Suggestions for Rehearsal Dinner in Tinton Falls area?
Lincroft Inn/Lincroft NJ has a nice private room and entrance. For a banquet dinner (steak, chicken, fish) it's ok. DO NOT GO for ala carte' dining it's terrible.
MJ's/Tinton Falls is moderately priced although it is more a pizza style place you could probably have one floor to yourself for something like that. Very nice setting.
Luigi's Tavern / Eddies Place has a small dining room they would let you book. Pizza & Good Italian food but mostly a bar type setting.
Picolo Italia/Oakhurst Excellent food......price TBD according to what you want.
Bogarts/Tinton Falls: Has a small back private room. Moderately priced with every thing on the menu from Sushi(decent) to Turkey Club to Osso Bucco.
Mooses Tavern/Tinton Falls: New place it's an old Charlie Browns with a very similar menu. They have a private dining room on the 2nd floor. Too new to give a fair rating on the food....I'll say average type place.
There is also as mentioned Portofino's (Mooses, Portofino's, MJ's are all at the same intersection)
Basil T's as mentioned is in Red Bank if you want to travel to Red Bank there are a million + 1 places that can be added. The above are all within 5 mins of where you are staying. Bogarts is literally 1/4 away on same street.