Psst... We're working on the next generation of Chowhound! View >
HOME > Chowhound > Manhattan >
Jan 4, 2013 08:16 AM

Am I the only one who thinks Per Se's dessert course is getting less attractive?

I have been enjoying Per Se's sophisticated desserts a lot, but I notice their dessert course at the Salon is getting less and less exciting these days.

From left to right:
Apr., 2012
May., 2012
Jul., 2012
Sep., 2012

My last dessert course experience at the Salon in Sep. 2012 was the least appealing. I am not saying it was bad, but there was no Per Se-ish sophisticated touch at all.

I am wondering if it was just one of those unlucky days, or is it the trend that Per Se's dessert course is getting less and less exciting? Anyone has some input?

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. Great comparison… the first three columns have a lot of visual appeal, and in contrast the last one is looks downright staid. But in the end it's all about taste.

    I've tried it once and it was a mix of highs and interesting-but-I-don't-love-it. Based on that I wouldn't recommend it to anyone unless they are really hardcore about desserts and willing to risk forgettable dishes. They are better off ordering a la carte. For the restaurant it may just be a demand issue, most people aren't there to do a degustation of sugar, and so it's never easy to justify so much effort on this one offering.

    I do wonder if there's been a sort of dessert void in the city, now that all the famous innovators (Laiskonis, Shawn Gawle, Alex Stupak) have moved on… Time to do some homework and find out what's out there.

    Momofuku Ssam Bar just came out with a chevre sorbet that is really terrific, light, balanced, and tasty. I was really impressed. Thematically it's like EMP's cheesecake dessert, but was so good and didn't feel derivative or anything like that.

    1 Reply
    1. re: calf

      Wow.. I should try that sorbet at Momofuku Ssam Bar sooner or later. Thanks for the info! :)

    2. You may be the only one who goes there frequently enough to notice.

      I am not a fan of the Salon. I just don't think Keller's food translates to an a la carte style, and the sofa/reaching for the table thing irritated me to no end. Regarding dessert, the last time I was there, none of the dessert choices sounded interesting to me, and I ended up with a creme brulee which was pretty much just a creme brulee.