gone out of favor.
Also, another thing to consider is that it seems that many of these quirky RI foods tend to be represented at specific small towns, many times even at specific establishments (e.g., Dynamites/Torpedo sandwiches of Woonsocket, and Iggy's Dough Boys of Warwick).
So, maybe the official food of Boston should be a Speed dog or a bahn mi? :)
-
re: Prav
There's a sizable Laotian-Cambodian population in RI. I should be more knowledgable about what is uniquely RI/US from those cuisines (for example, I believe "nime chow" is uniquely RI/US?). We also have Cape Verdean (more SE Mass, though), Liberian and Portuguese communities. As you wisely said, Prav, maybe those should be considered the new indigenous regional foods? Same goes for Boston? Yum!
-
-
re: existential_crisis
A hot dog from Boston Speed Dog, recently renamed (unfortunately) to Boston Super Dog, a truck vendor originally based in Newmarket Square, currently on hiatus due to health problems. The original owner and his product were legendary on Chowhound Boston; his successor still has a lot of loyal fans.
The main event is a big all-beef natural-casing wiener, marinated and grilled, topped with housemade condiments and chili in a good roll. I'm a fan, but it's more the specialty of an individual local purveyor than the region.
-
-
-
-
Rhode Island has pizza strips, which are baked dough with sauce. Thats it. No cheese. Why bother?
Also, "stuffies", which are stuffed quahogs, or hard shell clams. At some places, the actual presence of shellfish is iffy. Just like the traditional RI clamcake, which is too often fried dough with "essence of clam".
The, of course, there's the RI clam chowder, without milk/cream.
›4 Replies -
Although the origin may or may not be of racist connotation, most ice cream shops in this part still refer to chocolate sprinkles as "jimmies".
›2 Replies-
re: phatchris
As for the name "jimmies", I coulda sworn I read a story either on the Brighams menu or website LONG ago that gave the credit of the name to a little girl who's mon wanted to make her son a "special treat" (can't remember for what occasion) & decided to grate a chocolate bar over a dish of ice cream. When the little girl saw this, she wanted it & her mom told her, "No - that's Jimmy's" -meaning it was for her son Jimmy. The next day, the little girl asked for her ice cream with "jimmies" on it - thus, legend has it, jimmies were born.
-
re: southie_chick
I just did a little research and found the answer to that question from the Just Born company who, according to the following link, first made them. They were named after Jimmy Bartholomew, the employee that first made them.
http://www.snopes.com/language/offens...
-
-
-
-
Great answers so far- since moving out of the Boston area, there are some Boston and New England foods that i definitely miss. I agree that lobster rolls (in the grilled split-top New England style bun), clam chowder, and whole belly fried clams are distinctly New England, and while both are often attempted outside New England, it somehow doesn't taste as good. Just my opinion...maybe it's all in my head.
Another Chinese food that is found in the Boston metro area- "Lobster Sauce"- the brown pork sauce that originated from cooking with chopped up whole lobsters, but you can order it without the lobster in American-Chinese restaurants in the Boston metro area. Looks like slop, but I love it and can't find it anywhere in the Southern US.
While we're on the topic, another food I miss from New England- cider donuts. Ok, not Boston-originated, and more New England-y, but why don't they make these elsewhere?
›4 Replies-
-
re: lucywellington
i ate lobster sauce growing up in Chicago; my guess is that Chinese-American dishes have some regional variation from SF to Chi-town to NYC.
One thing that i discovered in Boston - I am sure that i have mentioned this earlier - is there a more delicious scallop than those from nantucket? and delicious when raw, better when seared.
-
-
-
In the course of my peripatetic life I have only had fiddlehead ferns in the Boston area, do they count?
›3 Replies -
As not a native new englander that had to cook traditional new england food every year for my job I had to learn what these were,it was very educational and fun to make.these are foods that say new england to me: chow mein sandwich, pot roast dinner, fried clams,johnny cakes, whoopie pies,oysters, clam chowder,toll house cookies,clam bakes, moxie, fluffanutters, cod,grapenut pudding,frappes, neccos,parker house rolls,hash,succotash, and coffee milk
›6 Replies-
-
re: existential_crisis
Southern cooks do seem to have claimed succotash as their own in the modern revival of the dish, but the word "succotash" comes from the Narragansett language, which was spoken throughout southern New England. Succotash was cooked by the Wampanoags before the English came to New England.
-
re: existential_crisis
There are interesting connections between southern cuisine and southeastern New England because of the Triangle Trade (Newport, Providence and Bristol (part of MA for most of the colonial period, then swapped by MA to RI for some other territory) - rum, molasses and slaves and all that - and then those links led to other links among elites during the Gilded Age. Thus, you see jonny cakes and the use of white cornmeal in this part of NE, as in the South.
-
re: Karl S
I always thought jonnycakes were derived from New England native cuisine.
