The website 'Slice' is NYC based. Any world class in pizza in NY will invariably show up on their site. If it's not on slice, and Pomodori isn't showing up in a search, then I think it's safe to say that it isn't exceptional.
That being said, shmoogle seems to give it good reviews.
I don't know how reliable shmoogle is, though. Both Yelp and Urbanspoon have done me incredibly wrong on the pizza front.
If you are looking for top notch kosher pizza in Brooklyn I can talk to a friend who is vastly knowledgeable on this subject.