Psst... We're working on the next generation of Chowhound! View >
HOME > Chowhound > Home Cooking >
Jan 28, 2013 08:05 AM

Where shall (kitchen) wisdom be found?

Looking back on thirty+ years of agonizingly slow improvement in kitchen results, I recognize the supremacy of Technique over Recipe. It ain't just, "chop A, dice B, saute, add D, pinches of E, F and G...." It's When? and How high? and How much? and much, much more. Out of my 400+ cookbooks, I have two that go into those issues: Mitchell Davis's "Kitchen Sense" and Rick Moonen's Fish Without A Doubt". I also learn from How2heroes videos. Sometimes Took a cooking class from Rick Moonen once, and found him extraordinarily generous in this arena; the link below is to a video of Rick making/explaining NE Clam Chowder. Question: Where do you find "Wisdom"?

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. >>Looking back on thirty+ years of agonizingly slow improvement in kitchen results, I recognize the supremacy of Technique over Recipe<<

    Totally agree.

    >>Where do you find "Wisdom"?<<

    Mom, and experience and trial-and-error.

    1. I've been making notes in the back of cookbooks for years whenever I happened on a 'tip'. When a dish turned to be crap or great I make notes. I got into 'Escoffier' a few years ago. Funny thing happened. I discovered whenever I followed his recipes absolutely religiously all my dishes turned out to be excellent. Go figure. LOL
      Now I 'SV' a lot and finish with Escoffier sauces. Pretty beautiful and tasty dishes are the result. IMO the sauces are the star and the meats etc. are there to support them.

      1. I absolutely agree with technique over recipe. I experiment and observe the results and try to learn from them. I see so much handwringing here, try it and see what happens is my motto.

        Your linked video has naught to do with clam chowder.

        12 Replies
          1. re: dickgrub

            A nice clam soup. NOT chowder, IMO. My grandmother is rolling in her grave.

            1. re: sr44

              What would Granny add or change? If the answer begins with or contains "tomatoes", I'm out. Grandpa, (B: Boston, 1882) often said of so-called Manhattan Clam Chowder, "That's just tomato soup with clams in it".

              1. re: dickgrub

                If it were tomatoes, she'd be revolving faster.

                Salt pork, not bacon. NO celery, leeks, carrots. Horrors, wine! NO flour or cream. NO herbs. Onions softened in the rendered pork fat (the pork bits reserved for later). Clam juice added, and cubed potatoes cooked in it. Clams and sufficient milk (whole) to make the chowder, and salt pork returned. Thickening: common crackers, softened in more milk. I think it was a Maine model of clam chowder. (p.s. she was born in Boston in 1885)

              2. re: sr44

                I suppose it's technically a chowder, because it has a potato and milk in it. But one small potato in a pot that size does not a chowder make, in my opinion. And the rest of it so nouvelle (wine?), it's disgusting. This is foodie chowder, not traditional chowder, in my opinion.

                1. re: GH1618

                  Except, it's cream, not milk. I do think whole milk was richer back in the day, but it certainly wasn't heavy cream. Yup, foodie chowder.

                  1. re: sr44

                    Beard calls for light cream in his chowder.

                      1. re: sr44

                        and he was born in Portland, Oregon...

                        1. re: sunshine842

                          That's right. It's Northwest style chowder, which is similar to New England chowder. Cream distinguishes it from the traditional recipe. There are many improvements to be found in Northwest cuisine.

            2. Joy of Cooking
              Better Homes and Gardens
              Betty Crocker (for cakes)
              Craig Claibornes Southern Cooking, for his mom's good sense and damn good recipes.
              Maida Heatter (again, for baking)
              Laurie Colwin. Her two cookbooks are Take with you when the earthquake hits gems.
              Marian Cunningham.
              And of course, Julia.
              and some more, but these are just off the top of my head

              1 Reply
              1. re: RosePearl

                RP: Your comment, " take with you when the earthquake hits" had me rush to Amazon to order two Colwins, of whom I had never heard. Much thanks.

              2. <Where do you find "Wisdom"?>

                Between instruction (from books or video) and practice, but more on the side of practice. To be more specifically, from the mistakes during the practice. Trial and errors. Every so called mistake is my learning experience where my wisdom is refined.