HOME > Chowhound > Home Cooking >

Whole lamb: spit roast or roast on grill (or cut up and grill?)

oneironaut Dec 29, 2012 04:00 PM

Hi, all. Planning an outdoor festive summer wedding, and the menu is smoked brisket and lamb. I've long wanted to spit roast a lamb, or roast it whole in the ground, but I've also been hearing from experienced hands that this is not great for lamb (although it is traditional), because different parts of the lamb are best cooked to different temperatures--they suggest getting a whole lamb butchered, and roasting the cuts individually.

Does anyone have any experience, or suggestions, they can share? Thanks!

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. f
    fourunder RE: oneironaut Dec 29, 2012 04:41 PM

    ..... because different parts of the lamb are best cooked to different temperatures-

    That's probably true for the Chop/Loin/ Sirloinn area, but the rest of the lamb is better suited for a long and slow roast. whenever I see segment on television where they spit roast a whole lamb or pig, it makes me jealous. If the hand you select knows what he is doing, I would vote for Whole Spit Roasted first, then grilled in sections. The Whole spit Roast definitely will turn some heads.

    I've been to many Italian Weddings where a Whole Pig or Suckling Pig are offered at Reception.....I make a dash for the belly and the cheek if possible.

    2 Replies
    1. re: fourunder
      oneironaut RE: fourunder Dec 29, 2012 05:10 PM

      I guess that since I enjoy many cuts of lamb medium rare (chops, leg), I was wondering if they would be as tasty cooked through on the spit.

      1. re: oneironaut
        fourunder RE: oneironaut Dec 29, 2012 05:16 PM

        Yes....you can also do two and grill the second one...they are not that big.

    2. j
      Joebob RE: oneironaut Dec 29, 2012 07:18 PM

      My vote is for spit roast, Greek style. Remove the tender parts first.

      1 Reply
      1. re: Joebob
        oneironaut RE: Joebob Dec 30, 2012 09:40 AM

        So, butcher out the ribs and the tenderloin, and then spit roast the legs and the shoulders?

      2. b
        Brandon Nelson RE: oneironaut Dec 29, 2012 09:45 PM

        I would consider these details;

        The number of people you are cooking for. Beyond that the number that will actually eat lamb. A whole animal, or even a half for that matter might be overkill.

        Of the 4 quarters of a split lamb the leg and the shoulder are best suited to a long slow roast on a spit. The rib and the loin are better suited to brief high heat cooking such as pan frying, broiling, or a quick trip across the grill. They are also more expensive cuts.

        Knowing those details should help you plan out the cooking of the lamb at your event.

        3 Replies
        1. re: Brandon Nelson
          oneironaut RE: Brandon Nelson Dec 30, 2012 09:41 AM

          I'll ask you the same question I did Joebob...butcher out the ribs and the tenderloin, and then spit roast the legs and the shoulders?

          1. re: oneironaut
            INDIANRIVERFL RE: oneironaut Dec 30, 2012 10:10 AM

            Having roasted numerous whole animals, start wih two fires at the ends, and work your way towards the middle. I would recommend removing the head before presentation. Just like a whole fish, many people are grossed out when they can easly recognise what they are eating.

            1. re: oneironaut
              Brandon Nelson RE: oneironaut Dec 30, 2012 09:43 PM

              That suggestion is entirely feasible, however it does require some knowledge and proper tools; a butchers saw, splitting the carcass, the ability to find the 7th lumbar vertabrae, and the skill to make a transverse cut thru 12 ribs and remove the breast, as well as splitting the saddle into a loin and rib portion.

              Buying a square cut shoulder or a whole leg is easier, the cuts are cheaper, and the process doesn't require a novice to table break a whole carcass, and these quarters will yield the best results when spit roasted.

              It all comes down to your sense of adventure, and resources. If you have enough mouths to eat a whole animal great, otherwise it might be a waste.

              If you are going to pay to have the animal butchered it makes more economic sense to simply buy the cuts that suit the occasion.

              I hope that helps some.

          2. t
            travelerjjm RE: oneironaut Dec 30, 2012 10:12 AM

            The spit would be very nice and rustic looking. I had some great spit roast lamb this past summer that was fantastic. I know the tenderloin and some other parts would be especially good cooked medium rare on the grill, but for a larger crowd, I'd probably borrow a Caja China and do the lamb in there.

            Show Hidden Posts