HOME > Chowhound > Greater Boston Area >
What have you made lately? Share your food adventure
TELL US

Dumpling Cafe overview

e
eatinjeff Dec 29, 2012 02:07 PM

This place is said to have some of the best XLB in town, and 'hounds that I admire also speak highly their live-tank seafood preparations. Their menu is long and compelling, and for this rundown I'm going to branch out from their well-established strengths and see what they've got in the wheelhouse.

And I have to be honest: everything about this restaurant says "awesome" *except* most of the food, which--for me--is usually in the "pretty decent" range or slightly below. I'll walk you through some menu items I've tried and the grade they've received once wiggling down my gizzard.

(Note: earplugs can't hurt if you're going at off-peak hours: they often play deafening, frantic K-Pop to ensure quickened eating, indigestion and feelings of helplessness.)

Braised Yellow Fish with Brown Sauce
Grade: D
I see this scrawny creature in my dreams and wet the bed.

Simmered Crab with Silk Noodles Hot Pot
Grade: B+
One of their better efforts: crab parts lazing on some mild, brown-flavored silk noodles with minced garlic and veg.

Roast Marinated Bean Curd
Grade: C+
"Roast" in what sense? This is simply that tofurkey loaf from the fridge section at the C-Mart across the street, sliced and garnished with green onions.

Grilled Shrimp Skewers
Grade: B+
A pleasant impaled-prawn appetizer

Sauteed Noodles with Seafood
Grade: C
Mushy linguini with too much pepper. For shame!

Grilled Anchovies Taiwan Style
Grade: B+
My favorite appetizer there; three slender grilled fish, no frills and no sauce. Very nice!

Seafood Noodles Soup
Grade: B-
A good amount of fresh seafood, but too much pepper in the broth! They've committed this same indecency twice on this dish, so I can no longer extend my mercy.

Steamed Dumpling with Vegetables
Grade: B
Serviceable pouches of green stuff.

Ma Po Tofu
Grade: B+
Surprisingly good. No pork, just wiggly tofu and mildly numbing sauce.

Oyster Tofu Soup
Grade: B
Oysters, green onions and tofu cubes in an unsalted broth; long forgotten before I even finished it, but pleasant enough (lots of oysters, at least!).

Hot and Sour Fish Soup
Grade: C+
Not even remotely hot, or sour (save for the single tomato chunk bobbing awkwardly against some squid scraps). Maybe they just didn't think I could handle the "real" thing, whatever it is? Pah! My parents were calling me "Hot and Sour" before... wait, I lost my train of thought.

Sauteed Squid with Pickled Mustard Greens
Grade: A-
A very respectable version of this pungent, bilious favorite.

Flounder with Sweet and Sour Sauce
Grade: D+
Breading with take-out-packet sauce.

Szechuan Style Steamed Flounder
Grade: A-
The best thing I've had there, though it pales next to the same dish at the place up the street (hint: its blessed name rhymes with Caiwan Tafe). And, of course, next to the several variations on this dish at the marvelous Thailand [sic!] Cafe in Central-- more on that restaurant in a later post...

Though my overall experience at this place has been in the B/B- range, I'm open to suggestions on their (fairly epic) menu! They do some things well, so...

  1. beetlebug Dec 31, 2012 09:49 AM

    I've never understood the CH love for Dumpling Cafe. The dish quality has always been a bit inconsistent. My preference has always been towards Taiwan Cafe and Gourmet Dumpling.

    1. g
      gourmaniac Dec 31, 2012 09:48 AM

      Thanks. I'm appreciating your posts lately. I agree that their entrees are not as good as Taiwan Cafe. I generally get the XLBs and the Taiwanese chicken leg off the grill menu. When I've ordered main dishes, I'm been disappointed.

      1. s
        ScotchandSirloin Dec 30, 2012 11:00 AM

        MC and others would disagree with me, but, other than the XLB which are great, I enjoy the food at Taiwan Cafe and Gourmet Dumpling house much more than the food at Dumpling Cafe. I took my foodie aunt to each and she agrees (not that that means anything and we got served some past razor clams at Dumpling Cafe that day, which probably clouded the judgement). I don't think you are off-base here. I think Dumpling Cafe is 1000X better than your generic suburban Chinese restaurant, but not the best place in Chinatown.

        1. Luther Dec 29, 2012 03:36 PM

          I've only been once and it was like 1am so I wasn't sure if they have a different kitchen staff at that hour... but out of about 10 dishes I got a similar impression. I was pretty surprised that it gets so much good coverage on CH.

          Show Hidden Posts