HOME > Chowhound > Manhattan >

Discussion

Del Posto was really good, but I'm still not quite convinced.

  • 8

Photos in context are here: http://www.donuts4dinner.com/2013/01/...

When I wrote in my Torrisi Italian Specialties review that Italian food in NYC is terrible, bland, and uninspired, the good people of Chowhound went crazy, telling me that I didn’t know what I was talking about if I hadn’t been to Del Posto, the Joe Bastianich/Lidia Bastianich/Mario Batali behemoth with one Michelin star.

So in the name of knowing what I’m talking about, my boyfriend took me there for the $165, eight-course Captain’s Menu for a tasting of Chef Mark Ladner’s finest. Our first impression was that the place was gigantic and cavernous, decorated in dark, heavy fabrics that made it seem like the perfect setting for cigar smoking, back door dealing, and hiding mistresses from wives. The staff was friendly despite the ominous feel, we were seated at the most perfect banquette that allowed for plenty of people-watching, and our server treated me like I was the first blogger to have ever entered the place once she saw my camera. Likewise, the sommelier kept talking up the special bottles he was opening up for us and even introduced us to this new contraption called a corovan or coravan or cordovan that separates the cork from the wine bottle without puncturing it so that the wine can be enjoyed without fully opening the bottle; he said that it was invented by a heart surgeon and that Del Posto is the only restaurant on the East coast to have one. Ooh-la-la.

Now, on to the food!

• amuse

Cauliflower and leek vellutata in the little cups
Bacalao (cod) on a very crispy cracker
Chicken salad tea sandwich with chicken cooked for five hours, which made all other chicken salad sandwiches seem classless

• wine: Ca’ Del Bosco, Franciacorta, Erbusco

secondi assaggi (second samples):

• tuna wrapped in daikon, jalapeno, sea salt

• chickpea, black truffle, lemon

Like eating truffle hummus.

• fried mozzarella with tomato powder

• bread

A beautifully diverse bread basket that was replaced halfway through the meal when it became cold. Our server also switched out our napkins at that point, which I loved.

• lardo and sweet cream butter

For the bread. In case you thought it was just for spooning.

• wine: Paolo Bea “Arboreus” 2008 Umbria

• insalata di verdue, robiola, swiss chard, sour apple

They call this vegetable salad brutte ma buone–ugly but good. I didn’t even think it was ugly, but it certainly was good. The sugary carrot cake crumble under this was almost candy-like and really worked with the super-acidic apple cider vinaigrette. The dressing was so sour that I felt like I was choking when I encountered too much of it resting in a little cup formed by the curve of an onion slice, in fact. But hey, what’s a little choking amongst friends?

• wine: Gravner Ribolla Gialla “Anfora” 2004 Friuli

• fluke, chestnut due, shallots, watercress, truffles, trumpet mushrooms

The many crunchy elements–watercress, water chestnuts, black trumpet mushrooms–made the dish what it was. I’ve never cared at all for watercress, but it was welcome and almost necessary here to add just a touch of freshness. This was also the first time in a long time that I’ve thought truffles really added something more than just an extra $50 to the bill. All in all, I think this was my favourite of the night, and I say this as someone who still totally thinks of fish as poo-drinkers.

• wine: Aldo Conterno Barolo 2007 Piemonte

• tortello puzzone, taleggio dolce, black truffle butter

I think the name of this dish literally translates to stinky tortello, which is entirely correct. I’m not used to such a strong cheese in my ravioli, so the juxtaposition between the creeeeeamy, buuuuuttery texture of the cheese gushing from the broken tortello and its pungent taste was intense. In a good way.

• wine: Scarzello Barbera d’Alba 2008 Piemonte

• orecchiette, lamb neck ragu, orange carrots, toasted rye

My boyfriend thought this was a little too one-note, especially following a dish that really was quite simple, but I actually found it complex with plenty of depth of flavor. The pasta was of course cooked perfectly, and then the spicy lamb sauce so complemented the sweet dollops of carrot puree and the dark, rich rye crumble.

• wine: Maine Beer Co. “Peeper” American Ale, Portland, ME

• cacciucco (fish soup), diver scallops carpaccio, garlic bread soup

A plate of assorted sea creatures arrived, a broth was poured over them, and the result was a seafood soup with tons of garlic and super-bright, super-acidic tomato flavor. The tender seafood was complimented so nicely by the citrusy marjoram in the broth.

• wine: Fontodi ‘Vigna del Sorbo’ Chianti Classico Riserva 2000 Toscana

• veal and beef, cosa viene prima, potato torta, soft spinach, Calabrian spicy tongue stew

A veal medallion surrounded by beef deckle was placed in front of each of us, and then a ragu of tongue was added tableside. I was more excited about this dish than any of the others because of its familiar beefiness, but the lack of seasoning on it was a real letdown; both the veal and potato torta seemed to be entirely lacking salt. However, the deckle (fatty brisket) was perfectly seasoned and perfectly crusted, and the tongue stew was both tender and spicy. Cosa viene prima translates to “what comes first”, which I took as a play on the age-old question of which came first, the chicken or the egg–or in this case, the baby veal or the adult beef.