-
re: MC Slim JB
Here's a bit of background on Johnny Cakes from Kenyons Grist Mill
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
From Boston north to Maine, what most people know as milkshakes are called frappes (pronounced fraps). In RI, milkshakes are called cabinets.
A milkshake in these parts is just milk and syrup, no ice cream.
›5 Replies-
-
-
re: Bob W
It has been a very long time since I've seen that distinction made in these parts. When ew first moved here in the early 80s that was exactly the conundrum we had. These day the only time I see the word frappe used are at places that are trying to be somewhat old timey (e.g. Bartleys) and I'm sure they'd understand what you meant if you asked for a milkshake.
-
-
-
-
-
re: hotoynoodle
The origin story I've heard on the chow mein sandwich points to the Fall River area.
-
-
re: MC Slim JB
yeah, im with mcslim on this .
The Original Hoo-Mee Chow Mein Mix from the Oriental Chow Mein company (42 Eighth st. Fall River, Mass) still exists and you can buy at local Shaws/Star Market kind of suprmarkets in the Fall River/Attleboro band of SE Mass.
This is an essential item for the chow mein sandwich, which i believe is the same thing, Evelyns in Tiverton has a lobster version of this sandwich.
Proprietary packaged gravy mix over included wheat flour Hoo-Mee noodles, better with onion, celery, and bean sprouts and added protein.
one caveat: if you do have the chance to buy Hoo-Mee, check the "best buy" date impressed on the top of the box, if the sit around for a while they acquire a musty/ off taste when you mix the gravy part into the noodle part.
-
re: hyde
The chow mein sandwich would not exist without the Oriental Chow Mein Company and its Hoo Mee mix. For a brief period (I think 2009) they closed down due to a fire and all the regional Chinese restaurants either stopped offering the chow mein sandwich (and other chow mein specialties) or subbed an inferior product which was not at all popular among the local aficionados. Fortunately, the company and the sandwich rebounded and continue to thrive.
Another relatively obscure Fall River specialty is the hot cheese sandwich -- a thick, grainy, emulsified cheddar cheese sauce served on a squooshy hamburger bun, often enjoyed with a ladle of coney sauce. And then there's, of course, the chorico & chips grinder which can be found all over New Bedford and Fall River as well.
-
-
-
-
re: kimfair1
To be fair, both "chorizo" and "chouriço" are akin to the English word "sausage" in that they encompass a lot of different styles of product, not just the smoked, paprika-heavy cured or fresh pork sausages we tend to see most commonly here.
-
re: MC Slim JB
I was just talking about this last night I grew up in a mexican household and moved to Boston about 20 years ago.
I was quite confused and frustrated that a lot of people (waitstaff and even cooks) will serve the Portuguese chouriço and really try to tell me that it is Mexican chorizo.I gave up years ago thinking people know the difference. I also gave up looking for the mexican chorizo of my youth in local stores and just stared to develop my own recipe.
-
re: l0b0SKI
and add to the variety, the Spanish-from-Spain chorizo...very different from Mexican chorizo. I wonder as well if Brazlilian chourico is different from that from Cape Verde, which I understand is the predominant origin of most from-Portugal-Portuguese speakers in the Boston area.
so you never found a source in Boston for mexican chorizo? If you did, please share!
-
re: l0b0SKI
I buy the Mexican chorizo of my youth at BJs. It's not entirely the same -- there's less fat and none of the ingredients I recall from back in the day like "pork salivary glands" (not kidding) -- but it was delicious last Friday morning scrambled with some eggs and wrapped in a flour tortilla toasted on the gas hob.
-
-
re: MC Slim JB
True, but what I grew up eating (chourico) isn't much like chorizo in taste or even texture, with chourico being more chunky for lack of a better term. I love them both, but similarity in names aside, they are two very different sausages. I would be interested in seeing how different Brazilian chourico is from the type found around here, which is definitely more Cape Verdean in style.
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
Oh, here's another old-time Boston-y thing: Receiving dinner rolls with your Chinese take-out order.
Also, (unrelated), we have a dish called American Chop Suey - which is basically macaroni, tomato sauce, and ground beef, called "chili mac" elsewhere (and "goulash", where I grew up, in Michigan).
›8 Replies-
re: Prav
Weirdly, my family here in Boston also called it "goulash" - it was one of my grandmother's specialties, and she was originally from Buffalo, but I have no idea where she picked up that particular name for the dish. Jenny Ondioline, who grew up in Texas and Colorado, also knew it as "goulash."
I knew what "regular" chop suey was when I was a child, and had heard the term "American chop suey," but I was quite surprised when I entered junior high in Boston and discovered via the school cafeteria that American chop suey = goulash!
