Psst... We're working on the next generation of Chowhound! View >
HOME > Chowhound > Home Cooking >
Feb 5, 2013 07:39 PM

Doughnuts? More like deep fried biscuits!

I recently tried to make this doughnut recipe from Bon Appetit I followed the recipe exactly but found the dough to be very dry and stiff. When fried, it yielded these tough biscuity things. Gross.

Any idea what could have gone wrong or why the dough was so dry? I've never made doughnuts before but imagine the dough should be like when i've made choux. I'm inclined to think the amount of milk is off or something.

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. I hate recipes that you volume rather than weight.

    I'm guessing you used too much flour. It's impossible to know how much "3 1/2 cups all-purpose flour" exactly is, as the recipe states.

    Another possible culprit is that your yeast is dead, but you said your dough was dry, so I don't think this is the likely culprit.

    1. The recipe says the dough should be sticky, so if yours was very dry and stiff it was not as meant to be. It's often a good idea to hold back a bit of the flour when mixing doughs. Flour strengths vary, humidity varies, the person measuring varies... it's more important to know what the consistency of the dough should be than to follow the recipe exactly.

      Did you use apple juice or milk? Did they rise until doubled? What kind of flour did you use?

      1. My yeast is def. good. I am using king author flour. I think I'll try again tomorrow but add the flour in additions and stop when the dough is sticky / what seems more reasonable. Thanks for the help!

        3 Replies
        1. re: Nigel1985

          I don't know if this is the problem, but KA all-purpose flour is higher protein than, say, Gold Medal. It's not as high protein as a bread flour, it's somewhere between standard supermarket flour and bread flour. I use KA for bread baking and find that I need to add a little extra water to get the correct consistency.

          1. re: rockycat

            I agree. I am making another batch and doubled the milk. The dough is much softer and sticker. Gonna fry them in a bit. If they still turn out so dense I'll try adding another 1/2 cup of milk.

            1. re: Nigel1985

              The recipe doesn't have milk, so am a bit confused. You said you followed it "exactly." Is the link the recipe you are using? The one with the grapefruit jelly?

        2. It looks like there isn't enough liquid in the recipe.
          When making bread recipes, I never follow the recipe exactly. Like others have mentioned, the amount of flour in any given recipe can vary depending on the humidity, the flour. I go by feel. When I make doughnuts, I make the dough just stiff enough to roll out, cut, and hold its shape, barely. It's a wet dough.