• wine: Chartreuse

I had never had Chartreuse before this. It’s a monk-made herbal liquor from France, and it made my mouth pucker worse than any lemon ever could. It’s interesting. And beautiful. And vegetal.

• sfera di caprino (sphere of Caprino cheese), celery, fig agrodolce, celery sorbetto

This was like a cheesecake rolled in thick, crispy breadcrumbs, paired with the most celery-flavored and refreshing sorbet and a fig dried as sweet as a raisin.

• wine: Marion Valpolicella Superiore 2007 Veneto

• warmed La Tur, charred bread, chocolate

This was Del Posto’s take on s’mores, and while it seemed simplistic to me at first, I thought it was a really nice take on a cheese course in the end. The La Tur was really funky, but the sweetness of the chocolate balanced it so nicely, and their flavors were so complimentary. I always love the difference in flavor between raw cheese and melted, so I was pleased to find this gave me an idea of both states of a La Tur.

• wine: “10 Anni,” Marsala Superiore Riserva, Marco de Bartoli NV

• butterscotch semifreddo, melon agrumata (citrus), crumbled sbrisolona (cake

)

This semifreddo was like a thick, rich, brightly sweet dulce de leche with a crunchy crumble. I thought the fruits on the side seemed like such a weird, uncomplimentary addition, but I actually loved them–particularly the melon. And I’m not a person who cares about melon.

• torta di zucca (pumpkin pie), candied pumpkin, sage gelato

My boyfriend got the raw end of the deal with this course. Instead of the semifreddo, he was served this pumpkin cake that was a little too dry, a little too simple, a little too not-at-all pumpkin-flavored. The sage gelato, on the other hand, was so overwhelmingly sage-y that I didn’t care much for it, either. It sure was pretty, though.

• chocolate sculpture

To end the meal, our server brought a drawer full of small bites, this chocolate sculpture, a cookie jar, and a plate with a giant almond cookie on it. She held the cookie up to show how delicate it was while my boyfriend and I secretly thought, “Why are you touching our cookie?” She explained to us that this type of cookie is commonly passed around the table after a family meal so each person can take a piece for dessert. The Del Posto version of this involved our server smashing the cookie down on top of the cookie jar so that cookie chunks went all over the table. It was quite the spectacle. And quite the delicious, crisp cookie.

My rating: 4 out of 5 stars

Del Posto was solid on all fronts, from food to decor to service. It’s clear why the restaurant has a Michelin star, and it’s clear that the staff are working hard to make it a destination, a place where you can expect a special bottle of wine to be opened for your special dinner. If this was an up and coming restaurant, I’d bump it up half a star, but I expected a little more wow from the food of the Bastianiches and Batali; I didn’t feel creative boundaries being pushed here, and I realize that’s probably because the restaurant is known amongst out-of-towners who don’t want any surprises, just traditionally good food. The better choice for dinner here for us probably would have been the five-course menu, which focuses more on pasta–the thing Del Posto is doing so well. I think this is the sort of place you only have to go to once to get the full experience, and I’m happy to have had mine.

 
 
 
 
  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
Delete
Posting Guidelines | FAQs | Feedback
Cancel
  1. Thanks for the excellent report and beautiful photos. I find your photos to be the finest of any blog. So many of my favorite restaurants are among your 5 donuts. Please keep up your great reports.

    4 Replies
    1. re: ellenost

      Ditto…

      1. re: calf

        Thank you so much!

      2. re: ellenost

        I'm going to print out twenty-two copies of this comment and hang it all around my apartment for all of the times I feel down on myself about my photography. Officially in love with you.

        1. re: plumpdumpling

          :-)

      3. I like Del Posto, but I find the food at Babbo - even at the lower price point - superior. It's just a bit gutsier, heartier. I'd eat at Babbo any day over DP.

        1 Reply
        1. re: sgordon

          That's always been my thought on Del Posto, too - it was fine but didn't jump out at me, particularly at that price point. It's comforting to know I'm not alone in that assessment (given that I'm also not that crazy about EMP and feel like I'm alone in the wilderness on that one). I loved the Del Posto space but the food was "good" but felt somewhat uninspired.

        2. Delposto is a great lunch option. Less crowded, very civilized. Good service. They raised the price of the prix fixe awhile ago but it is still very good value.

          A very recent dinner at Babbo was less than inspriring. Our pastas at Delposto were definitely superior. Pastas at a recent dinner at Marea also were superior.