Chicken Roasted Unevenly
After 2 hours at 350 degrees my five lb chicken had an internal (breast) temp of 160. But at the drumstick joint it was still clearly undercooked, and when I poked the themometer into the other breast it was 150 degrees. I put the bird back in and checked internal temp every 15 minutes or so. It took another hour or more to reach 170 internally. By that time, the whole thing was dried out and overcooked. Questions:
1. Is my oven thermometer sitting on the oven rack in the wrong place? Should it be somehow in the roasting pan, with the chicken?
2. My oven has a so-called speed bake feature, which turns on a fan at the back of the oven. Would this help for more uniform cooking?
3. What am I doing wrong? This was a trial run for roasting a much bigger turkey on Christmas!
Was your chicken sitting inside a recessed pan that wasn't preheated, breast-up?
Roasting a chicken inside a roasting pan (or another kind with raised sides) tends to insulate any meat sitting below the sides of the pan. If that is your problem, there are many possible fixes. You can use a rack to set the chicken above the sides of the pan. You can cook the chicken in a skillet preheated on the stove to give the bottom of the bird a head start. You can start with the dark meat up and then flip partway through cooking. You can spatchcock. You can cook on a mostly flat cookie sheet. I could go on.
As for one breast being more cooked than the other, many ovens aren't entirely even in their heat, so rotating the bird during cooking can be a good idea.
Also, 170 is on the high side for chicken, especially breast meat. I feel pretty comfortable removing the bird at 160. Or 155 if the chicken was cooked in a hotter oven. Residual heat will bring the temp to 165 during resting.
When you measure the temperature, make sure you don't hit any bones. Bones are much hotter than the center of the meat.
Was the bird trussed?
If you keep opening the oven door, you'll keep losing heat from the oven = longer cooking time. I like to use a remote meat probe. Just stick the probe into the thickest part of the breast, close the door and walk away. It beeps when the meat reaches the right temperature.
1. I think the oven thermometer is alright. Don't have to move it closer to the pan.
2. Yes, that will definitely speed things up and creates a more even cooking.
3. I use Alton Brown's method to roast turkey every single year and have come out perfectly done. Blast it at 500F for the first 30mins. Turn it down to 350F until the breast reaches 161F. Let it rest for at least 30mins. We cooked a 10lb turkey in less than 3 hours this year.
I start my chickens in a 425º oven for 20 minutes, then turn the oven down to 375. I cook two at once and put them on a rack in a roasting pan. My chickens are usually 4.5 pounds each. After 45 minutes of roasting, I start basting them every 20 minutes or so.
Also, I start with my chickens at room temperature. In the winter, I will prep my chickens at 12:30pm for a 6 pm dinner. I put the chickens in the oven at 4 pm and pull them out between 5:35 and 5:45 to rest before carving. I rotate the chickens once during cooking.
Good luck to you!