And yes, dinner rolls with your Chinese takeout is a very old-fashioned and very Bostonian thing. At Golden Dragon, my neighborhood Chinese restaurant in my childhood (where Jo Jo Taipei is now), they also served bread and butter at the table in the restaurant.
-
re: Prav
Growing up in Medford, we always called this "hamburg casserole". It wasn't until I was in Illinois for grad school that I heard the name "American Chop Suey".
This thread is my first encounter with the term "goulash" for this dish. That might be even odder to me than the name I first ran into in Columbus: "Johnny Marzetti" (sp?)
-
re: brandywiner
I knew the stuff as Johnny Marzetti, growing up in Columbus. It's not exactly the same as American Chop Suey -- Johnny Marzetti's baked as a casserole with a layer of cheese on top and eaten in slices, most of the time.
The name came from its time as a signature dish at Marzetti's restaurant in Columbus.
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
re: Allstonian
Not sure where sr44 went to elementary school, but they had it at my elementary school in the late 60's early 70's in New Bedford, MA. Then again, coffee was such an important part of my families life, that I was a regular coffee drinker by age 8, and a black coffee drinker by age 15. 35 years later, still drinking it black.
-
-
-
-
-
re: sr44
Durgin Park serves coffee jello and while I'm not a fan of Durgin Park, they do serve a nice coffee jello. When I went to order it the waiter tried to talk me into a different dessert. Growing up my grandmother often made coffee jello and we had it served with evaporated milk so maybe it was nostalgia but I really enjoyed it
-
-
-
Boston-style Italian subs tend to be served cold with lettuce, tomato and pickles, sometimes hots, but never hot. Never had subs like that other than here, but it may not be Boston-specific.
›6 Replies-
-
re: existential_crisis
In my area ( just north of Boston), an Italian sub has capicola, mortadella, genoa salami, provolone. Toppings are onions, pickles, tomatoes and hot peppers,topped with salt, pepper and oil. There are variations, of course, but this was the most usual. And they are never cooked. If a sub is cooked, it is called a grinder. Grinders are usually sold in Greek pizza joints (ie: "House of Pizza" restaurants)"
-
-
-
re: catsmeow
born and bred in ny/nj i have never had a good eggroll here and can count on one hand the decent pizza options.
please, please, skip the pizza tangent before it devolves into a regina/santarpio debate. that "greek pizza" is a crime against humanity.
i'll add lobster rolls served on toasted buttered hot dog rolls.
-
-
-
re: Prav
While it is true that some f the worst pizza around comes from the "XXXTown House of Pizza" which are cardboard flavorless crust pan pizzas, it is NOT true that all Greek pizza is bad pizza. In fact, if you are ever on the Cape in Harwich, try George's Pizza. A classic Greek pan pizza with a crispy undercrust with a nice flavorful chew, a spicy cooked sauce, and quality cheese and toppings. One of the best pizzas you will ever have.
-
-
re: hotoynoodle
So are Boston's lobster rolls distinctive because of being served on toasted buttered rolls?
The more people hate on the Greek style or bar pizza, the more intrigued I am with it. Is it the predominant style of pizza in Boston? When I first moved to Calgary, I was disgusted at first with the pizza (which turned out to be Greek style) but I eventually fell in love with it. I imagine that Greek style pizza probably varies from city to city where it is predominant.
Oh, and is it true that the Greek-style pizza uses white cheddar instead of mozza?
-
-
re: Boston_Otter
at one point there was an outpost here of an english pizza chain(!) called ruggles. they put cheddar on the pizza. i went once. blech.
the other distinction about the greek pizza is the cardboardy consistency of the dough. awful stuff, although now i am realizing the op isn't called "delicious unique regional foods." :)
those areas where fried clam strips are the norm -- where do the bellies go, i wonder?
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
re: existential_crisis
"Greek" pizza is what you'll find at a lot of Greek-owned pizza/sub/gyro shops around town here. It's a doughy crust cooked in a pan coated with a lot of olive oil, so it sort of fries the crust. Everything else about it (toppings, cheese, sauce) is pretty standard. It's not a pizza style to get very nostalgic about, I'll put it that way :)
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
re: existential_crisis
Yes I meant the full belly fried clam supposedly invented by chubby woodman on the north shore, you can still go there to get them, although there are others that seem to be able to do it better and cheaper that aren't open year round.
-
-
-
re: existential_crisis
But are they soft-shell clams? I believe you have them up north, but use of that particular species is something that distinguishes our fried clams.
-
-
-
-
I'm originally from elsewhere. When I think of something I had never had before I moved here it would be the "New England Style" hot dog bun (only brown on top) and the hot dogs with natural casings so that they snap when you bite them. Maine's red snappers being the most extreme version. However, I can't vouch that one can't find these elsewhere.
Other things that are hard to find elsewhere on restaurant menus: steak tips and baked cod/scrod.























